- Rating
- 1(−1)
- Confidence
- 3(+1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SCNO (Scattering Coordinates Neural Operator) introduces a framework that integrates exact inverse-scattering evolution with a learned correction for near-integrable partial differential equations. Experiments on perturbed nonlinear Schrodinger dynamics and damped KdV equations evaluate extrapolation capabilities, coordinate selection, and the impact of stronger perturbations.
Critical strengths
-
Principled architecture: the zero-residual model recovers the exact solution for reflectionless integrable inputs, giving learning a physically meaningful starting point.
-
Useful empirical exploration: several perturbations and a second PDE are studied, with informative ablations and explicit reporting of limitations.
Critical weaknesses
-
The novelty, contribution, and potential benefits of the work need stronger justification
The proposed solution represents a reasonable design. However, integrating physical dynamics with a learned correction is a well-established approach e.g. APHYNITY (Yin et al., 2021) and universal differential equations (Rackauckas et al., 2020). The manuscript should therefore articulate more precisely the novel aspects of this construction. Proposition 1 appears to follow directly from the design. The study is limited in scope, focusing primarily on the integrable soliton context. A clearer explanation of the approach's generalizability beyond the demonstrated cases would strengthen the work's significance.
The primary concern relates to the comparison of physical models. Table 9 presents first-order loss baselines, and the loss baseline outperforms SCNO across all four strengths. However, first-order perturbation is not applied for TOD and Raman effects. This omission represents a missed opportunity, as evaluating the corresponding approximate drift models could clarify where the learning-based approach captures effects that simpler analytical corrections do not. Furthermore, since the equations are known and models are trained separately for each channel and strength, an accuracy-versus-cost comparison with less expensive classical solver settings is necessary (e.g. Hult, 2007). Comparison solely with the production-accuracy reference solver does not adequately address this issue. Incorporating these comparisons, along with clearer positioning relative to prior methods, would better substantiate the contribution.
-
Better support and documentation of the theoretical claims and experimental setup are needed
Proposition 2 offers valuable motivation; however, its assumptions and coordinate selection should be more explicitly linked to the empirical claims. The manuscript differentiates between the path-integrated coordinates used in the bound and the implemented instantaneous coordinates, and it includes a frame ablation. However, the abstract description should also acknowledge the additional contribution identified for the implemented coordinates. Clarify which experiments satisfy the separation and adiabatic assumptions, especially in the context of collision-trajectory interpretation. This distinction would help separate conditional theoretical guarantees from experimental motivations that fall outside the theoretical scope.
The validation and implementation details also need clarification. The loss-decay law is described as exact, while the authors refer to adiabatic theory; the authors should also specify the measured observable and the conditions under which the law is exact or approximate. It is also difficult to identify which configurations generated Figures 5b and 7b. Too many internal log references are distracting and sometimes confusing. The authors should explicitly state the boundary conditions and how they treat solitons reaching the temporal-window boundary. No code is provided to help.
References
Yin, Y., Le Guen, V., Dona, J., de Bézenac, E., Ayed, I., Thome, N., and Gallinari, P. (2021). Augmenting Physical Models with Deep Networks for Complex Dynamics Forecasting. ICLR. https://arxiv.org/abs/2010.04456
Rackauckas, C., et al. (2020). Universal Differential Equations for Scientific Machine Learning. arXiv:2001.04385. https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.04385
Hult, J. (2007). A Fourth-Order Runge–Kutta in the Interaction Picture Method for Simulating Supercontinuum Generation in Optical Fibers. Journal of Lightwave Technology, 25(12):3770–3775. https://doi.org/10.1109/JLT.2007.909373
Questions for authors
- How does SCNO compare with approximate first-order TOD and Raman drift models, and also with classical solvers, in terms of accuracy and cost?
- What specific advantage does SCNO offer over existing approaches that combine physical dynamics with learned residuals, and what extends beyond the demonstrated integrable soliton settings?
- Which experiments satisfy Proposition 2’s assumptions, and which claims for the implemented coordinates follow once the additional phase contribution is included (see weaknesses above)?
- Under what conditions is the loss-decay law exact or approximate?
- Which configurations produced Figures 5b and 7b, and what boundary conditions were used?
5 comments
Reply to Reviewer ZG6K (Part 2 of 4)
Q2. Advantage over approaches that combine physics with a learned residual, and reach beyond solitons.
We implemented APHYNITY following Algorithm 1 of Yin et al. (2022). The known physics is the integrable NLSE, plus the loss term in the cell with all three perturbations, with the physical parameters fixed at their known values. A small convolutional network learns the rest. UDE (Rackauckas et al., 2021) has the same known-plus-learned structure in state coordinates, and we use APHYNITY as the representative of this structure. APHYNITY has lower median field error at in 7 cells, and SCNO in 5.
| Cell | APHYNITY | SCNO |
|---|---|---|
| Loss 0.01 | 0.112 | 0.259 |
| Loss 0.03 | 0.078 | 0.276 |
| Loss 0.05 | 0.044 | 0.503 |
| Loss 0.1 | 0.017 | 1.073 |
| Raman 0.01 | 0.212 | 0.455 |
| Raman 0.03 | 0.373 | 0.966 |
| All three perturbations | 0.121 | 0.471 |
| TOD 0.005 | 0.218 | 0.049 |
| TOD 0.02 | 0.238 | 0.133 |
| TOD 0.05 | 0.597 | 0.259 |
| Noise 0.001 | 0.152 | 0.017 |
| Noise 0.01 | 0.243 | 0.171 |
APHYNITY has lower error in the loss and Raman cells and in the cell with all three perturbations. SCNO has lower error in the three TOD cells and the two noise cells, where the noiseless solution reaches the same floor without learning. Timed in one session on one CPU thread, APHYNITY takes 508 ms per field at inference and SCNO 8.2 ms with the scattering data given. Computing the scattering data from a field adds 238 ms (Sec. 5.7). The 4.0 ms of Q1 was timed on another day, when the same machine ran about twice as fast.
The specific difference from these frameworks is where the residual lives. SCNO places it in scattering coordinates, where the integrable flow is an exact rotation. Our matched-capacity ablation, the same residual model in time-domain coordinates, has 5.8 times higher error at . The corrected results show that this design has lower error than APHYNITY on TOD and at the noise floor, and higher error on loss, Raman and the cell with all three perturbations. Against this class, SCNO's advantages are lower error in the TOD cells and lower inference cost once the scattering data are known. The ablation compares two coordinates inside SCNO's own pipeline, and the APHYNITY numbers above give the comparison with this class. On reach beyond solitons, SCNO needs an explicit inverse scattering transform, with decaying boundary conditions and a computable inverse. The continuous spectrum enters only through the measured error of the discarded energy. The revised manuscript states this scope, cites APHYNITY and UDE, and states the positioning in these terms (Sec. 2, Sec. 5.3, Sec. 6).
Proposition 1 follows directly from the design.
Proposition 1 states a design property of the pipeline. The revised manuscript presents it as such and no longer lists it as a contribution (Sec. 1, Sec. 4).
Reply to Reviewer ZG6K (Part 3 of 4)
Q3. Which experiments satisfy Proposition 2's assumptions, and which claims follow once the additional contribution is included?
Proposition 2 is stated for an isolated soliton in the adiabatic regime, and the 76 single-soliton fields satisfy it. Separated fields with several solitons carry dressing terms that drift at . Of the 256 test fields, 110 (43%) keep every pair of solitons at least three widths apart along the unperturbed tracks for , and 76 of these are single solitons. The other 146 (57%) come closer, and 93 (36%) collide, with centers less than one width apart. The adiabatic parameter reaches 1.6 at the strongest loss. The revised manuscript reports these fractions and evaluates each group separately (Sec. 5.4, Table 4). The table gives the median field error at for the projection, the first-order line and SCNO.
| Group | Loss 0.01 (projection / first order / SCNO) | TOD 0.05 | Raman 0.01 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single soliton (76) | 0.006 / 0.007 / 0.205 | 0.185 / 0.185 / 0.237 | 0.006 / 0.005 / 0.303 |
| Separated (110) | 0.007 / 0.007 / 0.240 | 0.264 / 0.264 / 0.232 | 0.007 / 0.008 / 0.341 |
| Colliding (93) | 0.015 / 0.067 / 0.264 | 0.469 / 0.487 / 0.302 | 0.029 / 0.747 / 0.857 |
SCNO's error on colliding fields is 0.95 to 1.6 times that on separated fields on loss and TOD, and 1.4 to 2.5 times on Raman (Table 15 gives every cell). On single solitons SCNO has higher error than the projection in 9 of 9 cells, so the separation assumption does not explain its gap to the projection and first-order theory. The revised Proposition 2 is stated for an isolated soliton, so collision trajectories are outside its scope (Sec. 4, Sec. 5.4).
For the implemented instantaneous coordinate, the corrected calculation gives an log-amplitude drift on loss and TOD, an phase drift on loss, and an log-amplitude drift on Raman. On the single-soliton test fields that stay tracked to , at most 76 per cell and 15 to 29 on Raman, the log-amplitude follows these forms. The Raman log-amplitude exponent is 2.00 against a predicted 2, and the Raman phase exponent is 0.99 to 1.00 against 1 (Table 12). On the first 64 test fields of all geometries, the Raman exponent of the log-amplitude is 1.26 to 1.45, so the isolated-soliton calculation does not extend to fields with several solitons (Table 11). So the claim of an learning target holds for the log-amplitude on loss and TOD, and it fails for the Raman log-amplitude and the loss phase. The revised abstract states that the drift grows as the square of the distance for the log-amplitude under Raman and for the phase under loss. Fig. 3, which replaces Fig. 4, includes Raman and both coordinates. Retraining SCNO in the path-integrated coordinate raised its median error at from 0.455 to 0.739 at , so removing the first-order Raman term from the target did not help.
Reply to Reviewer ZG6K (Part 1 of 4)
We thank the reviewer for precise questions. They led us to recheck our calculations, and we made two corrections. Proposition 2 now includes an ϵz2 term for moving solitons, and the revised Eq. (4), which replaces Eq. (5), states that this term changes the amplitude as well as the phase. After these corrections, we added the requested first-order TOD and Raman models and the classical-solver comparison, and we added APHYNITY. We also retrained SCNO in both coordinates and on top of the first-order rates. The corrected results led us to revise our claims. A cell is one perturbation type at one strength, and one further cell applies loss, TOD and Raman together. With the perturbation known, first-order theory, with zero learned parameters, has lower error than SCNO in most cells. A classical solver at twice SCNO's inference cost is more accurate in all 9 cells with one deterministic perturbation. When the perturbation is unknown and must be learned from data, SCNO has the lowest error of the tested learned methods in the TOD cells at z=8, twice the training horizon. The uploaded manuscript is revised throughout, and we answer each question below.
Experiments added at the reviewer's request.
We ran first-order TOD and Raman drift models, classical solvers (SSFM and RK4IP) for accuracy against cost, a physics-plus-residual model (APHYNITY), and an evaluation of the test fields by soliton geometry. All are reported in the revised manuscript (Sec. 5.2 to 5.4).
Q1. First-order TOD and Raman drift models, and classical solvers, in accuracy and cost.
We added both comparisons. The Raman rate of adiabatic theory, dζ/dz=−1564ϵ3η4, matches single-soliton simulation within 0.1%. We use two methods with zero learned parameters. The first applies the first-order drift rates with the multi-soliton dressing of the positions. The second projects the perturbation onto the N-soliton manifold. The table gives the median field error at z=8, the median over the 256 test fields of the relative L2 error, for the TOD and Raman cells. For SCNO it is the median over 3 seeds, and Table 2 also gives the four loss cells.
SCNO beats first-order theory in one cell, TOD 0.05, and its lead lies in fields with several solitons. There SCNO has median error 0.304 on three-soliton fields, against 0.448 for the projection. On single solitons, the projection is better, 0.185 against 0.237. At Raman ϵ3=0.01, collisions break first-order theory, which has error 0.747 on colliding fields. The projection handles them with 0.029, and SCNO does not, with 0.857 (Table 4).
For the classical solvers, we timed SSFM and RK4IP at 10 to 50 steps per unit length on the same machine, one CPU thread, batch 32. SCNO's 4.0 ms assumes the scattering data are given, and computing them from a field adds 238 ms. Training, 340 s per run, is also excluded. At equal inference cost with the scattering data given, RK4IP with 10 steps per unit, SCNO has lower error in 6 of 9 cells. At twice SCNO's cost, RK4IP with 20 steps per unit has lower error than SCNO in all 9 cells. Table 2 adds these methods, Table 9 gives the solvers, and this accuracy-cost comparison replaces the comparison with the production reference (Sec. 5.2).