- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces diffusion guidance mechanism (AMG) for the Aerodynamic Design via Diffusion Models. In introduces adaptive guidance weights based on the pseudo-inverse of the Jacobian (of the target properties with respect to the noisy input). Experiments on the SuperWing dataset report improvements in surrogate-evaluated prediction error over several generative baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a practically relevant problem involving multiple aerodynamic operating conditions.
-
The method is straightforward to implement and does not require retraining the diffusion backbone for different target combinations.
Critical weaknesses
-
Novelty: The main contribution of this paper (Eqs. 15-17), is essentially a classical pseudoinverse correction applied during diffusion sampling. Closely related approaches already exist, including Pseudoinverse-Guided Diffusion Models [1] Physics-Constrained Flow Matching [2], and Geometry-Correct Diffusion Posterior Sampling [3]. The manuscript does not sufficiently distinguish its mathematical contribution from these approaches. Moreover, the formulation performs local least-squares correction without establishing a principled resolution of conflicting objectives.
-
Insufficient independent physical validation: another critical weakness is that the entire experiments rely on the setup where the same learned surrogate model is used for guidance and evaluation. Consequently, the reported improvements may partially reflect optimization of surrogate-specific errors rather than actual aerodynamic performance. Independent CFD evaluations of generated designs would substantially strengthen the experimental conclusions.
[1] Pseudoinverse-Guided Diffusion Models for Inverse Problems (Song et al., 2023 ICLR).
[2] Physics-Constrained Flow Matching: Sampling Generative Models with Hard Constraints (Utkarsh et al., NeurIPS 2025).
[3] Geometry-Correct Diffusion Posterior Sampling with Denoiser-Pullback Curvature Guidance and Manifold-Aligned Damping, (Shin et al., ICML 2026).
Questions for authors
-
Can authors elaborate the methodological novelty compared to the above related works [1]-[3]? To my understanding, this is training-free guidance [4]-[5] where instead of direct gradient used in the classical DPS [5], Pseudoinverse is utilized and this was investigated before in the literature.
-
Satisfying multiple desired properties is an important problem, but that should keep the original diffusion sampler's basic properties (e.g., TACS [6]). For instance, training-free control of the target properties could break the basic properties of the generated samples (which indirectly proved as measuring ratios of Invalid ones but this heuristic base counting is not enough). Can authors further investigate whether the method does not break the basic ability of the trained diffusion models?
-
Can author investigate another surrogate models (trained separately with another data) to check whether the current evaluation setup is reliable?
I am willing to raise my score if above concerns are resolved.
[4] TFG: Unified Training-Free Guidance for Diffusion Models (Ye et al., 2024 NeurIPS).
[5] Diffusion Posterior Sampling for General Noisy Inverse Problems (Chung et al., 2023 ICLR).
[6] Conditional Synthesis of 3D Molecules with Time Correction Sampler (Jung et al., 2024 NeurIPS).
2 comments
Thanks for the response. While the authors provide the relevant answer to my questions, it still doesn't resolve my original concerns of the novelty and in fact, the new experiments indicate the proposed result might be highly overfit to the surrogate reward models (very low Surrogate MAPE but not the lowest other metrics: CFD MAP, Shape distance). Therefore, i will keep my original score toward weak rejection.
Thank you for recognizing the practical relevance and ease of implementation, and for your suggestions on related work, generation quality, and independent evaluation. We acknowledge overlooking relevant image-domain research. We added ΠGDM, PCFM, and CLAMP (the method proposed in Geometry-Correct Diffusion Posterior Sampling), and included MMPS at the request of other reviewers.
1. Differences from related methods and the adaptive mechanism
These methods are closely related to AMG; pseudoinverse correction itself is not unique to our work.
AMG aims to determine multi-target guidance adaptively. It first specifies the desired aerodynamic change for the current step based on the target residuals and remaining sampling steps. It then uses the full local sensitivities to jointly determine each target's contribution and the overall latent correction magnitude, without searching for target weights or an additional global guidance strength for different target combinations.
ΠGDM constructs guidance through conditional-score approximation, PCFM applies constraint corrections during flow-based generation, and CLAMP constructs updates using curvature and damping. Their correction magnitudes are determined by their respective sampling updates, step sizes, or damping configurations. AMG instead explicitly incorporates how much the aerodynamic targets should change in the current step into the displacement solve, giving the correction magnitude a direct target-based interpretation under the local linear model.
The distinction is jointly determining multi-target coordination and correction magnitude through the full aerodynamic mapping, rather than introducing a pseudoinverse. We compare these methods on the same design tasks.
2. Generation quality and additional experiments
We agree that visual inspection and invalid-geometry counts alone cannot fully establish whether guidance preserves the original model's generation quality. Although some methods produce visibly distorted shapes, visual inspection did not reveal obvious self-intersections, negative thickness, or similar geometric validity issues in the generated geometries.
To further quantify whether generated shapes depart from the dataset distribution, we use a vertex-distance-based shape similarity measure: the RMS distance between corresponding vertices of a generated geometry and its nearest training geometry, normalized by the reference chord length. This supplements geometric validity checks with a quantitative assessment of overall shape similarity to the training data.
We also performed independent CFD evaluations using ADflow, with the main physical settings based on SuperWing and computational meshes reconstructed from the generated geometries. The results are summarized below.
The shape-distance reference for the held-out test geometries is 2.14%, compared with 1.92% for AMG, indicating that AMG-generated geometries remain close to the training data under this overall distance measure. Although ΠGDM achieves the lowest surrogate MAPE, visual inspection reveals severe geometric distortions, showing that minimizing surrogate target error alone does not ensure plausible designs.
This distance provides a coarse supplementary assessment of shape distribution shift. It is not a sufficient criterion for geometric validity and cannot by itself establish that the original generation distribution and diversity are fully preserved.
AMG's surrogate advantage is not retained in the current CFD evaluation. Some surrogate-guided methods exhibit lower surrogate target error but higher CFD target error, suggesting that optimization may exploit surrogate prediction errors. The underlying mechanism warrants further investigation.
Improving surrogate reliability is outside the main scope of this paper. This issue is not specific to AMG but is a shared risk for methods relying on surrogate models. In practical design, the surrogate can be replaced by a differentiable CFD solver to avoid this source of error from the learned predictor; we have not experimentally evaluated this replacement in the present work.
3. Independent evaluation
We use the ADflow evaluations above as the independent validation reference, rather than adding a second surrogate evaluation.
Thank you again. We welcome follow-up questions and will do our best to clarify any remaining concerns.