- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, a new method called simulator refined diffusion (SRD) is proposed to solve the RF PCB inverse design. In view of the contradiction between full wave simulator (accurate but expensive and non differentiable) and differentiable proxy model (cheap but with distribution offset), SRD combines the two in the final stage of diffusion sampling. Specifically, SRD uses CenterNet to extract the diffusion prediction as a low dimensional structured rectangle parameter, proposes the editing direction using the gradient of the proxy model, and then uses the limited simulator budget to evaluate a small number of candidates in this direction (or reverse/random direction), selects the geometry with the least simulation loss, and injects it into the diffusion trajectory through the "Write back & Renoise" mechanism.
Critical strengths
1.In this paper, the gradient of surrogate is used to generate candidate directions, and then the palm simulator is used to select them. In view of the contradiction between full wave simulator (accurate but expensive and non differentiable) and differentiable proxy model (cheap but with distribution offset), SRD skillfully combines the two in the final stage of diffusion sampling.
Critical weaknesses
Weakness 1: Insufficient Justification for Using a Single Surrogate Gradient Direction
The proposed method computes a single surrogate gradient at the current geometry and generates multiple candidates by exploring different step sizes along the resulting direction. However, this restricts the surrogate-guided search to a fixed direction, even though the surrogate is differentiable and inexpensive to evaluate. A natural alternative would be to iteratively recompute the surrogate gradient and update the rectangle parameters, while respecting the same geometric admissibility requirements. Importantly, rather than relying solely on the final optimized geometry, several intermediate geometries along the optimization trajectory could be collected as candidates and evaluated by the full-wave simulator. This would allow the search to explore changing gradient directions while retaining simulator-based selection to mitigate surrogate inaccuracies. The paper does not compare against such an iterative surrogate-guided candidate generation strategy under the same simulator-call budget. Consequently, it remains unclear whether restricting candidate generation to a single surrogate gradient direction is preferable to exploring a sequence of surrogate-guided geometric updates.
Weakness 2: Unclear Necessity of Performing Refinement During Diffusion Sampling
The proposed method performs simulator-based refinement during the final denoising steps. However, it remains unclear whether integrating refinement into diffusion sampling provides an advantage over applying the same refinement procedure after diffusion has completed. Since the proposed method operates on extracted geometric parameters, its candidate generation and simulator-based selection strategies could also be applied directly to the final generated PCB layout.
A more appropriate comparison would be single-step (what the authors do in the maintext) and multi-step post-hoc refinement using exactly the same candidate search strategies (directional, adaptive, or hybrid) as SRD, under the same simulator-call budget. In the multi-step setting, each refinement round would start from the previously selected geometry, recompute the surrogate gradient, and generate a new set of candidates using the original SRD search procedure. This would allow the optimization direction to change across rounds without involving additional diffusion steps.
Such a comparison is particularly important because subsequent denoising may modify the simulator-selected geometry and potentially diminish the improvements obtained from refinement. Furthermore, the RENOISE operation inherently injects noise back into the simulator-selected geometry, which risks introducing artifacts or pushing the state off the natural data manifold. Without these controlled post-hoc baselines, it is difficult to determine whether the reported improvements arise from performing refinement within diffusion sampling or simply from repeated surrogate-guided candidate search and simulator-based selection.
Weakness 3: Unclear Noise Magnitude and Reliability of Geometry Extraction at Intermediate Diffusion Steps
The diffusion process introduces Gaussian noise into clean PCB layouts during training, causing the noisy states to deviate from the original clean-layout distribution. Although SRD applies CenterNet to the predicted clean layouts rather than directly to the noisy states, these intermediate predictions may still contain reconstruction errors. However, the paper does not quantify how much noise remains at the final denoising steps where refinement is performed. The authors should report the Gaussian noise schedule used during diffusion training, the corresponding noise standard deviation or signal-to-noise ratio at each refinement timestep, and whether CenterNet was exposed to similarly corrupted inputs during its training.
This leads to two concerns. If the intermediate predictions still differ substantially from clean layouts, the CenterNet extractor, which is trained on rasterized PCB layouts, may suffer from a distribution shift. In this case, why not train a timestep-aware geometry extractor on intermediate diffusion predictions, analogous to the noise-aware classifier used in classifier guidance? If the differences are negligible, it is unclear whether CenterNet can resolve such small geometric variations, particularly if its training images were quantized to 8-bit grayscale. More importantly, if the geometries barely change during the final denoising steps, what advantage does intermediate refinement offer over applying the same geometric refinement directly to the final generated layout?
The authors should quantify the changes in predicted layouts and extracted rectangle parameters across the final denoising steps, clarify CenterNet's training input precision, and evaluate its sensitivity to small geometric variations. These results are necessary to justify both the reliability of geometry extraction and the choice of refinement timesteps.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses
6 comments
W3a: If the intermediate predictions still differ substantially from clean layouts, the CenterNet extractor, which is trained on rasterized PCB layouts, may suffer from a distribution shift.
Note that CenterNet is never applied to the noisy diffusion state . At each guided step it is invoked on clean samples , i.e., the model's current estimate of the final design.
In our experiments we did not observe degradation of the rectangle extraction at the guided steps. Had extraction been unreliable, it would surface as malformed geometries and elevated simulation failure rates. SRD's failure rate (0.5% of final designs) matches that of the non-guided methods, and its seed-level variability (±0.009) is comparable to the baselines.
However, we agree that there is no guarantee against distribution shift. CenterNet may degrade on predictions far from its training distribution. In developing the method we also evaluated traditional CV extraction (e.g., watershed segmentation) and CenterNet proved more robust on our layouts. We have added this limitation to Section 7 where we also note our intention to explore more compact representations (e.g., diffusion directly in rectangle space), which would remove the need for CenterNet altogether.
W3b: If the geometries barely change during the final denoising steps, what advantage does intermediate refinement offer over applying the same geometric refinement directly to the final generated layout?
Starting refinement before the final steps gives the remaining denoising steps the chance to act on the edit. The prior can repair artifacts the geometric edit introduces and adapt to it, including changes that no local rectangle perturbation can express.
We’d like to, again, express our appreciation for your time reviewing our work. We believe that our responses have addressed each concern raised, but we are happy to engage in further discussion if any questions remain. Thank you.
Issues Addressed by the Revision
W1: Insufficient Justification for Using Only a Single Surrogate Gradient Direction
The authors have addressed this concern by introducing a multiple-surrogate-gradient variant in their rebuttal. The additional results show that repeatedly recomputing surrogate gradients improves performance on in-distribution targets but leads to worse performance on OOD targets, suggesting that repeatedly following potentially inaccurate surrogate gradients can accumulate errors under distribution shift.
This provides useful empirical evidence supporting the proposed strategy of using a single surrogate-proposed direction and relying on simulator feedback to determine whether and how to continue the search. I consider this concern largely addressed. However, I encourage the authors to incorporate the additional experiment and its implementation details into the revised manuscript for completeness and reproducibility.
Remaining Weaknesses
W2: Unclear Necessity of Performing Refinement During Diffusion Sampling
The revised manuscript has improved the discussion of diffusion-time refinement and added a comparison with post-hoc refinement in Figure 5 and Appendix A.5. In particular, the authors provide a qualitative example showing that subsequent denoising can repair artifacts introduced by local geometric edits, such as gaps and non-uniform conductor widths. This offers a reasonable explanation of how the diffusion prior can complement local geometric optimization.
However, the current post-hoc baseline performs refinement only once after diffusion sampling. It remains unclear whether the advantage of SRD comes specifically from integrating refinement into the diffusion process or simply from repeatedly applying surrogate-guided geometric optimization with simulator-based candidate selection.
A more conclusive comparison would involve multi-step post-hoc refinement using exactly the same candidate generation and selection strategies as SRD (directional, adaptive, or hybrid). After each refinement round, the surrogate gradient should be recomputed at the previously selected geometry, and a new candidate set should be generated using the original SRD procedure. The total number of simulator calls should be matched.
This comparison is important because the authors attribute the improvement of in-loop refinement to the diffusion prior's ability to repair and adapt local geometric edits. However, it remains unclear whether this advantage is specific to diffusion-time refinement or could also be achieved through multi-step post-hoc geometric optimization. Such a controlled comparison would better isolate the contribution of the diffusion prior.
W3: Unclear Noise Magnitude and Geometric Stability of Intermediate Diffusion Predictions
The proposed method applies CenterNet to predicted clean layouts at intermediate denoising steps to extract rectangle geometry. However, the paper does not specify the actual Gaussian noise schedule used during diffusion training or quantify the noise levels associated with the refinement timesteps.
The authors should report the noise schedule used during diffusion training, including the corresponding beta values, cumulative noise levels, and noise standard deviations or signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs). In particular, the specific values at the final two denoising steps on the test set (steps 19–20) and the final four steps on the OOD set (steps 17–20) should be provided.
Furthermore, the authors should quantify how the predicted clean layouts and their extracted rectangle parameters evolve across denoising timesteps along ordinary diffusion sampling trajectories without any SRD refinement. In particular, the analysis should cover steps 17–20 for the OOD set and steps 19–20 for the test set. Specifically, reporting the changes in extracted rectangle centers, widths, and heights across these timesteps, as well as the geometric differences between intermediate predicted layouts and the final generated layouts, would help establish the geometric stability of ordinary diffusion trajectories and assess whether CenterNet can reliably extract geometric information from intermediate predictions.
These analyses would help clarify the noise characteristics of the selected refinement timesteps, assess the reliability of geometry extraction from intermediate diffusion predictions, and justify the choice of performing refinement at these particular stages.
Many thanks for your detailed assessment of our manuscript. We are pleased to read of your appreciation for our novel combination of the surrogate model and full-wave simulator, which is integral to the strong empirical performance reported. Below, we have responded to each concern raised in your assessment.
W1: Insufficient Justification for Using a Single Surrogate Gradient Direction
Thank you for this suggestion. To test whether one surrogate direction is enough, we implemented a variant that recomputes the surrogate gradient for each candidate. At each guided denoising step, the predicted board is converted to a rectangle layout. After that, the rectangles are perturbed along the surrogate's descent direction, and recomputing the surrogate gradient. The original board and all perturbed candidates are simulated with Palace, and the best layout is written back before denoising continues. The budget is the same as SRD. The only difference is that SRD computes the gradient once and places its candidates along that single direction.
In the test set, where the surrogate is reliable, Multiple Surrogate Gradient follows the curved descent path more closely and lowers the test loss. Out of distribution, where the surrogate is much less reliable (Figure 1(c)), repeatedly following its gradient compounds errors and spends the simulator budget on poor candidates, so Multiple Surrogate Gradient is clearly worse than SRD (mean 0.4647 vs. 0.4346, median 0.4937 vs. 0.4082). This trade-off supports our design: committing to one direction and letting the simulator probe decide whether to follow it makes SRD more robust when the surrogate cannot be trusted.
W2: Unclear Necessity of Performing Refinement During Diffusion Sampling
We agree that the effect of refinement during the final denoising steps should be compared with post-hoc refinement. Indeed, we did include such an ablation in Figure 5. The left panel illustrates a single guidance step, which is equivalent to the post-hoc refinement baseline you described. We see that the benefit of additional simulator calls levels off quickly. In contrast, applying SRD at multiple diffusion steps results in notably stronger performance.
The unguided sample is too narrow and broken by a small gap. Post-hoc it closes the gap and widens one segment until it reaches the board edge, leaving a line of uneven width with 13 simulator calls. In SRD, the denoising step after each edit redraws the line as a single segment of uniform width, so the next search step widens the whole line, reaching a lower s-params loss with the same 13 calls.
We agree that this could be better emphasized in our paper. To make this clearer, we’ve added a new visualization to the Appendix A.5.