- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 2(+1)
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies performance gains from RLVR training, and their distribution along a generation trace. It introduces a prefix transplantation analysis in which the RL-trained model generates the first k tokens and the base model completes the remaining response. Using the performance-difference lemma, the resulting accuracy gains can be decomposed into token-level advantages under the base policy. Experiments across several model pairs suggest that early gains, especially for Qwen-Math models, can often be reproduced by generic opening prefixes or stronger prompting. The paper further studies how token-level divergence relates to estimated downstream value.
Critical strengths
The paper includes extensive experiments and ablations across different models and prompting conditions. The authors also report negative and inconclusive findings, and provide substantial supplementary materials for reproducibility.
Critical weaknesses
-
Extremely poor presentation and organization. The paper is genuinely exhausting to read. There is no Conclusion section, and the Abstract and Introduction are overloaded with unnecessary details (e.g., "13 cells", "+0.014", "m=8", "m=32") before the experimental setup is even introduced. The text is often unnaturally compressed, with awkward sentences such as "whether it grades the trained token our nulls leave open" (Line 106). Many paragraphs lack a clear logical flow, making the main contributions and takeaways very difficult to identify.
-
Limited novelty and unclear significance of the findings. The core mathematical framework is a direct application of the well-known performance-difference lemma [1,2]. Closely related token-level interventions and analyses of where RLVR changes model behavior have already been explored [3,4]. The central observation that RLVR gains often reflect elicitation of existing base-model capabilities, with strong sensitivity to prompting and even reward quality, is also well established [5,6]. I struggle to identify a sufficiently novel insight beyond these works.
The empirical findings are also heavily dependent on the choice of baseline. The strongest front-loading result comes from a post-hoc selected Qwen-Math setting, and much of the reported early gain disappears under stronger base-model prompts (Tables 43–45). Even the interpretation of "format" versus "content" changes substantially with the baseline. Moreover, the generic-prefix intervention does not cleanly isolate formatting effects, and the empirical conservation checks have limited statistical power. Although the authors acknowledge the strong dependence on the baseline prompt, I find that this substantially limits the significance of reported results. It remains unclear what generalizable insight the proposed "ledger" provides beyond the already established sensitivity of RLVR gains to prompting and elicitation.
Overall, the paper contains a substantial amount of analysis, but I find th scientific contribution rather limited and the presentation far below the expected standard.
- Kakade, S., and Langford, J. Approximately Optimal Approximate Reinforcement Learning. ICML, 2002.
- Setlur, A., et al. Rewarding Progress: Scaling Automated Process Verifiers for LLM Reasoning. ICLR, 2025.
- Meng, H., et al. Sparse but Critical: A Token-Level Analysis of Distributional Shifts in RLVR Fine-Tuning of LLMs. ICLR, 2026.
- Venhoff, C., et al. Base Models Know How to Reason, Thinking Models Learn When. ICML, 2026.
- Liu, Z., et al. Understanding R1-Zero-Like Training: A Critical Perspective. COLM, 2025.
- Shao, R., et al. Spurious Rewards: Rethinking Training Signals in RLVR. ICML, 2026.
Questions for authors
- What is the main new scientific insight enabled by the proposed ledger that could not be obtained from prior prefix transplantation or token-level intervention studies?
- Given the strong dependence on prompting and baseline selection, which of the main empirical conclusions should be considered general properties of RLVR, rather than artifacts of the specific experimental setup?
3 comments
Follow-up
Thank you again for your review. Before the discussion period closes on 18 November, we wanted to check whether the revision addresses your concerns. The paper was rewritten for readability (a plain-language abstract and introduction, one claim per results subsection, and a Conclusion), and our reply answers your two questions directly: what the ledger shows that divergence statistics or intervention studies cannot, with the 32B checkpoint of Meng et al. as an example, and which conclusions held on every pair versus which depend on the setup. We would welcome any further questions, and would be grateful if you would consider whether the revision changes your assessment.
I thank the authors for their response and the substantial revision. The clearer presentation and additional controls address some of my concerns. I have raised Presentation and Informativeness to 2, but am inclined to maintain my original rating, as I still have reservations about the incremental contribution and the strong dependence of the findings on the baseline.
Response to Reviewer nznL
We thank Reviewer nznL for a frank review. The criticism of the presentation was justified, and we rewrote the paper accordingly.
Presentation. The revised PDF rewrites the abstract and introduction in plain language without implementation details, defines each coined term where it first appears, states the contribution against prior work in one paragraph, reorganises the results into seven subsections with one claim each, moves the key tables into the main text and the frontier proposition into Appendix B, and adds a Conclusion. Compressed sentences were rewritten; the one you quote now reads: "Our nulls cannot tell whether dispersion singles out the trained token or only its position."
Q1. What new insight does the ledger enable?
Token-level studies (Meng et al.; Akgül et al.; Venhoff et al.) locate where the trained and base models differ, or how much accuracy an intervention recovers. The ledger prices how much accuracy each trained token buys, in units that add up to the gain, so a localisation claim can be checked against controls in the same units. Three results follow that a divergence statistic cannot give:
Whole-trace studies (Liu et al.; Shao et al.) show that templates and rewards shape the total gain. The ledger shows which tokens carry the template-dependent part, and that it is the part a random reward also buys. The identity is classical (Kakade & Langford; Setlur et al.); we claim a measurement framework, not a new lemma.
Q2. Which conclusions are general, and which are setup-specific?
The revised Conclusion separates them.
A token-level claim about "what RLVR adds" is incomplete without its baseline; the ledger measures how much the baseline matters.
Other points.