- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper describes a new strategy for event-triggered active exploration of a control-affine nonlinear system with Gaussian Processes. While there is no Knowledge About a global Control Barrier Function, active Exploration is required in order to learn the Dynamics while maintaining safety at all times. The active Exploration triggering is required in order to obtain feasibility of the safety filter given by a Control Barrier Function. The authors extend Prior work by introducing a more structured Exploration scheme in the space of Control inputs with finite trigger times and thereby providing sample complexity guarantees and recursive feasibility.
Critical strengths
- The authors provide a thorough review of each decision made. They discuss assumptions and embed their work thoroughly into the current research state.
- The proposed method leads in the given examples to no safety violations and therefore safe autonomous Operation
- The method has sample complexity bounds
Critical weaknesses
- I do not understand Figure 1. Please elaborate more on the main differences and the fundamental different uncertainties in the four cases. Why do the arrows start in the unsafe area? You could delete the outline for the paper in lines 105-107 if you need more space.
- The improvement seems incremental, comparing to Lederer2026c and Castaneda2025.
- The implementation of highest uncertainty directions, as meantioned in future work, is from my point of view a good additional ablation for the current paper.
- There seems to be no code given
Questions for authors
- The introduction of a full orthonormal basis is a scaling issue, when considering high dimensional systems. Where do you see the boundary for your method ?
- The same holds for the restriction of the unit ball. Have you seen issues with neglecting possible control Inputs which are in the unit ball, but not in the unit ball ?
3 comments
Response Part 2
Ablation on Maximum-Uncertainty Directions
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We have conducted an additional ablation study on the 7-DoF Franka Panda manipulator, where the structured exploration inputs are prioritized according to their GP predictive uncertainty. After each GP update, the original triggering condition is re-evaluated to enable early stopping.
Compared with full structured exploration, this heuristic reduces the number of online training samples by 40.40% and 26.70% for the Closed-Form CBF and Point-Wise CBF Evaluation settings, respectively, with zero CBF violations and SOCP infeasibilities in all 100 trials per setting.
These results demonstrate the potential of uncertainty-prioritized exploration with early stopping to reduce online sampling requirements. We have added the experimental procedure and quantitative results in Appendix G.5 (Uncertainty-Prioritized Exploration with Early Stopping). Theoretical guarantees for this heuristic extension remain an interesting direction for future work.
The quantitative results of this ablation are summarized in the following table.
Table: Ablation of uncertainty-prioritized exploration with early stopping on the Franka Panda manipulator.
| Metric | Closed-Form CBF (Full) | Closed-Form CBF (Early) | Point-Wise CBF Eval. (Full) | Point-Wise CBF Eval. (Early) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Online Training Samples | ||||
| CBF Violations | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| SOCP Infeasibilities | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Path Overhead Ratio | ||||
| Minimum Clearance (cm) | ||||
| Trigger Frequency (Hz) | ||||
| Min. Trigger Interval (steps) |
Scalability to High-Dimensional Control Spaces
We thank the reviewer for this question. We acknowledge that constructing a full orthonormal basis introduces additional exploration costs as the control dimension increases. For an -dimensional control input, each triggered exploration requires control inputs over a total duration of . Higher dimensions may therefore require a smaller sampling period to limit state variations during exploration, while GP computational complexity also needs to be considered.
Our approach primarily targets robotic systems with moderate control dimensions, which represent an important class of practical applications. The experiments on the 7-DoF Franka Panda manipulator further demonstrate its applicability in such settings.
Moreover, the additional ablation in Appendix G.5 shows that uncertainty-prioritized exploration with early stopping reduces online training samples by 26.70%–40.40%, indicating a promising way to mitigate exploration costs and potentially extend the approach to higher-dimensional control spaces. We therefore consider moderate-dimensional robotic systems the primary application domain of the current method, with further scalability depending on exploration length and computational costs.
Unit Euclidean Ball Constraint
We thank the reviewer for this question. The unit ball is primarily adopted to exploit its geometric structure for constructing safe orthogonal exploration directions. This exploration scheme can also be combined with a standard GP-CBF safety filter operating over the full box.
Specifically, structured exploration establishes a uniform GP posterior variance bound over the () unit ball using observations along orthogonal directions. Combined with the robust feasibility margin in Assumption 3, this bound ensures the existence of a feasible input within the ball after exploration, under the stated sufficient conditions. Since , this input also remains feasible for the box-constrained safety filter, allowing normal control to exploit additional inputs outside the ball. By extending the GP confidence and sampling-time drift bounds to the box domain, the resulting control inputs can satisfy the same GP-CBF safety condition.
We have clarified this extension in Section 3.1, following Eq. (4), and Appendix D.5.
Code Availability
We thank the reviewer for highlighting the importance of code availability. As stated in our Reproducibility Statement, we plan to release the source code under an open-source license upon acceptance.
Thank you for the rebuttal. I have read it and also the remaining reviews and author rebuttals. The clarifications on Figure 1, the added ablation and the explicit feasibility statement address my questions.
I tend towards acceptence, while acknowleding the paper as borderline. I will stick to my score.
Response Part 1
Clarification of Figure 1
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. Fig. 1 illustrates the exploration strategies and corresponding GP predictive uncertainty distributions in the control-input space at a fixed system state. The circular boundary represents the control-input magnitude constraint, the background color indicates the GP predictive uncertainty of the CBF derivative (blue: low; red: high), and the shaded region denotes unsafe control inputs. The arrows represent control-input vectors drawn from the origin, with their endpoints corresponding to the applied inputs. Thus, an arrow passing through the shaded region does not imply that the intermediate unsafe inputs are executed.
The four strategies differ in their exploration patterns: Time-triggered learning does not actively select exploration directions; Single Point primarily reduces uncertainty near a single safe direction; Bandit explores multiple directions but may select unsafe inputs; and our Structured Exploration uses orthogonal perturbations around a safe anchor direction to cover multiple control directions while maintaining safety.
We have clarified the graphical elements of Fig. 1 in the Introduction, immediately before the discussion of Single Point and Bandit exploration.
Novelty and Significance:
We thank the reviewer for the comment on the novelty of our work. We believe that, compared with Lederer et al. and Castañeda et al., our approach represents a substantial advance in exploration design, theoretical guarantees, and empirical performance, rather than an incremental improvement.
1. Our experimental results demonstrate significant performance improvements. As shown in Table 1, compared with the Single Point method, our approach reduces the average trigger frequency from 13.81 Hz to 1.22 Hz on the Quadrotor and from 15.40 Hz to 0.043 Hz on the AUV, while reducing CBF violations from 3 and 32 to zero, respectively. These results demonstrate that our method substantially reduces exploration frequency while improving safety.
2. Our work introduces a fundamentally different exploration mechanism with new theoretical guarantees. Unlike existing approaches that primarily explore along a single safe control direction to maintain safety-filter feasibility, our method employs structured multidirectional exploration to systematically reduce GP uncertainty across the entire control-input space. Through a novel GP variance decomposition, we establish a uniform posterior-variance bound over the bounded control-input domain and further derive a finite bound on the number of exploration triggers, together with a corresponding sample-complexity guarantee. These theoretical results are not provided by either of the two aforementioned works.
3. Our approach improves practical applicability and broadens experimental validation. Compared with prior approaches relying on idealized continuous-time or instantaneous exploration assumptions and exploration designs without predefined control-amplitude bounds, our method explicitly accounts for safety over finite sampling intervals and constructs safe exploration sequences within bounded control-input constraints. We also extend the experimental evaluation from relatively simple cruise-control and kinematic-vehicle models to more complex robotic systems, including a Quadrotor, an AUV, and a seven-degree-of-freedom Franka manipulator.