- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes mmSLP, a semantic-level privacy protection framework for mmWave human activity recognition (HAR) that suppresses sensitive-activity recognition while preserving normal-activity utility. The key idea is to inject class-wise perturbations only into sensitive fine-tuning samples, inducing shortcut learning that degrades recognition of clean sensitive activities. To reduce computational overhead, mmSLP combines error-minimizing and perturbation–target binding objectives with lightweight first-order optimization. Experiments across three datasets and multiple architectures show that mmSLP reduces sensitive-activity accuracy from 85.41% to 42.12%, while maintaining normal-activity with low computational overhead.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses an important privacy concern in mmWave-based HAR by enabling selective protection of user-defined sensitive activities while preserving normal-activity recognition. This fine-grained privacy–utility trade-off is more practical than indiscriminately disabling activity recognition and represents a meaningful research direction.
- The proposed method is conceptually straightforward, using class-wise perturbations and a first-order approximation without requiring an additional perturbation generator or higher-order gradient computation. This lightweight design reduces computational and memory overhead while maintaining effective sensitive-activity suppression, making it potentially suitable for resource-constrained user-side deployment.
Critical weaknesses
- I notice that the Random Noise baseline uses independently sampled noise for each sensitive sample, which fundamentally differs from the proposed class-wise shared perturbations. The authors should evaluate fixed class-wise random perturbations and a single perturbation shared across all sensitive classes, which may induce shortcut learning without any additional optimization. These comparisons are crucial to establish whether the gains come from the proposed optimization or merely from consistent perturbation patterns.
- The perturbation budget η = 0.2 allows an L2 distortion of up to 44.7% of the original signal norm, raising concerns that the observed protection may stem from obscuring the original signals rather than inducing shortcut learning. The authors should evaluate replacing sensitive samples entirely with constant-valued signals as an unconstrained reference to investigate whether the proposed optimization is truly necessary.
- The proposed binding objective is closely related to BAIT (ICLR 2026), yet BAIT is only discussed in the related work and not directly evaluated. Recent open-source unlearnable-example methods, such as Versatile Transferable Unlearnable Example Generator (NeurIPS 2025), also provide relevant methodological comparisons. Although these methods were originally developed for different modalities, adapting them to the same radar datasets, sensitive-activity partitions, and downstream fine-tuning protocols would help establish the novelty and effectiveness of mmSLP.
- The ablation studies mainly investigate computational efficiency, including generator-based perturbations and first-order versus second-order optimization. However, the paper does not isolate the contributions of the error-minimizing loss, binding loss, and surrogate adaptation.
- Appendix Table 6 shows that simply withholding sensitive samples already reduces sensitive-activity accuracy to 52.02%, compared with 42.12% for mmSLP, while achieving slightly better normal-activity accuracy (88.35% vs. 88.09%). The authors should justify whether this additional 9.90 percentage-point reduction warrants the extra computation and disclosure of labeled sensitive data.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors evaluate fixed class-wise random perturbations, a single shared perturbation across sensitive classes, and constant-template replacement, to determine whether the proposed optimization is necessary? Additionally, could complete signal replacement be evaluated as an unconstrained reference to distinguish shortcut learning from simple signal destruction?
- Could the authors compare mmSLP with adapted implementations of recent closely related methods, particularly BAIT (ICLR 2026) and VTG (NeurIPS 2025), under identical radar datasets, perturbation budgets, and downstream evaluation protocols? If such comparisons are infeasible, could the authors explain the specific technical incompatibilities?
- Could the authors provide ablations for (i) error-minimizing loss only, (ii) binding loss only, and (iii) optimization without temporary surrogate adaptation?
- The choices of = 3.5, = 0.1, and = 2 lack sufficient justification. Could the authors provide a systematic sensitivity analysis to demonstrate that the results are robust rather than dependent on carefully tuned hyperparameters?
8 comments
[Q4] Response
We thank the reviewer for suggesting a sensitivity analysis. On XRF55 with ResNet-18 and RDRA inputs, we halved and doubled the weights of the binding and error-minimization losses around their default values. Sensitivity to the binding and error-minimization loss weights in the earlier implementation.
| Setting | Normal acc. (%) ↑ | Sensitive acc. (%) ↓ | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sweep default | 3.5 | 0.10 | 92.13 | 40.16 |
| Binding weight halved | 1.75 | 0.10 | 92.50 | 40.78 |
| Binding weight doubled | 7.0 | 0.10 | 92.44 | 41.72 |
| Error-minimization weight halved | 3.5 | 0.05 | 92.25 | 41.41 |
| Error-minimization weight doubled | 3.5 | 0.20 | 92.75 | 41.25 |
Across the tested settings, normal-activity accuracy varied by at most percentage points and sensitive-activity accuracy by at most percentage points. The default pair yielded the lowest sensitive-activity accuracy in this sweep, with similar performance at the neighboring settings. For , Table~7 in the appendix section \emph{Effect of Normal-Activity Weighting} compares equal weighting () with the main-table setting (). For ResNet-18, increasing from to raised normal-activity accuracy from to and lowered sensitive-activity accuracy from to . ConvLSTM and ViT showed the same direction of change. Performance was relatively stable when varying or . The comparison of and likewise preserved the overall utility--privacy trade-off, suggesting that the reported results do not depend on a narrowly tuned choice of these weights.
[W5] Response
We thank the reviewer for highlighting this trade-off. We agree that withholding sensitive samples is an effective and low-cost baseline to some extent. It achieves slightly higher average non-sensitive-class accuracy than mmSLP (88.35% vs. 88.09%) and does not require perturbation generation or the sharing of sensitive samples. However, the value of mmSLP lies in providing additional protection when withholding sensitive samples alone does not sufficiently meet users' privacy requirements, by further reducing the recognition accuracy of sensitive activities.
The average reduction of 9.90 percentage points also masks substantially larger improvements in certain settings. For example, on Deep-Soli, mmSLP reduces sensitive-class accuracy from 56.54% to 36.94%, while decreasing non-sensitive-class accuracy by only 1.29 percentage points. With ResNet-18, mmSLP achieves an additional reduction of 29.32 percentage points in sensitive-class accuracy, with only a 0.63-percentage-point decrease in non-sensitive-class accuracy. Furthermore, across all 15 experimental configurations, mmSLP consistently achieves lower average sensitive-class accuracy than fine-tuning with only non-sensitive data, demonstrating the consistency of its additional privacy protection benefits.
Regarding computational overhead, under the reported XRF55 configuration, perturbation generation takes approximately 1.75 minutes per user on average. This process is performed before sharing the fine-tuning data and does not require perturbations to be repeatedly applied to future measurements.
We look forward to your further feedback. Thank you again for your time and consideration, and we wish you all the best.
I thank the authors for their additional experiments and clarifications. However, I still have the following concerns:
- For the fixed class-wise random perturbation baseline, I expect one fixed random perturbation per sensitive class, with an L2 norm of up to 44.7% of the original signal norm (similar to η = 0.2), applied to all samples of that class. Similarly, the globally shared baseline should apply one fixed random perturbation to all sensitive classes. Could the authors provide implementation details and confirm whether the mean and variant of random variable follow these settings?
- Theoretically, such fixed class-wise random perturbations should be sufficient to induce shortcut learning, since the model only needs to recognize a distinctive random vector to identify the corresponding activity class. However, the reported results show the opposite. Could the authors provide a detailed explanation and further experimental evidence to support their findings?
- The additional comparisons with BAIT and VTG largely address my original concern. However, the discussion lacks a direct analysis of mmSLP relative to these methods, particularly an explanation of mmSLP's advantages and methodological contributions.
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the significance of selective privacy protection and the lightweight design of our method. In response to your suggestions, we have added experiments on shared random perturbations and signal replacement, adapted comparisons with BAIT and VTG, ablation studies of key components, and sensitivity analyses of loss weights. We have also further discussed the additional benefits, computational overhead, and data disclosure trade-offs of mmSLP compared with withholding sensitive data.
[W1 W2 Q1] Response
Thank you for suggesting these controls. We evaluated shared random perturbations and complete signal replacement on XRF55 using ResNet18 with RDRA, RD, and RA inputs. All methods used the same user splits and downstream fine-tuning protocol. We modified only the sensitive samples in the fine-tuning set and evaluated the resulting models on clean test samples.
Shared random perturbations and unconstrained signal replacement on XRF55. Each cell reports normal-activity accuracy (higher is better) / sensitive-activity accuracy (lower is better), both in percent.
Shared random perturbations. Sensitive-activity accuracy remained between 75.94% and 85.94% across the random baselines. Sharing a fixed random perturbation within each sensitive class or across all sensitive classes did not consistently improve protection over independent noise under the same budget cap.
Complete signal replacement. As shown in the table, unconstrained constant and zero replacement yielded mean sensitive-activity recognition accuracies of 63.8% and 57.5%, respectively, both higher than that of mmSLP. Thus, under the perturbation budget, mmSLP suppressed sensitive-activity recognition more effectively than complete signal replacement.
[W3 Q2] Response
We thank the reviewer for suggesting these comparisons. We adapted both methods to XRF55 by perturbing only sensitive fine-tuning samples and using the same relative perturbation budget cap (η=0.2) and downstream fine-tuning protocol. For BAIT, we retained its perturbation generator, binding objective, and second-order surrogate optimization. For VTG, we used an adversarial radar gain field for domain augmentation and radar class prototypes in place of CLIP text embeddings for perturbation--label alignment.
Radar adaptations of BAIT and VTG on XRF55. Each cell reports normal / sensitive activity accuracy (%).
Across RDRA, RD, and RA inputs, BAIT achieved normal-activity recognition accuracies of 91.00% to 92.31% and sensitive-activity recognition accuracies of 58.13% to 64.69%. For VTG, the corresponding ranges were 90.17% to 91.56% and 73.91% to 81.88%, respectively.
These results suggest that, in the evaluated settings, both adaptations preserved normal-activity recognition accuracy while providing limited suppression of sensitive-activity recognition on clean test samples. In the VTG adaptation, a radar gain field and radar class prototypes replaced the original domain augmentation and label alignment mechanisms, respectively. These changes may affect how well the learned perturbations transfer to downstream models.
[W4 Q3] Response
We thank the reviewer for asking us to isolate the contributions of the two loss terms and temporary surrogate adaptation. In the ResNet18--RDRA setting on XRF55, the full mmSLP configuration in the main table achieved 94.50% normal-activity accuracy and 40.16% sensitive-activity accuracy. EM-only removes the binding loss from the perturbation objective, whereas Binding-only removes the error-minimization loss. The third ablation disables temporary surrogate adaptation while retaining the persistent surrogate updates.
Ablations on XRF55 with ResNet18 and RDRA inputs. Approximate values are provisional. Dashes indicate values pending verification.
The provisional results suggest that the full objective suppresses sensitive-activity recognition more effectively than either loss alone.