- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes CMLI, a framework for incomplete multi-view clustering (IMVC) that replaces conventional statistical imputation with a causal meta-learning imputation mechanism. The pipeline consists of: (i) view-specific autoencoders with an Information Bottleneck objective for compression and preservation; (ii) dual embeddings that construct view-specific causal graphs, which are refined via meta-learning into convolution kernels for imputing missing views; (iii) contrastive alignment between recovered and observed views; and (iv) an end-to-end cluster consistency learning module combining category-level contrastive loss and a KL-based high-confidence objective. Experiments on six datasets under multiple missing rates show consistent gains over eight IMVC baselines, with ablations and sensitivity analyses supporting the design.
Critical strengths
- Framing missing-view imputation as a causal discovery problem rather than a purely statistical correlation problem is a meaningful departure from existing DIMVC work. The critique that statistical imputation is vulnerable to confounders and view-private attributes is reasonable and well articulated.
- The overall framework is reasonably coherent. Combining representation compression, imputation, cross-view alignment, and end-to-end clustering is a meaningful design choice.
- The empirical evaluation is relatively broad, including six datasets, three missing rates, and multiple recent baselines. The proposed method achieves strong results on the main datasets, and the ablation study indicates that the imputation, information-bottleneck, and clustering-consistency components all contribute to performance.
Critical weaknesses
- The causal-graph construction is motivated by prior causal-discovery work using dual cause/effect-oriented embeddings. However, that mechanism was originally developed and empirically validated in a time-series Granger-causality setting, whereas CMLI constructs a graph over latent feature dimensions for clustering. The paper should more clearly explain why the causal interpretation transfers to this non-temporal feature setting, state the precise identifiability assumptions, and empirically distinguish the proposed causal graph from a generic learned dependency graph.
- The empirical results are reported as single values without standard deviations, confidence intervals, or the number of random runs. Since clustering outcomes and missing-pattern generation can be sensitive to random seeds, it is difficult to assess whether some improvements are statistically reliable.
- There are spelling errors and other non-standard writing issues present in the work.
Questions for authors
- The paper should more clearly explain why the causal interpretation transfers to this non-temporal feature setting, state the precise identifiability assumptions, and empirically distinguish the proposed causal graph from a generic learned dependency graph.
- The empirical results are reported as single values without standard deviations, confidence intervals, or the number of random runs. Since clustering outcomes and missing-pattern generation can be sensitive to random seeds, it is difficult to assess whether some improvements are statistically reliable. 3.What is the biggest difference from other current works? It's not very clear at the moment.
Clarified Scope, Reliability, and Novelty
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. We agree that the original causal framing was not sufficiently supported. We have therefore narrowed the paper's positioning and renamed our method GCDI, a predictive graph-conditioned dynamic-imputation framework rather than a causal discovery or causal-identification method.
Causal interpretation and dependency graph (W1/Q1). We agree that the previous formulation did not justify transferring a causal interpretation from time-series causal discovery to non-temporal latent feature dimensions. The revision therefore does not make this transfer. In revised Eq. (10), A(v) is explicitly defined as an asymmetric predictive feature-dependency matrix, not a causal graph. It is not constrained to be acyclic and is only used to condition feature-specific dynamic kernels. Accordingly, we no longer assert causal identifiability assumptions, causal effects, or confounder adjustment.
Graph-conditioning ablation at missing rate 0.3 (ACC/NMI/ARI, %).
These results distinguish the proposed predictive graph conditioning from fixed, identity, symmetric, and randomly permuted dependency structures. They support predictive utility rather than a causal interpretation.
Statistical reliability and repeated runs (W2/Q2). We apologize that the original presentation did not clearly state the evaluation protocol. All clustering results are averages over 10 independent random seeds. Within each seed, all methods use the same missing-view mask, which controls for variation caused by incomplete-observation construction. We have clarified this protocol in Sec. 4.2. We agree that mean values alone do not establish statistical significance and now describe the comparisons as descriptive rather than statistically conclusive.
Writing and presentation (W3). We appreciate this observation and have carefully proofread the manuscript. We corrected spelling, grammar, notation, and non-standard phrasing throughout, and revised the terminology to consistently distinguish predictive dependency learning from causal inference.
Difference from existing work (Q3). The main difference of GCDI is not a causal claim. Compared with IMVC methods based on fixed predictors, global similarity structures, prototype completion, or generative recovery, GCDI learns asymmetric feature dependencies and uses them to generate feature-specific dynamic kernels for missing-view recovery. It further combines this adaptive imputation mechanism with information-bottleneck regularization, cross-view alignment, and cluster-consistency learning in one end-to-end objective. Section 2 now clarifies this positioning and distinguishes GCDI from both existing imputation-based IMVC methods and causally formulated multi-view methods.