- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Anchored Latent Flow (ALF), a conditional wireless signal generation framework that incorporates spectrogram-based auxiliary supervision into latent flow matching to improve generation quality and efficiency.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important problem: generating high-quality synthetic wireless signals that can potentially improve downstream model training, particularly in scenarios where collecting real-world data is costly or limited. This is a practically relevant research direction with potential value for wireless machine learning applications.
Critical weaknesses
1. Limited evaluation of generation quality and downstream utility.
The evaluation relies mostly on TSTR/TRTS experiments between ALF-generated samples and WaveScene, which is itself a synthetic dataset constructed by the authors. Since ALF is trained to reproduce the WaveScene distribution, both the generated and reference signals are tied to the same simulation framework. As a result, the reported classification performance may reflect simulator-specific patterns or shortcuts rather than physically meaningful signal properties that generalize to real-world wireless environments.
This limitation leaves two important claims insufficiently supported:
a) Conditional fidelity: The current TSTR/TRTS results do not convincingly establish whether ALF generates signals that faithfully satisfy the specified physical conditions generally. Evaluation using independent and reliable condition-specific measurements or pretrained evaluators (not on WaveScene, preferably real-word recordings) would provide stronger evidence that the generated signals capture the intended physical attributes rather than simulator-specific correlations.
b) Downstream utility: The authors highlight data augmentation as an important application and motivation for wireless signal generation in the abstract and introduction. However, the experiments do not establish whether ALF-generated data provides meaningful utility for real-world downstream tasks. The reported TSTR results only show that a classifier trained on ALF-generated signals can perform well on WaveScene samples, which are themselves simulator-generated.
More convincing evidence could be provided at two levels: (1) demonstrating that models trained solely on ALF-generated signals achieve competitive performance on real-world RF recordings, which would provide strong evidence of the synthetic data's practical utility; or (2) demonstrating that augmenting real-world RF training data with ALF-generated signals improves downstream performance compared to training on the same real-world data alone, particularly in limited-data settings. Without either evaluation, the practical motivation for generating these signals remains insufficiently substantiated.
2. Insufficient analysis of the spectral anchor.
Spectral anchoring is the central component of the proposed method, but the quality of the anchor representation itself is not sufficiently evaluated. The anchor is obtained from a separately trained spectrogram autoencoder, but the paper provides limited quantitative evidence of how faithfully its latent representations preserve the relevant spectral properties. While Figure 4 offers a qualitative visualization and Table 3 demonstrates improvements over unanchored flow matching, neither directly validates the quality of the learned anchors.
Furthermore, it remains unclear whether the improvements specifically arise from the proposed spectrogram latent anchoring or could be achieved with simpler spectral supervision, such as directly predicting spectrogram features or applying frequency-domain losses. Additional analysis and ablations would help substantiate the necessity of the proposed anchor design.
Questions for authors
The presentation of Section 6 (Results) could be substantially improved. Currently, experiments addressing different objectives are presented together without a clear structure, making it difficult to follow the evaluation logic and understand what each experiment is intended to demonstrate. For example, Table 2 is introduced before the corresponding evaluation protocol, baselines, and metrics are explained. I would suggest organizing the results into separate subsections according to their evaluation objectives (e.g., generation quality, ablation studies, computational efficiency, and downstream applications). Each subsection should first clearly state the research question or claim being evaluated, followed by the experimental setup, evaluation metrics, and results. A dedicated experimental setup subsection would also help readers understand the overall evaluation protocol before interpreting the results.
5 comments
Response to reviewer Ndrf - Part 2/3
(Q2 (a)) Insufficient evaluation of spectral anchoring. The learned spectrogram anchor is a central contribution, but its quality and benefits are not sufficiently established.
(A2 (a)) Gains from spectral anchoring.
Spectral anchoring helps preserve fine-grained fidelity in the spectral domain, particularly in bandwidth accuracy and the preservation of structured time–frequency features. With newly expanded Appendix E.11, we now demonstrate these benefits using 2 additional experiments and highlight theoretical benefits that were previously not sufficiently emphasized in Appendix A. Both bandwidth accuracy and preservation of structured time–frequency features are important for functional wireless signal generation. For example, frequency-modulated chirps, a fundamental tool in radar technology, enable longer-duration, higher-energy transmissions while maintaining range resolution through pulse compression. Their practical utility depends critically on preserving their characteristic frequency evolution.
Bandwidth fidelity. We demonstrate how spectral anchoring improves adherence to requested occupied bandwidth. Narrowband signals are particularly sensitive to relative bandwidth errors: energy leakage outside the desired band can interfere with neighboring channels. To quantify bandwidth fidelity, we consider identical subsets of the held-out 100k test sets for ALF and LF-M (without spectral anchoring), with occupancy labels between 0 and 0.2 and SNR above 20 dB. These subsets contain 24,272 records. We measure bandwidth noncompliance by the absolute difference between requested occupancy and measured 99%-energy occupied bandwidth, normalized by sampling rate, where \mathrm{OccBW}_{99\\%}=\frac{\mathrm{BW}_{99\\%}}{f_s}. As shown in Table 14, under identical conditions, ALF reduces the mean occupied-bandwidth error by 14.23% relative to LF-M, demonstrating improved adherence to spectral occupancy conditions.
Spectrogram fidelity. Spectral anchoring also reduces spectrogram errors for nonstationary waveforms such as radar chirps and hopping sequences. Following the evaluation setting of Table 3, we compare ALF and LF-M on the same held-out 100k test set using identical conditioning labels. We restrict the analysis to SNR ≥ 0 dB to include low-SNR regimes while excluding signals below the noise floor. We measure spectrogram MSE (Spec-MSE) between each generated recording and its reference waveform, then analyze 10 nonstationary and 16 stationary waveform classes separately, averaging within each class before averaging across classes. Shown in Table 15, ALF reduces Spec-MSE by 7.8 dB² on nonstationary waveforms, compared with 1.2 dB² on stationary waveforms, representing a 5.4× larger relative improvement. This demonstrates that spectral anchoring is particularly beneficial for signals with evolving spectral structure.
Theoretical benefits. In the revised paper, we have emphasized the theoretical analysis included in Appendix A. From a theoretical standpoint, spectral anchoring eases the generative modeling task by encouraging structural constraints that are challenging to learn purely in the time domain. For a sequence containing n discrete points spanning d levels, an unconstrained joint distribution demands free parameters. RF waveforms are inherently band-limited: despite containing n temporal samples, their spectral representations have restricted support. Through the inverse Fourier transform, the retained spectral coefficients determine the sequence, illustrating that time-domain samples are tightly coupled rather than independent parameters. Incorporating a spectral anchor s leverages this structure through . As discussed in Appendix A, a support-conditioned formulation reduces the required parameter space to at most , where denotes valid frequency support, compared with in an unconstrained formulation. This motivates spectral anchoring as a physically informed inductive bias for flow learning.
Response to reviewer Ndrf - Part 3/3
(Q2 (b)) Could simpler spectral supervision, such as direct spectrogram features or frequency-domain losses, provide similar improvements?
(A2 (b)) Why a separate latent spectral encoder. Regarding the choice of spectral anchor, Stage 2 learns to transport representations toward the reconstruction-oriented IQ latent space established in Stage 1. The Stage 1 spectral branch is fused with raw-IQ features and jointly optimized for reconstruction and label alignment; its information is therefore already incorporated into the final latent representation that the flow aims to learn. Reusing these features as intermediate supervision would provide a target closely related to the flow's endpoint, rather than an independent spectral constraint. Instead, we seek an intermediate target that retains important time-frequency structure while abstracting away finer IQ details. The separately trained spectrogram autoencoder provides such a compact, spectrally focused representation, allowing the flow to learn global spectral structure before completing the transport toward the full IQ latent. As for direct STFT log-power supervision, it would require an additional mapping to produce compact, context-aware spectral embeddings compatible with the flow's intermediate representations. This is precisely the role of our separately trained spectrogram autoencoder, which learns such embeddings through a dedicated spectral reconstruction objective rather than relying on an arbitrary projection.
(Q3) Organization of Section 6. The reviewer suggests introducing the evaluation setup before the results and reorganizing the experiments into clearly separated objectives, such as generation quality, ablations, computational efficiency, and downstream applications.
(A3) Organization of Section 6.
We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion. We have restructured Section 6 of the revised manuscript accordingly, introducing the experimental setup and evaluation protocol before presenting the results, and organizing the experiments into clearer subsections based on their objectives: experiment setup, generation quality, ablation studies, computational efficiency, and downstream applications. This organization is intended to make the evaluation logic and the purpose of each experiment easier to follow.
Concluding Remark
We hope the clarifications and additional results above address your concerns. If you are satisfied with our response, we kindly ask you to consider revisiting your score. We welcome any further questions and are committed to addressing additional concerns during the discussion period.
Response to reviewer Ndrf - Part 1/3
Dear Reviewer Ndrf,
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback, particularly regarding the necessity of spectral anchoring and the real-world utility of ALF. We have conducted additional experiments to address these concerns and clarify the design choices underlying our framework.
(Q1) Limited evaluation of real-world generation quality and downstream utility. Since existing TSTR/TRTS experiments use WaveScene as both the source and target distribution, how can the authors establish that ALF-generated signals provide meaningful benefits on real RF recordings rather than merely reproducing simulator-specific characteristics?
(A1) Real-world validation and utility.
We strongly agree with the reviewer’s concern, and have added extensive real-world validation in Appendix H. We provide an overview of the topics covered in Appendix H below:
To evaluate whether ALF-generated signals provide practical benefits beyond the WaveScene simulation environment, we conducted Over-The-Air (OTA) experiments in two distinct settings: a controlled indoor laboratory environment and the outdoor NSF PAWR POWDER testbed.
Results from laboratory measurements (Indoor Hotspot/InH).
We collected 13,776 OTA recordings across 13 capture configurations in an indoor-hotspot setting, including LOS, NLOS, reflector/blockage, and moving conditions, with TX–RX separations of 2.16, 3.90, and 9.14 m. ALF-generated augmentation improves classification accuracy on held-out InH recordings by 8.66 percentage points over limited-real-only training, achieving performance comparable to training on the complete real dataset.
Results from outdoor urban measurements (NSF PAWR POWDER platform).
We further evaluated ALF using 23,621 OTA recordings classes across 3 directed links on the NSF PAWR POWDER testbed. Unlike the laboratory measurements, outdoor transmitter and receiver positions remained fixed while transmit gain was varied to capture different received-signal conditions. This set of data has a longer transmission distance (~200m) and exhibits lower measured SNR, presenting a significant distribution shift compared to InH data. ALF augmentation still improves classification accuracy by 8.57 percentage points over limited-real-only training, approaching the performance obtained using the complete real training set.
Details of the two augmentation experiments can be found in Appendix H.3 (Tables 20–21), where we further show comparisons of ALF and other traditional data augmentation methods. We also included label-only decoding as a baseline to isolate the learned flow's contribution. Directly decoding metadata-derived latents from the metadata encoder through the frozen Stage-1 decoder, without flow matching, achieves much worse results on both experiments. These results demonstrate that the learned latent flow contributes substantially beyond the pretrained decoder and label conditioning alone.
Synthetic-to-real encoder transfer.
Appendix H.4 (Tables 22–25) separately evaluates the frozen WaveScene-trained encoders using both synthetic-trained and OTA-trained classification probes. ALF achieves the strongest accuracy among the evaluated encoders in both settings. Together with the embedding visualizations in Figures 20-21, these results demonstrate that ALF's learned representations retain meaningful waveform information after transfer to real OTA measurements.