acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Residual Advantage: Student-Relative Teacher Guidance for RL with Verifiable Rewards

Abstract

Reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards (RLVR) and on-policy distillation (OPD) have become two main paradigms for post-training reasoning models. RLVR gives each response a single outcome label, leaving the steps inside it without separate credit. OPD provides token-level guidance at student-visited prefixes, but its pointwise signal does not directly reflect the pattern of teacher–student disagreement across the vocabulary. Dense, unbounded log-ratio supervision can amplify the teacher’s influence, yet a strong solver is not necessarily a suitable guide when the student’s solution paths depart from the teacher’s. We propose Residual Advantage (RA), which treats the teacher–student probability residual as a bounded one-step reward, subtracts the corresponding state value under the student policy to form a standard advantage, and centers the result within each response before adding it to the verifier advantage. The guidance term has zero mean within each response, so the verifier advantage remains the response’s mean label and the teacher only redistributes credit among the steps within it. Co-RA further updates a teacher LoRA with verifier advantages on the same scored student batch and uses the updated teacher in the next iteration’s residual, adapting guidance to the student’s attempts. With Qwen3-1.7B-Base and Qwen3-4B-Base students and a Qwen3-8B teacher, RA combined with GRPO or REINFORCE++ improves the underlying sequence-advantage algorithm in all 24 comparisons on three mathematical benchmarks, raising macro Avg@8 by 1.7–3.6 points and Pass@8 by 3.9–6.3 points. Both combinations surpass teacher-only OPD, and Co-RA adds a further 1.0–1.5 Avg@8 points.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards, on-policy distillation, language model post-training, token-level credit assignment, mathematical reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_vcwLOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a method called Residual Advantage, aiming to improve the post-training process of reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards. This method calculates the probability residuals between the teacher model and the student model on the vocabulary, treats them as bounded single-step rewards, and subtracts the state value under the student policy to construct the advantage function. Additionally, the authors introduce a collaborative residual advantage mechanism, using the feedback from the validator to synchronously update the low-rank adaptation module of the teacher model. The authors evaluated this method on multiple mathematical benchmark tests and claimed that it outperforms traditional online strategy distillation and basic reinforcement learning estimators. However, upon thorough review, this paper has serious flaws in terms of innovation, experimental design, and practical value, and is not recommended for publication.

Critical strengths
  1. In the post-training stage of reinforcement learning, how to effectively utilize the fine-grained signals from the teacher model to guide the exploration of the student model is indeed a research direction worth exploring.

  2. The author provided a formal proof of the boundaries of the local advantage function and the expected update direction, demonstrating the theoretical consistency of this method.

  3. The author verified the effectiveness of the proposed method on two different reinforcement learning estimators, providing certain empirical support.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The proposed residual advantage is essentially just a trivial variant of the baseline technique in the standard policy gradient. Using the probability difference as the reward and subtracting the expectation does not break out of the theoretical framework of the traditional advantage function and lacks substantive algorithmic breakthroughs.

  2. The author compared a student model with a large teacher model with extremely small parameter quantities. This huge gap in parameter quantities makes it likely that the performance improvement is merely due to the compensation of model capacity rather than the inherent superiority of the proposed guidance mechanism.

  3. All experiments were limited to specific mathematical reasoning tasks and were not tested in more challenging real scenarios such as general instruction following, code generation, or complex logical reasoning, resulting in doubts about the practical application value of the method.

  4. The collaborative residual advantage mechanism requires simultaneously maintaining and updating the low-rank adaptation module of the teacher model, which significantly increases the memory usage and computing time during training. However, the experimental results show that the performance gain it brings is negligible and cannot prove the rationality of this additional expense.

Questions for authors

see weakness

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer vcwL

We thank the reviewer for the comments. We respectfully note that W2 and W4 are contradicted by results already reported in the paper. Below we address each point with the relevant numbers and our new experiments.

W1 (novelty). We agree that RA keeps the standard form of an advantage, and we do not claim a new algorithmic paradigm. Our goal is to bring the teacher guidance of on-policy distillation into RLVR in a natural and principled way. The advantage framework, from REINFORCE with a baseline (Williams, 1992) to PPO, GRPO and REINFORCE++, has remained the foundation of this line of work because it is simple and well understood, which makes it the natural choice here: RA needs no critic, schedule or threshold, and plugs into GRPO and REINFORCE++ unchanged. RA's contribution is the label that enters this framework. It condenses the teacher–student difference over the whole vocabulary into one scalar per sampled token, centers it within each response, and adds it to the verifier advantage. These choices are not interchangeable. Under a fixed protocol (Tables 2–3), each single change lowers macro Avg@8, and every paired difference excludes zero:

VariantMacro Avg@8
RA29.25
Remove response centering28.71
Remove the student value baseline27.16
Remove both27.52
Replace the residual by the log ratio (best variant)28.04
Replace the label by the direct squared-distance loss28.02

W2 (teacher capacity). A larger teacher guiding a smaller student is the defining setting of knowledge distillation. On-policy distillation (Agarwal et al., 2024; Gu et al., 2024; Lu, 2025) has become a standard stage of LLM post-training precisely because it lets a small model improve quickly under a larger model's guidance. The teacher's capacity is therefore the resource that every method in this setting draws on, not a confound. What distinguishes methods is how well they use the same teacher. Every teacher-guided method below uses the same Qwen3-8B teacher, data and generation budget, and RA outperforms each of them:

MethodAvg@8Pass@8
OPD, sampled token24.8038.60
OPD, full vocabulary27.4541.30
REINFORCE++ with a reverse-KL loss to the teacher26.1439.94
OPD, then REINFORCE++28.3943.61
OPDVR (new)27.9741.73
PowerOPD, α=500 (new)28.7242.13
RA + REINFORCE++29.2545.20

Moreover, the student's gain does not track the teacher's own accuracy: at 1.7B, Co-RA's adapted teachers score 1.9–2.3 Avg@8 below the frozen teacher (App. D.9), yet they produce better students.

W3 (tasks beyond mathematics). We take this point and have added experiments on text-to-SQL, a code-generation task verified by execution. We train Qwen3-1.7B-Base on BIRD with the same Qwen3-8B teacher, keeping λ=10 and the training recipe of the paper, and report execution accuracy (Avg@8):

MethodBIRD devSpider dev
Qwen3-1.7B-Base (untrained)23.454.9
OPD (teacher only)40.674.2
REINFORCE++44.373.8
RA + REINFORCE++46.175.4
Qwen3-8B teacher (reference)52.482.2

RA scores highest among the students on both benchmarks. General instruction following lies outside the scope of RA, which requires a verifiable reward; we will state the evaluation scope explicitly in the paper.

W4 (Co-RA). Co-RA asks whether letting the teacher adapt to the student's behavior yields better guidance, and the experiments show that it does. The gain is not negligible: Co-RA improves over RA in all four settings, and in each setting every Co-RA seed scores above every RA seed (Tables 1 and 18; macro Avg@8):

SettingRACo-RA
1.7B, REINFORCE++29.2530.70
1.7B, GRPO29.8631.09
4B, REINFORCE++37.1238.39
4B, GRPO37.5738.60

The adapted teachers become weaker solvers yet better guides (App. D.9), which is the effect Co-RA is designed to test. We agree that this additional gain should be assessed together with its cost. For completeness, we report the measured cost (8×H20, 1.7B, REINFORCE++, three seeds):

GPU-hoursPeak memory per GPU (GB)Avg@8Pass@8
RA (step 270)1752529.345.2
Co-RA (step 180)1713129.745.3
Co-RA (step 270)2653130.746.4

Even with slightly less compute than RA, Co-RA scores higher. We present Co-RA as an optional extension; the main contribution of the paper is RA, which adds no generation passes and costs about 10% more per token than REINFORCE++.

We would be glad to answer any further questions.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Gentle reminder

Dear Reviewer vcwL,

Thank you again for your constructive comments on the evaluation beyond mathematics and the additional cost of Co-RA. We would like to follow up on our response and ask whether our clarifications and additional experiments have addressed your main concerns. If any questions remain, we would be happy to provide further details.

We would greatly appreciate it if you could take our response into consideration in your final assessment.

Best regards, The Authors

Reviewer_DEqXOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates how to integrate token-level teacher guidance into RLVR. The authors propose Residual Advantage, which constructs local advantages from teacher–student probability differences and combines them with verifier advantages through a student-policy value baseline and response-level centering, allowing the teacher to redistribute credit within each response. Experiments on two Qwen3 student models and three mathematical benchmarks demonstrate improvements in average accuracy.

Critical strengths
  1. The method is simple and highly extensible. RA does not require an additional learned value model and can be directly integrated with GRPO and REINFORCE++. The paper also provides theoretical analysis establishing its boundedness and response-mean preservation properties.

  2. The experimental results are relatively consistent. RA achieves improvements across comparisons involving two model sizes, two RL algorithms, and three mathematical benchmarks. The paper also provides thorough ablation studies.

Critical weaknesses
  1. PowerOPD[1] has already investigated bounded probability-difference rewards, with q-p being a special case. Moreover, combining teacher guidance with RL has been explored in prior work, such as RLAD [2]. The paper does not sufficiently discuss these closely related works, making its motivation and novelty over existing approaches less clear.
  2. Insufficient comparisons with recent methods. The experiments mainly compare against standard OPD and the authors' own ablation variants, without comparisons to closely related methods such as PowerOPD.
  3. RA uses the probability difference q-p rather than the log-ratio, and its expected logit update is further scaled by the student's own probability. This may weaken the teacher's ability to correct confidently incorrect student decisions, particularly when the teacher-preferred tokens have very low probability under the student. The paper lacks targeted analysis or experiments to investigate whether RA can effectively transfer novel reasoning strategies beyond the student's existing preferences.
  4. Limited evaluation beyond mathematical reasoning. The experiments are restricted to MATH-500, AIME24, and AIME25. Evaluations on other verifiable tasks, such as code generation, are missing, leaving the method's cross-domain generalization unclear.

[1] Zhao A, Tong J, Fan Y, et al. PowerOPD: Stabilizing On-Policy Distillation with Bounded Power Transformation[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2606.17199, 2026. [2] Zhang Z, Jiang S, Shen Y, et al. Reinforcement-aware knowledge distillation for llm reasoning[J]. arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.22495, 2026.

Questions for authors
  1. What are the key differences between RA and prior methods such as PowerOPD, beyond the additional baselines and integration with RLVR? How much of the improvement can be attributed specifically to the proposed advantage construction?

  2. How does RA perform on verifiable tasks beyond mathematical reasoning, such as code generation? Could the authors provide additional experiments to demonstrate its cross-domain generalization?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Gentle reminder

Dear Reviewer DEqX,

Thank you again for your constructive comments and for raising the question of whether RA can help correct the student’s confident errors. We would like to follow up on our response and ask whether our clarifications and additional experiments have addressed your main concerns. If any questions remain, we would be happy to provide further details.

We would greatly appreciate it if you could take our response into consideration in your final assessment.

Best regards, The Authors

Thank you to the authors for the detailed response and additional experiments.

Regarding W1 and W2, I appreciate the new comparisons with PowerOPD and OPDVR, as well as the ablations on the advantage construction. These results demonstrate the practical value of RA. However, the improvement over PowerOPD remains relatively small, and the core method still overlaps considerably with existing OPD approaches. I am not fully convinced that the methodological novelty is sufficient.

Regarding W3, the confident-error analysis and Pass@512 results help address my concern, but they do not directly establish whether RA can help the student learn reasoning strategies that were previously difficult to explore.

Regarding W4, the additional text-to-SQL experiments largely address my concern about generalization beyond mathematical reasoning.

Overall, the rebuttal has strengthened the experimental evidence, but my main concern about the novelty of the method remains. I therefore lean toward keeping my original rating (Weak Reject).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

A Sincere Response to Reviewer DEqX

Dear Reviewer DEqX,

Thank you for your thorough and insightful follow-up comments, and for recognizing both the practical value of RA demonstrated in our additional experiments and the effectiveness of our text-to-SQL experiments in addressing cross-domain generalization. We understand that your primary remaining concern centers on the novelty of our approach. Below, we address this in three parts by further clarifying our experimental results, our perspective on W3, and the core methodological contributions of our work.

1. Regarding the comparison with PowerOPD, we acknowledge that the margin in average accuracy is relatively modest, but RA demonstrates a much clearer advantage in problem-solving coverage.

Method (matched 1-response/prompt budget)Avg@8Pass@8
PowerOPD, α=500\alpha=50028.7242.13
REINFORCE++25.6739.44
RA + REINFORCE++29.2545.20

As shown in the table (all evaluated at the matched 1-response/prompt budget), RA+REINFORCE++ outperforms PowerOPD by 0.53 points on Avg@8 (a margin that is indeed small); however, on Pass@8, it achieves a notable lead of 3.07 points. Separately, under GRPO's 8-response/prompt budget (Table 1), adding RA also raises GRPO from 27.49 / 40.40 to 29.86 Avg@8 / 44.75 Pass@8 (+2.37 / +4.35), showing that the gain transfers consistently across RLVR estimators.

2. Regarding W3, we agree that these results do not directly prove that RA enables the student model to acquire previously hard-to-explore reasoning strategies.

Our confident-error analysis and Pass@512 results indicate that RA broadens the model's problem-solving coverage, while also showing that probability-residual-based guidance does not exhibit any noticeable disadvantage in confident errors compared to the log-ratio. Nevertheless, these constitute outcome-level evidence and cannot yet directly reveal the underlying mechanism by which new reasoning strategies are formed. Accordingly, we have tempered our claims in the revised manuscript, carefully framing our explanation of exploration mechanisms as a hypothesis, and added a discussion on the limitations of sampled-token-based guidance.

3. Regarding novelty and motivation, we would like to clarify that RA's primary contribution lies in the structural integration of teacher guidance into RLVR (RL with Verifiable Rewards), rather than the bounded residual q−pq-p itself.

Although both the recent PowerOPD and RA adopt a bounded residual as an alternative to the log-ratio, the residual serves merely as a carrier and is not the core innovation of RA. RA was motivated by a fundamental challenge we face in industrial post-training with RLVR: how can we assign credit to intermediate decisions when the environment evaluates only the response as a whole? In our view, the key innovation of RA is treating the teacher model as an advantage-level, Critic-like role, effectively translating the discrepancy between the teacher and student into relative advantage estimates for local actions. This achieves a deep integration of teacher guidance with RL, fundamentally differing from sparse gating (OPDVR) or trust-region modification (RLAD).

PowerOPD and OPDVR essentially still treat the teacher as a global supervision target (as in PowerOPD) or a local one (as in OPDVR), rendering them variants of knowledge distillation. Consequently, they do not unduly overlap with RA in terms of research positioning. Admittedly, RA may intuitively resemble OPD-style methods in incorporating a teacher model and using a similar residual to replace the log-ratio; however, RA is rooted in RLVR rollouts, verifier advantages, and policy gradient frameworks. At its core, it remains a reinforcement learning approach rather than a distillation method aimed solely at approximating the teacher.

We truly value your insights and hope these clarifications help address your remaining concerns. As the discussion period draws to a close, we remain at your disposal should you have any final thoughts, and we sincerely appreciate the time, effort, and careful consideration you have dedicated throughout the review process, as well as your longstanding contributions to the academic community.

Best regards,
The Authors

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

gental reminder

Dear Reviewer DEqX,

Thank you again for engaging in the discussion and sharing your follow-up feedback. As the rebuttal and discussion period is drawing to a close, we would like to gently follow up on our latest response regarding RA's Pass@8 margin over PowerOPD and its methodological distinction in RLVR credit assignment, and ask whether these clarifications help address your remaining concern about novelty. If any questions remain before the deadline, we would be happy to provide further details.

We would greatly appreciate it if you could take our follow-up response into consideration in your final assessment.

Best regards, The Authors

Reviewer_97niOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Residual Advantage (RA), a method for incorporating token-level teacher guidance into reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards. At each student-visited prefix, RA treats the teacher–student probability difference as an immediate reward and subtracts its expectation under the student policy:

Atd=(qt−pt)(at)−⟨pt,qt−pt⟩.A_t^d = (q_t-p_t)(a_t)-\langle p_t,q_t-p_t\rangle.

It then centers these local advantages within each response and adds the resulting guidance to the verifier advantage:

\qquad \sum_t c_t A_t = A^V.$$ Co-RA additionally updates a teacher LoRA adapter using verifier advantages on the same student-generated batch. The updated teacher supplies guidance in the following iteration. The paper analyzes the relationship between the local residual advantage and squared-distance descent, establishes boundedness and response-centering identities, and evaluates the method with two Qwen3 students, a Qwen3-8B teacher, and both GRPO and REINFORCE++. RA improves all 24 reported benchmark–metric means over the corresponding verifier-only estimators across three training seeds, increasing macro Avg@8 by 1.74–3.58 percentage points. Co-RA further improves average accuracy, although its effects on Pass@8 are mixed.
Critical strengths
  1. The guidance construction has a clear and verifiable mathematical structure.

    The probability residual corresponds to a local squared-distance gradient, while the exact student value baseline and response centering operate at the action and response-position levels, respectively. Section 2 and Appendix A carefully distinguish orthogonality in label space from orthogonality of parameter gradients, including counterexamples and explicit assumptions. This makes both the contribution and its limitations comparatively easy to assess.

  2. The controlled experiments support the specific design choices.

    Table 1 reports improvements across two student sizes and two RLVR estimators. Tables 2–3 and Appendix D include results across three training seeds, weight sweeps, direct squared-distance losses, centered and clipped log-ratio guidance, and sequential distillation followed by RL. For the 1.7B REINFORCE++ setting, RA achieves macro Avg@8 of 29.25±0.2529.25 \pm 0.25, compared with 25.67±0.6625.67 \pm 0.66 for verifier-only training, 28.02±0.3128.02 \pm 0.31 for the direct squared-distance loss, and 28.04±0.2828.04 \pm 0.28 for the best reported clipped, centered log-ratio configuration. These comparisons provide stronger evidence than a comparison with teacher-only OPD alone.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The incremental value over the closest existing methods has not been directly established.

    Section 5 discusses methods such as OPDVR that already combine teacher guidance with outcome feedback, but the experiments primarily compare teacher-only OPD, constructed log-ratio controls, and sequential or joint objectives. OPDVR conditions the teacher reward on verifier outcomes, so outperforming teacher-only distillation does not establish an advantage over this closely related approach. The existing log-ratio controls are useful, but they do not reproduce that outcome-conditioned rule. A comparison with at least one closely related method under the same teacher, data, and generation budget is important for assessing the practical significance of the proposed construction.

  2. Preserving the mean label does not establish verifier dominance or exploration preservation in the actual update.

    Equation (6) is a deterministic identity about labels. Appendices A.3 and A.7 acknowledge that teacher guidance can reverse an update direction. The fixed-prefix scaling by p(b)(1−p(b))p(b)(1-p(b)) does not provide a general exploration guarantee in parameter space, and response centering can transfer guidance from other positions to a confident position. Appendices B.2–B.9 also explain that random response lengths and batch token weights in the actual implementation fall outside the full assumptions of Proposition 4. The evidence therefore supports the effectiveness of this training recipe in the evaluated settings, but the broader exploration interpretation remains unproven. Its practical value is also difficult to assess without wall-clock and peak-memory measurements, particularly for Co-RA, which adds teacher-adapter training.

Questions for authors
  1. Assessment-critical validation: How does RA compare with an outcome-conditioned teacher-guidance method such as OPDVR under the same teacher, training data, and generation budget? If this comparison has already been conducted, please provide the results. It would directly affect the assessment of the incremental contribution.

  2. Clarification and assessment-critical validation: Which statements about preserving exploration are intended as hypotheses rather than established properties? Can the reported training diagnostics clarify how teacher–verifier gradient conflicts, policy entropy, or confidently incorrect predictions evolve during training? The existing Pass@512 evaluation and gradient diagnostics are useful, but their limited settings do not independently establish the proposed mechanism.

  3. Clarification: What are the additional generated-token cost, total GPU time, and peak memory of RA and Co-RA relative to their corresponding verifier-only baselines? In a representative setting with a fixed total compute budget, does Co-RA retain its additional accuracy advantage? This question concerns the practical value of the added teacher computation rather than an extension to new application domains.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer 97ni

We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and the precise questions.

Q1 / W1 (comparison with OPDVR). Thank you for this suggestion. Under the same teacher, training data and generation budget, RA outperforms OPDVR by 1.28 Avg@8 and 3.47 Pass@8. We reproduced OPDVR as defined in its Sec. 4.2, with the same optimizer settings for every method. Because we take one optimizer step per rollout batch, our surrogate reduces exactly to OPDVR's per-token objective. We also include PowerOPD, which Reviewer DEqX raised.

MethodAvg@8Pass@8
OPD, sampled token24.8038.60
OPD, full vocabulary27.4541.30
OPD, then REINFORCE++28.3943.61
OPDVR27.9741.73
PowerOPD, α=50028.7242.13
RA + REINFORCE++29.2545.20

Each of RA's three seeds scores above OPDVR on both metrics. OPDVR gates the teacher's log ratio by correctness, so the teacher remains the only per-token signal and the outcome fixes the sign of every token's label. RA keeps the verifier advantage as the mean label of each response, and the teacher only redistributes credit within the response. We will add this comparison to §3.

Q3 (cost; Co-RA at fixed compute). RA and Co-RA add no generation passes; the teacher only scores the student's own tokens in a single forward pass. Measured on 8×H20 for the 1.7B runs:

REINFORCE++RACo-RAOPD
GPU-hours110175265220
Seconds per 1k tokens0.500.550.780.52
Peak memory per GPU (GB)22253124
Mean response length (tokens)3,2114,5934,7355,522

Per token, RA costs about 10% more than REINFORCE++. All runs generate the same 34,560 responses, so most of the remaining difference in GPU-hours comes from RA's longer responses; the responses of teacher-only OPD are longer still. Co-RA's adapter update adds about 40% per token over RA and 6 GB of peak memory. To compare at equal compute, we evaluated Co-RA at its saved checkpoint closest to RA's compute (step 180), averaging over three seeds:

GPU-hoursAvg@8Pass@8
RA (step 270)17529.345.2
Co-RA (step 180)17129.745.3
Co-RA (step 270)26530.746.4

With slightly less compute than RA, Co-RA retains a smaller advantage. The rest of its gain requires the additional compute, so we present Co-RA as an optional extension for when that compute is available.

W2 / Q2 (which statements are hypotheses). We agree: our experiments do not fully establish that RA preserves exploration, and the revision will narrow these statements. Concretely, we separate three kinds of statements:

  • Exact, with no assumptions: the response-mean identity (Eq. 6), the orthogonal split of the label (Eq. 7) and the bounds on the guidance term (Eq. 8).
  • Conditional: Prop. 1(ii) holds at a fixed prefix, in logit coordinates, at the rollout policy, and says nothing about entropy, exploration or a finite parameter step (App. A.3). Prop. 4 assumes a fixed horizon and trajectory-independent token weights; our implementation falls outside these assumptions (App. B.2), so it describes the long responses that carry most tokens and does not guarantee the actual update. Centering also places −λA‾d-\lambda\overline A^d on every position, confident ones included; its SD is below 0.03 on responses longer than 1,000 tokens and 0.32 on shorter ones (Table 16).
  • Hypotheses: that the confidence scaling helps RA preserve exploration (§6), and the interpretive sentences in §4.3 and §4.4. They will read, e.g., "which we hypothesize helps RA preserve exploration; our experiments do not isolate this mechanism." We also do not claim that the verifier dominates the parameter update; App. A.3 gives a case where the teacher reverses the net direction of an expected logit update.

The training diagnostics of Table 17 (three seeds) are consistent with the exploration interpretation, but they do not isolate policy entropy or confident errors as the mechanism:

Diagnostic (Table 17)Value
Batches with negative teacher–verifier gradient cosine26%
Teacher's share of the update after clipping and Adam0.30 → 0.25 over training
Cosine between the update and the verifier-only step0.92–0.94

We are happy to provide further details.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Gentle reminder

Dear Reviewer 97ni,

Thank you again for your constructive comments, especially your suggestion to compare RA with OPDVR under the same training budget. We would like to follow up on our response and ask whether our clarifications and additional experiments have addressed your main concerns. If any questions remain, we would be happy to provide further details.

We would greatly appreciate it if you could take our response into consideration in your final assessment.

Best regards, The Authors

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

gental reminder

Dear Reviewer 97ni,

Thank you again for your constructive comments, especially your suggestions to compare RA with OPDVR under the same training budget and to evaluate Co-RA at matched compute. As the rebuttal and discussion period is drawing to a close, we would like to gently follow up on our response and ask whether our clarifications and additional experiments have addressed your main concerns. If any questions remain before the deadline, we would be happy to provide further details.

We would greatly appreciate it if you could take our response into consideration in your final assessment.

Best regards, The Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.