- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Paper proposes a neural operator for long-term prediction of capacitively coupled plasma dynamics which combines numerical Poisson solver, an auxiliary cycle-to-cycle predictor, and random subsequence training to reduce prediction errors.
Critical strengths
-
Using a Poisson solver to reconstruct the electric potential is physically motivated.
-
The experiments include component comparisons, different trajectory lengths, and temporal extrapolation beyond the training horizon supporting the main claims.
Critical weaknesses
-
Methodological novelty needs clearer discussion.
-
Experiments are limited to a 1D geometry with the same initial condition across trajectories. Generalization over varying parameters remains unclear.
-
Training description has an indexing ambiguity. It uses 10 input states and 118 rollout steps, while the auxiliary target is shifted by 128 steps. Can you clarify it?
-
Main text and appendix appear to use different mathematical signs for Poisson’s equation and the electron drift term.
-
Consider comparing against latest baselines such as Transolver, Latent Neural operator and Latent Mamba Operator.
Questions for authors
-
What does the proposed cycle-level objective add beyond a standard consistency loss between short-step and long-step predictors? Would an auxiliary predictor with a non-RF-aligned horizon provide similar gains?
-
Could you clarify the exact time indices used for the consistency loss? Is the local rollout extended beyond the stated 118 prediction steps if yes then how?
-
How much training and inference time does the Poisson closure add? Compare full rollout cost with both the neural baselines and the reference numerical solver.
-
Can you report all five training seeds, including the excluded runs, and indicate how often each method fails to train reliably?
-
How does model perform with unseen initial conditions or RF frequencies? Testing several physical parameters would strengthen the generalization claims.
-
FP regularization performs worse than Poisson closure alone on short trajectories. Could you explain when it becomes beneficial and how sensitive this is to the consistency-loss weight?
-
I find the physical motivation useful. However, the novelty, training details, and robustness evidence need to be clearly stated.
9 comments
Author rebuttal (2/2)
[Q1] cycle-to-cycle operator: Thank you for the comment. Our motivation for choosing a lag of exactly one RF period is that the CCP trajectories can be viewed as rapidly RF-periodic oscillations modulated by a much slower cycle-to-cycle relaxation. By mapping states separated by (T_RF), the auxiliary operator always compares states at the same forcing phase, thereby largely factoring out the fast intra-cycle oscillation and focusing the learned mapping on the slower evolution of the cycle-wise envelope. Intuitively, this is analogous to sampling a slowly decaying oscillatory signal once per period: the resulting sequence exposes the underlying decay trend much more directly than samples taken at arbitrary phase offsets. This role of the cycle-scale operator is also reflected in the cycle-convergence results (Figure 5), where FP more accurately captures the gradual cycle-to-cycle evolution toward the converged oscillatory state.
So far, we have performed an ablation to distinguish the effect of the learned auxiliary target from direct one-cycle ground-truth supervision (suggested by the reviewer f2yy). On the 24-RF-cycle trajectories, using the ground-truth state at the same one-cycle offset increases the overall error from (0.0333, hpFNOx-FP) to (0.0573, about 42% increase in error). This result suggests that the learned cycle-scale operator provides a useful auxiliary supervisory signal for the local rollout.
We are currently completing additional lag-based ablations to further isolate the role of the one-RF-period timescale relative to more generic longer-timescale supervision. We will incorporate all the ablation results to the revision when the experimental results are ready.
[Q3] Computation: Thank you for the suggestion. We now have added a new section in Appendix C.1.5 reporting the computational timings of the unconstrained version hpFNOx and two variants hpFNOx-PC and hpFNOx-FP. In summary, the variants provide faster inference in practice (7.7~7.8 compared to 8.5 of hpFNOx)---note that the discrete Poisson operator and RF boundary schedule are fixed, the corresponding discrete Green operator (i.e., via a precomputed factorization of the discrete Poisson operator) can be constructed once before the autoregressive rollout. We also report the computational timing of the reference numerical solver (approximately, 120 seconds), supporting the benefits in the multi-query scenarios.
[Q4] Reporting all five runs: Thank you for the comment. We have added a new section in Appendix C.1.4 reporting the results of all five runs, including the originally excluded runs, across RF-cycle counts from 16 to 48. The results show increased variance when the excluded runs are included; however, the overall ranking remains unchanged, with hpFNOx-PC and hpFNOx-FP continuing to provide the best overall performance.
[Q6] FP regularization details Thank you for the question. The FP regularization is intended primarily to suppress cycle-to-cycle error accumulation rather than to improve short-horizon prediction. For short trajectories, the accumulated rollout drift remains relatively small, leaving less room for the additional cycle-scale supervision to provide a measurable benefit over Poisson closure alone. As the rollout horizon increases, however, cycle-to-cycle drift becomes more pronounced, and FP becomes increasingly competitive and beneficial; in our experiments, this behavior emerges from approximately 24 RF cycles onward, with clearer improvements at longer horizons.
Regarding the loss-weight, we want to note that the same consistency-loss weight, 0.01, is used across all RF-cycle lengths and the voltage-sweep experiments without setting-specific tuning, and consistently provides stable improvements in the longer-horizon regime. We are currently completing additional experiments on the sensitivity to the consistency-loss weight and will report those results in the revised manuscript.
I thank the authors for their detailed response, clarifications, and revisions to the manuscript. As I am less familiar with plasma physics, I have one remaining question: does the plasma dataset exhibit nonstationary behavior across the different conditions studied? If so, could the authors explain how the Fourier Neural Operator captures this behavior, particularly any localized high-frequency features or sharp transitions, given the potential limitations of retaining a finite number of Fourier modes?
Author rebuttal (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for carefully reviewing the paper and providing constructive feedback. The comments have helped us improve the manuscript. While we are still completing several additional numerical experiments, we would like to provide the responses and clarifications available so far.
[W1] Novelty: Thank you for the comment. As the reviewer f2yy acknowledges in the strengths, we would like to reiterate that the objective of this work is not solely to introduce an entirely new standalone learning primitive, but to better address a challenging scientific application through problem-specific methodological developments and their integration. We believe that this is consistent with the broader notion of contribution described in the ICLR reviewer guidelines, which explicitly recognizes work that draws attention to a new application or problem, better addresses an existing problem, and combinations of methodological and application-driven contributions. All together, these adaptations and a proper integration (random-subsequence training for scalable long-trajectory learning, a hybrid neural--numerical rollout for enforcing the Poisson constraint, and auxiliary one-cycle supervision for mitigating long-horizon drift) enable accurate 48-RF-cycle prediction in a regime where the general-purpose neural-operator baselines considered in our experiments perform poorly.
[W2/Q5] Voltage parameter sweep: Thank you for the comment. We have extended the voltage parameter sweep to include 24 RF cycles and consider hpFNOx and hpFNOx variants. The summary of the results are as follows:
hpFNOx: 1.6632, hpFNOx-BC: 0.2830, hpFNOx-PC: 0.2467, and hpFNOx-FP: 0.1680.
The full details are presented in Appendix C.3.
Initial conditions and operating conditions: Thank you for the comment. We agree that generalization across additional initial conditions and operating parameters is an important direction in the general SciML domain. At the same time, the present study is intentionally formulated as a parameterized surrogate-modeling problem in which trajectories evolve from a prescribed initial condition while physical parameters are varied, which is a standard formulation in reduced-basis and parametric model-reduction methods for time-dependent systems [1,2,3]. The primary benchmark spans a broad three-order-of-magnitude range of the reaction-source amplitude, producing substantially different plasma-density regimes. The RF frequency is fixed at (13.56) MHz, a conventional operating frequency widely used in CCP studies and adopted in established CCP simulation benchmarks [4,5].
We also note that variation of the RF driving condition was already considered in the original submission through a voltage-amplitude sweep over (V_0 in [100,300]). That experiment directly changes the time-dependent boundary forcing and consequently the electric field, sheath dynamics, and charged-particle evolution, which we have further extended this experiment to 24 RF cycles in revision. We show that the benefit of FP regularization persists under varying RF-drive amplitudes.
We again agree with the reviewer on the importance of the raised question and we note that generalization beyond this remains beyond the present scope.
[1] Benner, Gugercin, and Willcox, A Survey of Projection-Based Model Reduction Methods ..., SIAM Review (2015)
[2] Hesthaven, Pagliantini, and Rozza, Reduced Basis Methods for Time-Dependent Problems, Acta Numerica (2022)
[3] Grepl and Patera, A Posteriori Error Bounds for Reduced-Basis Approximations of ..., M2AN (2025)
[4] Turner, et al, Simulation benchmarks for low-pressure plasmas: capacitive discharges, Physics of Plasmas, 2013
[5] Chabert and Braithwaite, Physics of Radio-Frequency Plasmas, Cambridge University Press, 2011
[W3/Q2] Time indexing for the consistency loss: Thank you for pointing this out. The reviewer is right. The description on how that consistency loss is computed was not complete in the original submission. We revised the manuscript to clearly state this in Appendix B.2 (p. 25).
In short, when the standard local rollout of length L_sub does not reach one full RF period, we continue the hpFNOx-PC backbone autoregressively for the additional steps needed to reach the phase-aligned one-cycle target. In our setting, this requires one extra rollout step beyond the standard 118-step local rollout.
[W4] sign error: Thank you for the careful reading. This has been fixed; the one in Appendix is correct.
[W5] Additional Baselines: Thank you for the suggestion. We have added a new set of results obtained from LNO (Wang and Wang, NeurIPS, 2024) and LaMO (Tiwari, et al, ICML, 2025) in the Appendices (B.1 and C.2). In summary, the proposed methods remain the best-performing methods, outperforming these additional recent NO baselines.