- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes ASAP (Arbitrary-Step Safe Planning), a framework that integrates MeanFlow with Control Barrier Functions (CBFs) to enable efficient and safe trajectory generation with an arbitrary number of sampling steps, including one-step generation. The key contribution is a discrete-time affine barrier constraint that enforces safety during the generative process without requiring model retraining.
Critical strengths
-
Efficient and Safe Motion Planning: The paper enables fast trajectory generation while providing formal safety guarantees, addressing an important limitation of existing generative motion planners.
-
Strong Theoretical Guarantees: The authors establish formal safety guarantees for arbitrary-step generation, including one-step sampling, and prove zero conservatism of the affine barrier constraints under the stated SDF assumptions.
-
Extensive Experimental Validation: The method is evaluated across diverse simulation benchmarks, including navigation, locomotion, and manipulation, as well as a real-world robotic handover task. The results demonstrate substantial improvements in planning efficiency while maintaining safety and competitive task performance.
Critical weaknesses
None
Questions for authors
Suggestions for Future Work: While the work presents strong theoretical and experimental results, I encourage the authors to consider evaluating the proposed framework in autonomous driving simulations. Given the safety-critical nature of autonomous driving, demonstrating the effectiveness of ASAP in such scenarios would further strengthen the practical relevance of the proposed safety guarantees and enhance the overall impact of the work.
4 comments
Additional Response to Reviewer QXDf: Autonomous Driving Evaluation
Motivated by the reviewer's suggestion, we conducted additional experiments on NAVSIM, an end-to-end autonomous-driving benchmark also used in recent flow-based planning studies [1,2].
Experimental setup. Following [2], we use its pretrained visual encoder to condition the generation of eight future trajectory waypoints. We formulate an SDF for roadside walls, where indicates wall contact or collision, and evaluate ASAP across 20 driving scenarios against three baselines considered in our main paper: MeanFlow (MF), SafeFlowMatcher (SFM), and SafeDiffuser (S-Diff.) .
Results. As shown in the table below, ASAP achieves a % safety rate across all 20 scenarios with one-step generation in only s in average. In contrast, MeanFlow is faster ( s) but achieves only % safety. SFM achieves % safety with steps and requires steps to reach % safety, taking s ( slower than ASAP). Similarly, increasing S-Diff.'s sampling steps from to improves its safety rate from % to %, but still fails to achieve complete safety while increasing computation time from s to s. These results demonstrate ASAP's clear advantage in achieving both safety and computational efficiency for autonomous-driving trajectory planning.
Comparison of safety rate and planning time across 20 NAVSIM driving scenarios.
| Method | Sampling step() | Safety rate() | Average time() |
|---|---|---|---|
| MF | % | ||
| SFM | % | ||
| SFM | % | ||
| S-Diff | % | ||
| S-Diff. | % | ||
| S-Diff. | % | ||
| S-Diff. | % | ||
| ASAP | % |
We appreciate the reviewer's suggestion. These additional results further demonstrate ASAP's effectiveness in safety-critical autonomous-driving scenarios, strengthening the practical relevance of its safety guarantees and the broader impact of our work.
[1] Liu, Lin, et al. "Guideflow: Constraint-guided flow matching for planning in end-to-end autonomous driving." CVPR, 2026.
[2] Wang, Junli, et al. "Meanfuser: Fast one-step multi-modal trajectory generation and adaptive reconstruction via meanflow for end-to-end autonomous driving." CVPR, 2026.
Thank you for the authors detailed response and additional experiment. The NAVSIM experiment increases the practical relavance of the proposed approach. All my comments have been addressed
Author Response to Reviewer QXDf
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive feedback and for recognizing the additional autonomous-driving validation! We are glad that our revisions and experiments have fully addressed your comments. We would be grateful if you could consider whether the additional evidence changes your overall assessment. Of course, we fully respect your decision if you prefer to maintain your current rating.
Response to Reviewer QXDf (1/1)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of ASAP's efficiency, formal safety guarantees, and extensive validation across simulation and real-world experiments. We appreciate the recognition of our contributions and the valuable suggestion for future work.
Q1: Extension to autonomous driving.
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment and valuable suggestion. We agree that autonomous driving is a promising application of ASAP. Recent studies [1,2] have demonstrated the effectiveness of flow matching for end-to-end autonomous driving, further motivating the application of our framework to this domain. In particular, ASAP provides a unified safety framework for both efficient one-step and flexible multi-step trajectory generation, enabling test-time safety correction without retraining. Our current evaluation focuses on validating these properties across navigation, locomotion, and robotic manipulation tasks. Extending ASAP to autonomous driving would require incorporating driving-specific constraints and evaluation protocols, which we consider an important direction for future work.
[1] Xing, Zebin, et al. "Goalflow: Goal-driven flow matching for multimodal trajectories generation in end-to-end autonomous driving." CVPR, 2025.
[2] Liu, Lin, et al. "Guideflow: Constraint-guided flow matching for planning in end-to-end autonomous driving." CVPR, 2026.