- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposed the Semantic-Guided Fuzzy Difference Refinement Network (SFDRNet) to addressed the problem that existing methods struggle to preserve weak temporal evidence and make reliable decisions when real semantic changes exhibit low visual contrast. TSC constructs and calibrates temporal and semantic evidence, while USDR refines ambiguous change responses before prediction.
Critical strengths
- The organization of this paper is easy to follow.
- The related work summarize many SCD-based methods that are very related to the proposed method.
- The supplement shows several visualization results that can support the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
-
The motivation of the proposed method is not very clear. The author claimed that existing methods still struggle to preserve weak temporal evidence and make reliable decisions when real semantic changes exhibit low visual contrast. I think this issue is very common in the current SCD task. Many state-of-the-art methods are designed to address this issue in different perspectives such as capturing the tiny change from different temporal images, using some Anchor-based mechanism to capture the true change. The author should discuss the main difference between the proposed method and other different type methods with experiment and theory.
-
The figure 1 is hard to understand. What is the main difference between the two times images? I do not think it exists small visual change between this two images. In contrast, I think the change between this two images are very obvious. It is better to use a real image-pair to explain the "small visual change". In addition, It seems that the ordinary variation and real weak change are in different distributions. However, why the weak evidence is easily suppressed? I think the motivation in this figure is not very clear to describe the main issue.
-
The proposed architecture is not very novel compared to existed state-of-the-art methods. In figure 2, it seems that the TSC fuses the high and low level features by FFT and uses semantic decoder to calibrate semantic feature, which is very common in many deep learning based architectures. I think the main contribution of the proposed method is in USDR module. However, it hard to understand in this figure. It seems that the USDR just splits semantic feature channels with global and local branches then using Gaussian Dual- Response to fuse the feature, which is also not novel compared with other methods. It should discuss the different fusing mechanisms to show the main difference of the proposed method.
-
More state-of-the-art SCD methods should be evaluated and compared in the experiment part, especially some hybrid-based architectures that can capture the local and global features. In addition, more architectures with different types should also be compared and evaluated in the experiment.
-
It seems that the proposed method is not significantly better than the SCGNet. And it is hard to see the main differences in visualization results between the proposed method with SCGNet in figure 6.
-
More visualization results or evidences should be illustrated the motivation of the proposed method. It is better to show many "small visual change" examples in the visualization results and give some heat maps or attention maps to show the interpretability of the proposed method.
Questions for authors
please see the weakness.