- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates whether learned priors can be identified from how reconstruction solvers respond to measurement perturbations, even when their outputs are similar. The authors propose a response fingerprint based on centered log energies in frequency bands, estimated through repeated solves with randomly perturbed measurements. Attribution is performed by matching the fingerprint to reference centroids of known candidate priors. For variational solvers, the paper proves that, under local regularity assumptions and with the operator and perturbation level known, the first-order response covariance determines the solver Jacobian and the regularizer’s curvature on the reachable subspace. Experiments across nine inverse problems and external reconstruction models demonstrate promising attribution performance, supported by extensive comparisons and ablations. Overall, I appreciate the proposed method and its theoretical analysis. However, I remain concerned about its practical contribution, particularly how identifying a prior informs meaningful decisions or provides useful guidance for solving imaging inverse problems.
Critical strengths
S1. The research perspective is novel. Starting from the observation that "similar reconstruction results may arise from different priors," the paper clearly formulates the problem of prior identification and provides a relatively detailed theoretical analysis.
S2. The experiments cover various inverse problems and different types of priors, with relatively comprehensive comparisons and ablation studies. The proposed method achieves good attribution performance.
S3. The paper is well-structured and coherently written, clearly presenting the research problem, method design, and underlying ideas.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The practical value needs further clarification. Although I appreciate the proposed method and theory, I find it difficult to identify concrete practical uses or understand what guidance the method provides for solving imaging inverse problems. In imaging inverse problems, we typically care more about reconstruction quality and reliability. If different priors produce equally good reconstructions, the additional value of identifying which prior was used remains unclear. The authors mention provenance tracking and model comparison, but the experiments primarily evaluate attribution accuracy and do not sufficiently explain how attribution results can inform practical decisions. The authors should clarify: in what scenarios is evaluating reconstruction results alone insufficient, making identification of the underlying prior necessary or useful?
W2. The connection between theoretical identifiability and the practical fingerprint requires clarification. Theorem 1 relies on the full first-order response covariance, whereas the practical method retains only a small number of frequency-band energies and removes the overall scale. Consequently, different covariance matrices may still yield identical fingerprints. The authors should clarify to what extent theoretical identifiability supports the practical compressed fingerprint, and which differences between priors may be lost during compression.
W3. The target of attribution needs to be further clarified. I am not entirely sure whether the fingerprint identifies the prior itself or the entire reconstruction process, including the solver and its parameter settings. Although the theoretical analysis focuses on variational solvers that satisfy certain conditions, the actual reconstruction results can also be affected by factors such as regularization strength, the number of iterations, and randomness. This means that even with the same prior, changing the solver settings may produce different fingerprints. Therefore, the authors should further explain to what extent the proposed method can truly identify the prior, rather than simply distinguish between different reconstruction settings.
Questions for authors
Q1. Could the authors provide concrete application scenarios explaining why evaluating reconstruction quality alone is insufficient, and what practical decisions or guidance for solving inverse problems can be supported by identifying the prior?
Q2. Theorem 1 relies on the full response covariance, whereas the practical fingerprint retains only a small number of frequency-band energies. Could the authors explain what identifiable information is preserved after compression and which differences between priors may be lost?
Q3. When the prior remains unchanged but the regularization strength, number of iterations, or solution algorithm changes, can the method still identify it as the same prior? Should the attribution result be interpreted as identifying the prior or the complete reconstruction configuration?
4 comments
Author Responses (Part 2)
Regarding what the compression keeps and what it loses (W2, Q2). We appreciate this question on what the compression loses. Inspired by it, we added Proposition 5 (Appendix K, summarized in Section 4): two responses have the same fingerprint if and only if their band energies are proportional. Theorem 1 states what the response contains, the curvature of the prior on the subspace that the solver can reach, and the fingerprint keeps how this response is distributed across the 12 frequency bands: how strongly the prior regularizes each band that the operator attenuates, relative to the other bands (Example 1). It sets aside three properties:
- The overall size of the response, by design, which makes the fingerprint independent of the perturbation level; in our ablation, the centered log band energies raise the accuracy from 0.773 to 0.808 (Table 19).
- Where in the image and in which direction the response lies within a band, and how the bands are correlated. A circular translation of the spatially varying weights of a prior changes C by 30% to 37% (over seeds and operators) and leaves the fingerprint unchanged (Proposition 5(ii)). The direction depends on the acquisition: with the acquisition rotated by 90°, our fingerprint attributes at 0.837 / 0.853, while the Cartesian cells with the same standardization decrease to 0.270 / 0.280 (Table 21).
- The curvature outside the reachable subspace, which no method that observes the response can recover (Theorem 1, converse), and which is therefore not a loss of the compression.
With exact covariances, all 1,200 random pairs of priors per operator are separated, and with nine random priors the fingerprint reaches the accuracy of the maximum-likelihood classifier that knows every exact covariance (1.000 at N=64): the compression loses no accuracy for nine random priors at N=64, and pooling makes each band energy measurable from 8 re-solves (Proposition 3).
Regarding the prior or the reconstruction configuration (W3, Q3). Thank you for this question. The attribution identifies the prior. Once the solver has converged to a solution, its response there depends on the objective it minimizes, the data fit plus λ times the regularizer, and not on the algorithm, the number of iterations or the initialization that reached it (Theorem 1). The strength λ scales the prior inside this objective, and the auditor covers an unknown λ by running each candidate prior at a few strengths. Following your question, we tested both directly on 9 inverse problems (N=64, random guess 0.111; Tables 20 and 22 and Appendix L):
| The same prior, run with | Configurations among the references | Configuration not among the references |
|---|---|---|
| L-BFGS instead of Adam* | 0.870 | 0.811 |
| 0.5× / 2× / 4× the iterations | 0.853 / 0.848 / 0.836 | 0.775 / 0.830 / 0.778 |
| Zero / random initialization* | 0.822 / 0.881 | 0.731 / 0.851 |
| 0.25× / 0.5× / 2× / 4× its λ | 0.810 / 0.849 / 0.850 / 0.833 | 0.829 / 0.755 (λ between / outside the referenced strengths, standardized, Table 20) |
In the first column, every candidate prior is run under the listed configurations, and the re-solves of a test measurement are attributed to the closest (prior, configuration) reference; in the second, the configuration of the test is removed from the references. *For the 7 explicit regularizers, whose objective defines the solution. Under every change in this table, the same prior is attributed to itself in at least 73.1% of the test clouds, 6.6 times the random guess or more. When the configuration or λ of the test is not among the references (Table 20), the total response decreases from 0.737 to between 0.367 and 0.534, whereas our standardized fingerprint attributes the same test clouds at 0.755 to 0.829. With all 9 candidate priors matched in total response, by calibrating the size of the measurement perturbation for each prior, the total response attributes at 0.311, while our fingerprint attributes at 0.860 (N=64, Table 23). The total response follows the configuration, and the fingerprint follows the prior; following your question, Section 5.4 now summarizes this result. A random initialization leaves the attribution at 0.881 / 0.851 (Table 22), and when the objective itself is stochastic, re-solving the unperturbed measurement measures the randomness of the solver, which is subtracted band by band from the response (Appendix E.2).
Thank you again for your positive recommendation and your questions, which helped us clarify the scope and the practical value of the paper. We hope that these additions address your concerns and that you will consider revising your score; we are happy to discuss any remaining questions.
Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. The concrete application scenarios clarify the practical motivation. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns. After considering the responses and revisions, I will maintain my original recommendation.
Dear Reviewer UNpq,
We thank you for the continued support in our work, and for your actionable and detailed feedback, which we feel helped us to improve the quality of our paper.
With kindest regards,
Authors.
Author Responses (Part 1)
Thank you for the positive and constructive review. We are glad that you found the research perspective novel, that the paper clearly formulates the problem of prior identification and provides a relatively detailed theoretical analysis, that the experiments offer relatively comprehensive comparisons and ablation studies, and that the paper is well-structured and coherently written.
In short: your review asks what identifying the prior adds when reconstructions are equally good, what the compressed fingerprint keeps, and whether it identifies the prior or the configuration. We added:
Regarding when the reconstruction alone is not enough (W1, Q1). Thank you for this question, which helped us sharpen the motivation of the paper. Reconstruction quality is measured with the ground truth, which a deployed system does not have, and two priors of equal quality can still react differently to noise in the same measurement (Figure 1). For this reason, the reliability of a learned reconstruction is established for a specific model, by its validation and clearance, and the question in practice is which model produced an image. Each scenario below is a decision that rests on this question (Appendices J and L):
Inspired by your question, we tested the case of equally good reconstructions directly. On the internal set, on the clouds of Table 18 that no hyperparameter selection used, we collected every test image on which two candidate priors reconstruct within 0.5 dB PSNR of each other (3,067 cases, 6,134 two-way decisions):
On these cases, which reconstruction quality cannot separate, the fingerprint identifies the prior in 84.4% of the decisions. For solving inverse problems, the response also shows where a reconstruction is set by the prior rather than by the data: by Example 1, the band energies are set by the operator at the frequencies it passes and by the prior at those it attenuates. Following your comment, Section 1 now states these scenarios, Appendix J describes them, and Appendix L reports their measurements.