- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper is about task-aware MRI reconstruction with unrolled networks. At every stage, a segmentation network predicts at the current image, and its label is fed back to guide the next stage. The authors argue that the full label at every time is spurious and may contain redundant and task-irrelevant content that should be purified. PTP-MRI instead keeps a running task state. At each stage, TPIB produces task increments to update task state. This task state then guide the reconstruction. The reconstruction network, TPIB, and the task network are trained in alternation. PTP-MRI gets the best Dice/mIoU in all benchmarks.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is clear, and the method is clearly written. The paper starts from a concrete observation in fig1. The method follows this observation: keep only new at each stage, accumulate it, and use the state to decide where the denoiser should be trusted. The formulation is carefully written.
- Clear improve on segmentation. Dice/mIOU improve.
Critical weaknesses
-
The method is heavy for what it buys. 1st, training starts with a segmentation teacher pre trained on fully sampled images and labels. 2nd, each iteration runs 3 Training stages(reconstruction, TPIB, segmentation), each update runs the full six-stage(6 recon stages) pipeline. Too much hyper parameters to tune. At inference, segmentation network runs 7 times(6 recon and 1 final). These costs are not reported: no training time, inference time, memory usage. 3rd, It is also not clear that this gain comes from TPIB. The baselines seem not to get the knowledge distillation loss & task feature consistency loss. neither loss seems to be ablated.
-
It is hard to see how this would be used in practice. 1st, everything is limit to one task. The reconstruction is trained to serve one segmentation task on one anatomy. A new organ means retraining all modules. 2nd, It needs a lot supervision. Requires pixel-level labels and fully sampled images. Many of the clinical settings where acceleration matters have neither. This limits where the method can be used. 3rd, most of the image is left largely unrestored. when t_n approx 0, the denoiser has no effect. In practice, radiologists still read the whole image and look for other findings, so an image optimized for one segmentation mask isn't that practical.
Questions for authors
Questions:
- It seems that the code contains only model, no losses, training loop?
- What are the training time, memory usage and inference time, compared with the baselines?
- Is TPIB needed? If available, please show (a)The model with t_n set to the segmentation network's foreground probability, without TPIB; (b)PTP-MRI without knowledge distillation loss & task feature consistency loss
small suggestions:
- Fig. 3 would be easier to read as table
- Please report the standard deviation across seeds
- typos: "With TPIB and the task network fixed" seems repeat; "stagesin" ?
6 comments
Response to Reviewer isfh (Suggestion1-3)
Thank you for your thoughtful suggestions. Below, we explain how we addressed each one in the revised manuscript.
Suggestion1: The quantitative results previously shown in Fig. 3 are now presented in Table 1 of the revised manuscript, alongside the computational efficiency results, to improve readability.
Suggestion2: We have added the standard deviations across three random seeds (42, 88, and 100) to Tables 1, A1, and A2 in the revised manuscript.
Suggestion3: Thank you for pointing out these errors. We have removed the duplicated sentence containing “With TPIB and the task network fixed” and corrected “stagesin” to “stages in” in the revised manuscript.
Follow-up on Our Response to Reviewer isfh
We hope that our clarifications and additional experiments have addressed your main concerns. We would greatly appreciate your further feedback and welcome any remaining questions during the discussion period. We also hope that the new evidence and discussions will be taken into account in your final assessment.
Response to Reviewer isfh (Question1-3 and Weaknesses 1–2)
Thank you for your careful review and constructive feedback. Below, we address your questions and concerns point by point and describe the corresponding revisions to the manuscript.
Weaknesses1 & Question2 & Question3: We acknowledge that teacher pretraining and the three alternating training stages introduce additional training complexity, and that the computational costs were insufficiently documented in the original manuscript. To quantify model size, computational complexity, and inference efficiency, we have added comparisons of parameter counts, FLOPs, and per-slice inference time using the same hardware, input size, and batch size (Table 1, Page 8). These comparisons show that PTP-MRI achieves the highest Dice score among the evaluated methods while maintaining competitive computational efficiency. Compared with A2MC-fix, the strongest baseline in terms of Dice, PTP-MRI improves Dice by 0.78 percentage points while reducing the parameter count by 44.0%, FLOPs by 32.8%, and inference time by 8.2%. Compared with IDSLR, which has the fewest parameters and the shortest inference time among the evaluated methods, PTP-MRI improves Dice by 13.76 percentage points. These results demonstrate a favorable balance between segmentation performance, model complexity, and inference efficiency. Regarding performance attribution, we have added ablation experiments within the PTP-MRI framework to examine the contributions of TPIB, the knowledge distillation (KD) loss, and the task feature consistency (TFC) loss. As reported in Table 3 of page 8, removing either KD or TFC reduces Dice, while removing TPIB leads to the largest decrease among the evaluated ablations. These findings support the contribution of both loss terms and highlight the importance of TPIB within the proposed framework. Table R2. Ablation study
Weaknesses2: Our intended application is accelerated MRI for a predefined anatomy and segmentation task, where reconstruction is optimized to preserve the structural information needed for subsequent segmentation and quantitative analysis. We agree that the current model is task-specific. Extending it to a new anatomy or task requires appropriate adaptation, training, and validation; direct transfer across anatomies or tasks has not been established in this study.
Regarding supervision, our method requires fully sampled reference images and pixel-level segmentation labels during training, but neither is required at inference. Once trained, the model processes undersampled measurements for the corresponding task. Nevertheless, we acknowledge that acquiring these training resources can be costly and limits applicability in settings where paired data or annotations are unavailable. Our experiments evaluate the method within this supervised setting and do not resolve the problem of insufficient training data.
To examine robustness to changes in sampling conditions, we additionally evaluated reconstruction and segmentation under different sampling masks (Table 2 of Page 8). Our method continued to outperform the comparison methods under the evaluated conditions. These results support generalization to the tested sampling patterns, but should not be interpreted as evidence of generalization across anatomies or tasks.
Regarding regions where (t_n) is close to zero, we would like to distinguish attenuation of the task-weighted denoising update from exclusion of those regions from reconstruction. When (t_n\approx0), the corresponding denoising contribution is attenuated. However, these regions remain subject to reconstruction loss in Eq (23). Thus, a near-zero denoising weight alone does not establish that the corresponding region is excluded from reconstruction.
Question1: We have added the loss functions and training loop to the appendix. The trained model weights will be publicly released upon acceptance of the paper.