- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the Hybrid Diffusion model, which decomposes time‑series data into low‑frequency and high‑frequency components via the discrete Fourier transform. Two diffusion branches with different schedules are adopted: the frequency‑domain branch uses the full total timestep T for high‑frequency component generation, while the time‑domain branch employs a shorter schedule t* to model low‑frequency components. During sampling, the frequency‑domain denoising runs independently first. After reaching timestep t*, the time‑domain denoiser is conditioned on the current high‑frequency state through cross‑attention, and the two branches perform joint iterations. Finally, the complete time series is reconstructed via inverse Fourier transform.
Critical strengths
S1. This method separately models low‑frequency trends and high‑frequency details. Cross‑attention is utilized for information interaction and constraints between high‑ and low‑frequency components, combined with an asymmetric diffusion schedule. It preserves the time‑domain capability for global trend modeling while leveraging frequency‑domain diffusion to recover fine‑grained high‑frequency details.
S2. Mechanism validation is first conducted on synthetic Gaussian‑process data. Two groups of experiments are carried out on real‑world datasets, with comparisons against single‑domain diffusion baselines and six mainstream time‑series generation models.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Ablation and sensitivity experiments show that model performance is highly dependent on the switching timestep t* (the breakpoint for standalone frequency‑domain denoising) and the frequency cutoff f_c. No automatic strategy is provided to determine these two hyper‑parameters, and grid‑search tuning is required. The optimal t* and f_c vary across datasets, increasing the tuning overhead for practical deployment.
W2. All experiments in this paper focus on unconditional generation. The effectiveness of this hybrid diffusion framework is not evaluated on conditional time‑series tasks such as time‑series forecasting and missing‑value imputation. A large number of real‑world time‑series applications require conditional modeling, yet the transferability of this architecture to conditional scenarios lacks experimental evidence.
W3. Built upon discrete Fourier transform (DFT) decomposition, the method assumes fixed‑length and uniformly‑sampled time series. It cannot be directly applied to variable‑length or non‑uniformly‑sampled time series, which necessitates preprocessing for length alignment. The paper does not discuss how to adapt the hybrid diffusion framework for non‑equispaced and variable‑length time‑series inputs.
Questions for authors
Q1. Since model performance is sensitive to the switching timestep t* and frequency cutoff f_c, could an adaptive mechanism be designed to automatically learn these hyper‑parameters and reduce dataset‑specific tuning efforts?
Q2. All experiments in this work target unconditional time‑series generation. What architectural modifications would be required if Hybrid Diffusion is extended to conditional time‑series tasks, e.g., time‑series forecasting and missing‑value imputation?
Q3. Beyond existing baselines including Diffusion‑TS and TimeGAN, comparisons against additional state‑of‑the‑art baselines are expected.
4 comments
ponse to Reviewer r3PG (Part 2/2)
Q3. Comparisons with additional state-of-the-art baselines are expected.
A3. We have added PaCoDi [4], a recent frequency-domain diffusion model (KDD 2026). Hybrid Diffusion achieves lower mean scores on all three metrics on both ETTh and fMRI, using fewer parameters.
We trained PaCoDi with its official implementation, adjusting the model dimensions to obtain a size comparable to Hybrid Diffusion and retaining the default settings for the remaining hyperparameters. We used the same data as Table 3 (sequence length 24) and the same evaluation code. For the Table 3 configurations, PaCoDi has 0.54M parameters on ETTh and 2.15M on fMRI, while Hybrid Diffusion has 0.45M and 1.81M, respectively. The comparison is shown below:
| Dataset | Method | Context-FID ↓ | Correlational ↓ | Discriminative ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ETTh | PaCoDi [4] | 0.074 ± .005 | 0.074 ± .007 | 0.025 ± .015 |
| Hybrid | 0.036 ± .002 | 0.039 ± .008 | 0.018 ± .009 | |
| fMRI | PaCoDi [4] | 0.118 ± .004 | 0.988 ± .021 | 0.331 ± .005 |
| Hybrid | 0.103 ± .007 | 0.880 ± .014 | 0.148 ± .013 |
Q4. The DFT-based method cannot directly handle variable-length or non-uniformly sampled time series.
A4. Both cases can be handled using existing data preprocessing techniques while retaining our two-branch diffusion framework. The benchmarks we follow use fixed-length, uniformly sampled sequences, as in Crabbé et al. [2], so we did not explicitly discuss these cases in the paper. For non-uniform sampling and variable-length inputs, practical extensions are as follows:
- Non-uniform sampling: interpolate the observations onto a uniform grid so that the DFT can be applied as usual, and use a mask to down-weight the interpolated points in the time-domain loss.
- Variable length: pad all sequences to a common length and mask the padded positions; the cutoff defines the frequency split relative to this common length.
We will revise the paper to discuss these approaches for handling non-uniformly sampled and variable-length inputs. Thank you for suggesting this useful addition to the discussion of our framework.
Thank you again for reading our response and for the constructive suggestions. We welcome further discussion.
References
[1] Chung et al. Diffusion Posterior Sampling for General Noisy Inverse Problems. ICLR, 2023.
[2] Crabbé, Huynh, Stanczuk, and van der Schaar. Time Series Diffusion in the Frequency Domain. ICML, 2024.
[3] Yuan and Qiao. Diffusion-TS: Interpretable Diffusion for General Time Series Generation. ICLR, 2024.
[4] Cai et al. Parallel Complex Diffusion for Scalable Time Series Generation. KDD, 2026.
Reply to Authors
Thank you for your rebuttal. I will keep my current score.
Thanks for your time and support!
Response to Reviewer r3PG (Part 1/2)
Thank you for your time in reviewing our paper, and for your recognition of our design that separately models low-frequency trends and high-frequency details with cross-attention and an asymmetric schedule, as well as our mechanism validation on Gaussian processes and comparisons on real-world datasets. We now summarize the weaknesses and questions you raised and address them as follows:
A1. Thank you for the suggestion. While one fixed setting already achieves strong performance across all nine datasets, learning t∗ and fc adaptively is a promising direction for further study. Our current results provide a practical starting point:
Developing an effective adaptive mechanism may require further study of how data-specific spectral structure should determine the cutoff and switching time. We view this as a promising extension of the current framework and leave it for future work.
A2. No architectural modification is required; only the sampling procedure changes. Forecasting and imputation both mean generating a sequence that agrees with some observed time steps. Diffusion Posterior Sampling (DPS) [1] does this with an unconditionally trained diffusion model: at each denoising step, it nudges the sample towards the observations using the gradient of the mismatch between them. For Hybrid Diffusion, this guidance can follow the two-stage sampler. In the frequency-only phase, it can use the clean-sequence estimate reconstructed from the full-spectrum frequency branch. During joint denoising, it can use the sum of the low-pass-filtered time-domain estimate and the high-frequency reconstruction from the frequency branch. This reconstruction and the observation mask are differentiable, so the guidance gradient can update both states during this phase. We will add this discussion to the revised version.