- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper formulates RSCD as continuous evidence-to-geometry transport using Flow Matching (FM) and proposes TempoFlow-CD, which reformulates FM through target coupling and temporal parameterization. NIGF couples nuisance-varied sources through a shared mask–distance target and endpoint consistency, while CASC combines geometrysupervised local phase conditioning with boundary-guided velocity refinement on a shared integration grid. Experiments are conducted on six RSCD benchmarks demonstrate improved detection accuracy and boundary localization, with additional evaluations supporting robustness to radiometric disturbances.
Critical strengths
(1) The paper is easy to follow and the motivation of this paper is clear. It claims that visual discrepancies caused by illumination, blur, noise, and residual misregistration are often entangled with true changes.
(2) The experiment is conducted on many different datasets show the good performance of the proposed methods.
Critical weaknesses
(1) Although the motivation of the proposed method is clear, the author did not analyze the visual discrepancies caused by illumination, blur, noise, and residual misregistration are existed in the different datasets. For example, in the LEVIR-CD dataset, how many visual discrepancies are existed in the true scenario. It is better to describe different scenarios that visual discrepancies effect the true changes.
(2) The figure 2 is confused to describe the proposed TempoFlow-CD. In this figure, the inputs pass through VRWKV Encoder, NIGF, and CASC. However, the output is not clear in this figure. The motivation of the NIGF and CASC is not clear in the figure.
(3) For the overall objective function, the author did not analyze the hyperparameters of λ in this equation. Also, the ablation study does not discuss this in the experiment. Without this, we can not determine which term is more important in the current design.
(4) More visualization results should focus on different visual discrepancies caused by illumination, blur, noise, and residual misregistration in the experiment part. Only figure 4 demonstrates several changes in different datasets. More detailed analysis and discussion should be added to support the motivation.
(5) More state-of-the-art change detection methods should be evaluated and discussed in the experiment. Actually, it is better to classify the compared method with different types, such as flow matching-based methods, hybrid-based methods, et al.
Questions for authors
Please see the weakness.