- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies UAV–ground retrieval without direct UAV–ground training pairs. It trains on UAV–satellite and satellite–ground pairs from disjoint locations. GeoCoRe uses frozen DINOv3 features, shared learnable queries, and local spatial-relation modeling in Stage 1. Stage 2 uses the query responses to guide optimal-transport feature aggregation. Both stages train on the two available relations; at test time, UAV and ground descriptors are compared directly. The main experiment trains on DenseUAV and VIGOR and reports 6.11% average UAV–ground Recall@1 on University-1652.
Critical strengths
-
The setting poses a useful generalization question. Independently collected UAV–satellite and satellite–ground datasets can cover different locations. Testing whether they support retrieval on a relation absent from training supervision is a reasonable way to study transfer between view pairs.
-
The reported improvements are not confined to DINOv3. Table 1 includes five backbones. With ConvNeXt-B, GeoCoRe improves average UAV–ground Recall@1 over Sample4Geo from 1.53% to 2.00%; with DINOv2 ViT-B/14, it improves over LKGL from 0.60% to 5.58%. These results provide evidence of an advantage beyond simply selecting DINOv3.
-
The ablations and same-dataset experiment provide useful evidence. Table 2 improves from 3.94% with Stage 1 alone to 5.42% with unguided shared aggregation and descriptor combination, and to 6.11% with primitive guidance. Table 3 supports sharing projection heads. In the disjoint-pair experiment within University-1652, the full model achieves 10.83%, compared with 7.20% for Pairwise and 7.44% for Stage 1. The gains therefore persist without the main experiment's cross-dataset shift.
Critical weaknesses
-
Excluding all direct UAV–ground training pairs needs stronger motivation. The introduction cites independent data collection and scarce complete tri-view correspondences. These make incomplete supervision plausible. However, direct UAV–ground training requires only two views, and paired training data already exist in University-1652. The paper needs to explain what concrete data limitation makes such pairs unavailable or inadequate, and why training only on the two indirect relations is useful under those conditions. Excluding direct supervision defines a valid generalization experiment, but does not by itself establish the practical need for this training restriction.
-
The presentation obscures substantial overlap with prior work and overstates the novelty of the aggregation mechanisms. In Stage 1, the shared primitive reference begins with eight learnable queries that aggregate patch features through cross-attention. This basic mechanism is established in retrieval methods such as BoQ (Ali-bey et al., CVPR 2024). Sharing query parameters does not ensure that the same query attends to corresponding content across views. GeoCoRe adds local spatial-relation modeling and consistency constraints; the contribution needs to be identified at that level.
Stage 2's learned assignments, Sinkhorn transport, dustbin, and grouping-based feature aggregation closely overlap with SALAD: Optimal Transport Aggregation for Visual Place Recognition (Izquierdo and Civera, CVPR 2024), which is neither cited nor discussed. Calling these operations “shared-coordinate mapping” obscures this relationship. The primitive-based reference, occupancy priors, and assignment constraints appear to be incremental modifications to this established aggregation pattern. The ablations demonstrate a benefit within the proposed architecture, but do not establish a substantial advance over a competitive shared aggregator such as SALAD. Together with the unacknowledged methodological overlap, this leaves Stage 2's claimed contribution insufficiently substantiated for acceptance.
-
The experiments show better retrieval on the missing relation, but do not establish the proposed explanation for that improvement. Both stages learn from the two observed relations, and the final descriptors are directly compared on UAV–ground images. A shared SALAD model trained on the same relations would also permit this evaluation. The key question is what the proposed guidance adds beyond strong shared aggregation. Table 2 supports an increment of 0.69 percentage points over the authors' unguided variant, but this is not a comparison with SALAD: the variant uses a different mass allocation.
Appendix A correctly shows that pairwise similarity constraints alone do not determine cross-relation similarities, while acknowledging that shared encoders and pretraining restrict the ambiguity. It does not show that this ambiguity is the main cause of errors in the actual model. Likewise, sharing query or aggregation indices does not establish content correspondence across views. Tables 2–3 and Figure 4 support the design, but do not establish that it improves retrieval specifically by correcting “coordinate incompatibility.” A matched shared aggregation baseline is needed to assess the proposed mechanism's additional value.
Questions for authors
-
Training-data restriction: Under what concrete data-acquisition conditions are direct UAV–ground training pairs unavailable or inadequate? Why do existing paired datasets not meet that need, making the proposed indirect training setup useful?
-
Actual methodological contribution: Please properly cite and discuss SALAD and relate the shared-query design to prior attention-based aggregation. Which specific changes beyond these established mechanisms are essential for the reported gains? What evidence shows that shared primitives capture corresponding content across views, beyond using the same query indices?
-
Shared aggregation comparison: How does a shared SALAD model perform when trained on the same two relations with a matched backbone, descriptor size, and training budget? To isolate Stage 2's contribution, replacing its guided aggregation with SALAD while retaining the Stage 1 features and descriptor combination would also be informative. These comparisons would clarify the value of primitive guidance beyond ordinary shared representation learning.
5 comments
Official Response to Reviewer V25W [2/3]
W2 & W3 & Q2 & Q3. Methodological Contribution and Cross-Edge Comparability
1. Overview
GeoCoRe's core contribution is to use a shared primitive reference for primitive-guided coordinate assignment and to improve the cross-edge comparability of independently supervised relations under a common metric. New experiments show that GeoCoRe improves by 2.00 pp and 1.45 pp over Shared SALAD and Stage 1 + SALAD, respectively, demonstrating additional gains beyond shared aggregation.
We thank the reviewer for pointing out the technical connections between GeoCoRe and BoQ/SALAD. In the revision, we will add citations to these methods and clarify the differences between established aggregation mechanisms and GeoCoRe. To further assess this methodological contribution, we add two SALAD comparisons mentioned by the reviewer and combine them with the existing ablations, primitive visualizations, and a new representation analysis to provide further evidence.
2. Experiments and Analysis
(1) Methodological Distinction: From general shared aggregation to cross-edge comparable representations.
BoQ uses learnable queries and cross-attention to aggregate local features. SALAD constructs global retrieval descriptors through SALAD assignment implemented with Sinkhorn-based optimal transport (OT), a dustbin, and local-feature aggregation. These methods can learn discriminative representations, but shared queries or aggregation parameters alone do not guarantee sufficient cross-edge comparability between two relations supervised by independent datasets.
GeoCoRe addresses this issue by a coordinated design. Stage 1 combines local spatial-relation modeling with cross-view primitive consistency constraints to learn a shared primitive reference. Stage 2 uses primitive responses to construct a primitive-guided reference assignment and an image-level occupancy prior. Finally, shared local projection and coordinate fusion functions establish a common metric.
Therefore, the key distinction is that shared primitive responses are explicitly converted into the basis for primitive-guided coordinate assignment across relations, while a common metric improves the comparability of independently supervised relations. This design serves missing-relation recovery rather than merely enhancing feature aggregation for a single observed relation.
(2) SALAD Comparisons: Assessing the additional value of the complete design over general shared aggregation.
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we add two comparisons, Shared SALAD and Stage 1 + SALAD. The former trains a shared SALAD aggregator on the two observed edges. The latter retains the same frozen Stage 1, base descriptor, and fusion scheme, while replacing only the guided aggregation in Stage 2 with SALAD. All methods use the same disjoint-location u–s/s–g supervision, a frozen DINOv3 ViT-B/16 backbone, the same input resolution, and a 1536-dimensional final descriptor. They are evaluated on University-1652 using the same u–g Query and full Gallery.
Table R10. Comparison with shared SALAD aggregation under the cross-dataset missing-edge protocol.
| Method | u2g R@1 | g2u R@1 | u2g mAP | g2u mAP | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shared SALAD | 3.95 | 4.27 | 4.11 | 3.55 | 2.87 |
| Stage 1 + SALAD | 4.46 | 4.85 | 4.66 | 3.78 | 3.18 |
| Full GeoCoRe | 5.98 | 6.24 | 6.11 | 4.93 | 4.01 |
As shown in Table R10, when the Stage 1 representations and descriptor-fusion scheme are held fixed, the complete Stage 2 still achieves better recovery performance, supporting the additional value of Stage 2 over standard SALAD aggregation.
Official Response to Reviewer V25W [3/3]
(3) Cross-Edge Comparability: Assessing the roles of the shared reference, coordinate organization, and common metric.
Shared primitive indices do not automatically guarantee cross-view content correspondence. The key to GeoCoRe is that primitive responses guide the subsequent coordinate assignment, while learning over the two observed edges improves the comparability of cross-edge representations.
Tables 2–3 in the manuscript demonstrate the complementary roles of the validated shared Primitive Reference, Primitive-Guided Coordinate Assignment and Dual-Edge Metric Alignment. Notably, upon removal of the unified metric, the performance for observed edges improved whilst that for missing edges deteriorated, indicating that the discriminatory power of observed relationships does not necessarily translate into comparability across relationships.
Figure 5 in Appendix E shows local responses at the same primitive indices across the three views and illustrates how these responses contribute to constructing the primitive-guided reference assignment and the final content-adaptive coordinate assignment .
To further analyse the impact of Primitive-guided Coordinate Mapping on cross-view representation, we compare the location discrimination capabilities of Stage 1 Geo-primitives and Stage 2 Shared Coordinates on the University-1652 dataset. Specifically, the average cosine similarity of cross-view features is calculated separately for the same location and for different locations, and the difference between the two is used to measure the ability to distinguish between locations.
Table R11. Cross-view place discriminability of same-index representations. Values denote the cosine-similarity margin between matched and unmatched locations for each view pair.
| Representation | u–s | s–g | u–g (Missing) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stage 1 Geo-primitive representations | 0.00285 | 0.00068 | 0.00057 |
| Stage 2 Shared-Coordinate Representations | 0.332 | 0.157 | 0.153 |
Table R11 shows that, following Stage 2 coordinate mapping, the co-indexed representations of the three viewpoint relationships all exhibit stronger ability to distinguish locations, including the u–g relationship, which was not directly supervised. Taken in conjunction with the comparison with Stage 1 + SALAD in Table R10, these results support the contribution of Primitive-guided Coordinate Mapping to the comparability of cross-viewpoint representations in terms of both retrieval performance and representational distinctiveness.
3. Revision
In the revised manuscript, we will add citations to BoQ and SALAD and clarify their technical differences from GeoCoRe. We will also add the controlled SALAD comparisons and cross-view representation analysis to Appendices D and E.
Official Response to Reviewer V25W [1/3]
W1 & Q1. Practical Motivation for Missing UAV–Ground Supervision
1. Overview
We thank the reviewer for highlighting these practical data constraints. We further clarify the specific source of this supervision gap and the coverage limitations of existing datasets.
(1) Pairing-coverage limitations arising from independent data collection and existing datasets.
UAV imagery may form u–s pairs with satellite images, whereas street-view and satellite images collected at other locations may form s–g pairs. When the locations in the two datasets do not overlap, obtaining direct u–g supervision requires additional collection of the missing view and verification of the correspondences.
Existing datasets reflect this difference in pairing coverage. DenseUAV and SUES-200 primarily provide u–s pairs, while VIGOR, CVUSA, and CVACT primarily provide s–g pairs. Although University-1652 contains direct u–g pairs, it covers different locations and thus cannot directly supply the missing same-location correspondences in the above data sources. Introducing these direct pairs as additional cross-domain supervision would represent a different data-availability condition.
(2) Indirect supervision provides useful learning signals for the missing relation.
As shown in Table 6 of manuscript, in the same-domain, location-disjoint experiment on University-1652, directly using pretrained DINOv3 features yields an Rmiss of 2.67%, Pairwise, trained using only u–s and s–g supervision, reaches 7.20%, and GeoCoRe further improves it to 10.83%. This indicates that indirectly observed relations can provide useful learning signals for missing u–g retrieval, and that GeoCoRe can use these signals more effectively to improve missing-relation recovery.
2. Revision
In the revised Introduction, we will clarify the pairing-coverage limitations caused by independent data collection and use examples from existing datasets to explain the practical motivation for incomplete relation supervision.