- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
LOPA is a privacy-preserving framework for Split Federated Learning (SFL). It constructs task-relevant local subspaces from between-class and within-class scatter statistics, and calibrates them using classification loss together with distance correlation. The locally learned projection matrices are then aggregated into a shared subspace. During online training, this subspace is kept fixed and used to filter the intermediate representations uploaded from clients to the server. Experiments on CelebA, CIFAR-10, and FMNIST under FORA and Inverse-Network reconstruction attacks show that LOPA substantially reduces reconstruction quality while maintaining classification accuracy comparable to, or slightly better than, undefended SFL.
Critical strengths
A clear strength of LOPA is its balance between privacy protection and classification utility. The method constructs subspaces from local class statistics and calibrates them with distance correlation, which reduces the risk of reconstructing sensitive inputs from intermediate representations while maintaining competitive classification accuracy.
Critical weaknesses
- The evaluation uses only three clients, which is not sufficient to establish scalability in large-scale split federated learning systems. Because LOPA aggregates locally learned projection matrices into a shared subspace, increasing the number of clients may raise communication overhead and lead to more heterogeneous local subspaces. However, the paper does not examine whether classification accuracy and reconstruction resistance remain stable as the number of participating clients grows.
- Appendix A.2.2 reports the cost of offline subspace construction, but the online overhead introduced by feature filtering and backward propagation is not analyzed. LOPA also requires clients to transmit local projection matrices, while the uploaded intermediate representations retain their original dimensions. A comparison with standard SFL in terms of computation, end-to-end training time, and communication would help assess whether LOPA is practical for resource-constrained clients.
Questions for authors
- How does the aggregation mechanism behave as the number of clients and the degree of data heterogeneity increase? Are classification accuracy and reconstruction resistance maintained under these conditions?
- The authors should report the end-to-end online overhead, including feature filtering, backward propagation, and projection-matrix communication, relative to standard SFL.
- The rationale for selecting δ = 1.0001 in Eq. (5) is not fully explained. Was this value adopted from prior work or determined empirically? A sensitivity analysis over δ would help clarify its effect on accuracy, reconstruction resistance, and training stability.
- Although the paper compares LOPA with Dropout and B-SL, it does not provide direct comparisons with NoPeek and ResSFL, which are discussed in the related work section. NoPeek also employs distance-correlation-based regularization, while ResSFL addresses reconstruction attacks in split federated learning. The authors should clarify why these methods were excluded and provide comparisons under matched experimental settings.