- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose a new method for prior-guided MRI reconstruction that learns edge conductivities from a companion scan. In prior-guided reconstruction, the authors ensure that zero-measurements yield a zero reconstruction, and perform randomization in the companion during training to improve robustness. The proposed method is shown on multiple different datasets and settings.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses an important problem of prior-guided MRI reconstruction, which aims to improve accelerated MRI recovery by incorporating additional priors in the form of supplementary scans.
Critical weaknesses
-
I think the authors use unclear and over-complicated terms and wording, making the paper difficult to follow or understand. While I have a knowledge on the topic, I had to re-read sentences and sections multiple times to understand aimed meaning. The clarity and readability of the paper must be significantly improved by using simpler language and more direct explanations.
-
The experimental protocol has several issues. First, both IXI and BRATS datasets are single-coil datasets. This limits the representation of a realistic and practical MRI reconstruction scenario. Modern scanners use multiple coil channels, and the experiments should focus on multi-coil reconstructions. Second, the protocol for IXI and M4Raw are inconsistent. In IXI, the ratio between training and test sets is 540:9, whereas in M4Raw, it is 128:25. The test set in IXI should be expanded to enable a more robust evaluation. Third, baselines should reflect the current state-of-the-art. For instance, results are shown for compressed sensing TV (from 2007) and directional TV (from 2016), showing them on single-coil reconstruction, which is a limiting factor.
-
Overall, the results section is not well structured. The goals and settings of the demonstrations are not sufficiently provided in advance. For instance, I had issues in understanding the purpose of the demonstrations in Section 4.1 and Section 4.2. It is also difficult to understand what conclusions should be drawn from them. No visual results are shown in the corresponding sections in the main paper. Table 1 and Table 2 report results, but there is no pattern in the conclusions. For each task, another column is shown to be the best.
-
What's the volumetric results shown on IXI? Are they simply metrics calculated on the concatenation of the slices? Were there any volumetric trainings? If so, how is the reconstruction task built as a slice-wise reconstruction in the earlier experiments, and volumetric here? Similarly, how's the radial sampling simulated in IXI. The IXI dataset is a collection of single-channel MRI images, mostly containing T1, T2, and PD-weighted images. A simulation of a radial sampling on these images will not reflect a realistic reconstruction scenario. In order to claim demonstrations on radial sampling, it is required to use a radially acquired data.
-
The comparison experiments should also include MRI contrast synthesis methods, as they are relevant benchmarks that only focus on generating target contrast images from given source contrast images.
-
The reconstruction experiments are mainly shown for relatively low acceleration ratios of 4x and 8x. It would be helpful to show how the proposed method behave on even more aggressive acceleration, such as 12x or 16x.
Questions for authors
- The main experiments are focusing on single-coil reconstruction with a limited set of benchmark methods (not reflecting current state-of-the-art, such as diffusion models). Is the proposed approach demonstrated through large-scale experiments on multi-coil datasets containing different anatomies including brain, knee etc. and shown on more recent models? How does the proposed approach work on more aggressive acceleration ratios? What are the potential use cases of this approach? Are there any downstream evaluations?