- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BRepPreDiff for learning transferable geometric and topological representations from large-scale unlabeled CAD/B-Rep data. The method employs a topology-aware B-Rep graph encoder with edge-update attention to model the relationships between adjacent faces and shared edges. During pre-training, Gaussian noise at different levels is applied to face and edge geometric features, and the model is jointly trained for noise prediction, clean-feature reconstruction, attribute prediction, and adjacency-relation prediction. The authors also introduce BLEND, a dataset containing approximately 18K B-Rep models, and evaluate the proposed method on multiple segmentation and classification tasks.
Critical strengths
- The problem is practically meaningful, as it aims to exploit large-scale unlabeled CAD data to alleviate the scarcity of face-level semantic annotations in downstream tasks.
- The edge-update attention mechanism explicitly models the interactions among faces, edges, and adjacent faces, making the architecture well aligned with the structural characteristics of B-Rep models.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological contribution of diffusion-based representation learning is not sufficiently established. The pre-training procedure is more closely related to a multi-level denoising autoencoder with timestep conditioning, noise prediction, and auxiliary multi-task supervision. Although the method adopts a diffusion-style noise schedule, it does not perform reverse diffusion or use a learned score function for generation. The current experiments lack strict comparisons against fixed-level denoising, self-supervised Gaussian corruption, a variant without timestep conditioning, and a model trained only with clean-feature reconstruction. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the performance gains come from the diffusion objective itself, or simply from stronger geometric perturbations and additional auxiliary tasks. The authors should provide these ablations, or position the method more accurately as topology-preserving multi-level denoising pre-training.
- The paper lacks pre-training scaling experiments. The paper pre-trains on approximately 512K unlabeled B-Rep models, but reports results only for a fixed pre-training corpus, model capacity, and training budget. A key question for pre-training is whether scaling the data and computation leads to consistent improvements on downstream tasks. The different annotation ratios in Table 3 mainly measure downstream label efficiency and cannot replace scaling analyses with respect to pre-training data size or computational budget. The authors should report performance as a function of pre-training corpus size, model capacity, training steps, and noise schedule.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.