acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Norm-Controlled Likelihood Guidance for Diffusion-based Inverse Solver

Abstract

Diffusion-based inverse solvers approximate the posterior by combining a pretrained diffusion prior with an approximate likelihood guidance term. For Tweedie plug-in likelihood-guided solvers, which evaluate measurement likelihoods on a Tweedie posterior-mean estimate , we identify a clear diagnostic signal in the evaluated settings: for the same image and inverse task, different noise realizations lead to different reconstructions, and larger low-noise likelihood-guidance norms correlate with worse perceptual quality across the tested hosts and runs. This makes the likelihood-score norm an actionable empirical diagnostic for this solver family. To leverage this signal, we propose Norm-Controlled Likelihood Guidance, a training-free wrapper composed of three modules that steer the sampling trajectory toward smaller likelihood norms while retaining the pretrained diffusion prior term. Theoretically, we establish a low-noise certificate showing that, under a tractable multi-modal Tweedie plug-in model, smaller likelihood norms imply smaller score approximation errors up to an explicit floor. Experimentally, NCLG improves the host solvers across all reported rows in our FFHQ and ImageNet-256 evaluations, with ablation studies and cost analyses further supporting the design and quantifying representative quality–compute trade-offs.

Primary area:
probabilistic methods (Bayesian methods, variational inference, sampling, UQ, etc.)
Keywords:
Diffusion Model, Inverse Problem, Generative Modeling

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_zbDWOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies diffusion-based inverse solvers that use Tweedie plug-in likelihood guidance, such as DPS. The authors observe that, for the same image and task, runs with larger likelihood-score norms in the low-noise stage tend to give worse LPIPS. Based on this signal, they propose NCLG. A theoretical analysis on a Gaussian mixture model relates the likelihood-score norm to the true conditional-score error.

Critical strengths
  • The method is plug-and-play and needs no training. It improves four different host solvers, and the task coverage is broad.
  • The comparisons under similar compute are convincing. NCLG performs better than hosts with more sampling steps, and also better than Best-of-8, CAS, ReGuidance, random restarts and data-consistency selection.
Critical weaknesses
  • The writing is hard to read. Hedging phrases such as "in the evaluated settings" and "across the reported rows" are repeated many times. The paper is 38 pages long, and the appendix is also very long.
  • Some experimental details are missing. I could not find the number of evaluation images in the main paper or the appendix. All experiments use pixel-space diffusion models, and no latent diffusion based inverse solver is tested. The paper also does not compare with newer and stronger solvers.
  • The extra cost is large. On DPS, full NCLG takes about 5.5 times longer than the host, and peak GPU memory rises from 2.81 GB to 10.24 GB.
Questions for authors
  • How many images are used for evaluation?
  • Can the method be applied to inverse solvers based on latent diffusion models?
6 comments

We thank the reviewer for the helpful feedback on our presentation and evaluation. We respond to the concerns in turn below.

W1. Presentation and length

We thank the reviewer for this feedback. Regarding presentation, we have removed redundant qualifiers such as "in the evaluated settings" and "across the reported rows" from the introduction, experimental discussion, and appendix to make the writing more direct. The experimental scope is specified in Section 5.1.

Regarding length, the paper covers theoretical analysis, three sampling modules, and evaluations across multiple solvers and tasks. We have made this material easier to navigate: Section 5.4 summarizes the additional experiments in four focused bullet points, each with a direct reference to the corresponding appendix section.

W2 and Q1. Number of evaluation images

We thank the reviewer for requesting this clarification. As stated in Appendix H.3 (Evaluation Protocol), mean LPIPS is computed over 100 evaluation instances per configuration. Each instance uses an independent sampling run. We have stated this explicitly in Section 5.1.

W2. Comparison with more recent solvers

The paper already includes comparisons with DCPS [2024], MGPS [2025], DAPS [2025], CAS [2024], adapted misalignment-map selection [2023], and PnP-DM [2024]. The NCLG variants improve reconstruction quality over their respective host solvers. To supplement these results, we additionally provide comparisons with DiffStateGrad-DPS [1, 2025] and SPGD [2, 2025] on FFHQ center inpainting with σy=0.3\sigma_y=0.3, using the same evaluation instances, observation operator, and pretrained prior. The NCLG variants retain each host's gradient-management mechanism and add RS+LNP, with NSS disabled.

MethodLPIPS ↓Low-noise norm aggregate ↓
DPS0.316938.87
DPS + RS + LNP0.138106.74
DiffStateGrad-DPS0.264892.63
DiffStateGrad-DPS + RS + LNP0.132105.81
SPGD0.247517.92
SPGD + RS + LNP0.12596.14
DiffStateGrad-DPS uses a retention threshold of 0.99 and applies projection at every step. SPGD uses 100 outer steps, five warm-up iterations per step, and ADM with β=0.95\beta=0.95. Both recent methods improve on DPS, and adding NCLG further reduces LPIPS and the likelihood-score norm. We have added these comparisons and configurations in Appendix H.16, Table 26, with a pointer from Section 5.2.

W2 and Q2. Applicability to latent diffusion models

Yes, the norm-control mechanism can be adapted to latent diffusion solvers directly. Let DD be the decoder and z^0(zt,t)\hat z_0(z_t,t) the clean-latent estimate. For Gaussian observation noise, the corresponding likelihood guidance is gtz=−∇zt∣y−A(D(z^0(zt,t)))∣222σy2.g_t^z=-\nabla_{z_t}\frac{\\|y-\mathcal A(D(\hat z_0(z_t,t)))\\|_2^2}{2\sigma_y^2}. LNP can use this latent-space guidance and its norm; RS can restart through the latent model's inversion procedure; and NSS can select among stochastic latent proposals using low-noise norm probes. To evaluate this extension, we use the pretrained unconditional FFHQ LDM-VQ-4 model [3] on FFHQ 256×256256\times256 center inpainting with σy=0.3\sigma_y=0.3. The setting uses a 200-step host schedule and the same 100 evaluation instances, masks, and noisy observations as our pixel-space evaluation.

MethodLPIPS ↓Low-noise latent likelihood-score norm aggregate ↓
DPS0.32474.35
DPS+RS+LNP0.14336.51
We have added the latent-space score, setup, and results in Appendix H.19, Eq. (85) and Table 29, with a summary in Section 5.4.

W3. The extra cost is large

We thank the reviewer for raising this concern. We clarify that our existing experiments already show that our method outperforms the baselines under comparable computational budgets. For a direct comparison, we reproduce below the results for ImageNet256 center inpainting with σy=0.3\sigma_y=0.3 reported in Appendix H.8.

Lower-cost configuration: RS+LNP versus 1,000-step baselines.

MethodHost stepsTime (s/image) ↓LPIPS ↓
DPS1,000394.20.425
DPS + RS + LNP200253.70.337
MGPS1,000953.50.403
MGPS + RS + LNP200469.30.340
DCPS1,0001184.30.374
DCPS + RS + LNP200569.80.337

Higher-cost configuration: full NCLG versus 2,000-step baselines.

Full NCLG applies NSS at the start of the second pass, tinv=⌈0.7T⌉t_{\mathrm{inv}}=\lceil0.7T\rceil, as clarified in Section 4.1 and Appendix H.5.

MethodHost stepsTime (s/image) ↓LPIPS ↓
DPS2,000786.30.417
DPS + RS + LNP + NSS200548.10.324
MGPS2,0001882.40.392
MGPS + RS + LNP + NSS200736.90.331
DCPS2,0002346.10.368
DCPS + RS + LNP + NSS200908.80.328

These results are reported in Appendix H.8, Table 19. We have highlighted both budget regimes in Section 5.2.

References

[1] Diffusion State-Guided Projected Gradient for Inverse Problems. [2] Enhancing Diffusion Model Stability for Image Restoration via Gradient Management. [3] High-Resolution Image Synthesis with Latent Diffusion Models.

Thank you for the additional experiments.

Could you clarify whether the 100 evaluation instances correspond to 100 distinct images, and how many sampling runs are used per image?

Please also report the runtime of the newly added comparisons and the peak GPU memory of the lower-cost RS+LNP configuration. The runtime comparisons are helpful, but the memory overhead remains a concern.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to reviewer zbDW part. 1

We thank the reviewer for these follow-up questions.

1. Evaluation images and sampling runs

We are sorry for the confusion. We clarify that, in our implementation, we use 100 distinct images with 10 independent sampling runs per image.

Here we report the mean LPIPS and LPIPS standard deviation for DPS and DPS+RS+LNP on FFHQ center inpainting with σy=0.3\sigma_y=0.3, as in Table 4. We compute the mean and sample standard deviation of LPIPS over the 10 runs for each image, then average both statistics across the 100 images. For normalized std, we divide the standard deviation by the mean LPIPS for each image, then average these ratios across the 100 images.

MethodMean LPIPS ↓Average within-image LPIPS standard deviationNormalized std ↓
DPS0.3160.04180.1365
DPS + RS + LNP0.1380.00310.0217

We find that NCLG is more stable across sampling runs. This may be attributed to RS, which obtains a data-informed initialization through deterministic inversion of the first-pass reconstruction. Similar first-pass reconstructions of the same observation can lead to similar restart states, supporting consistent refinement across runs. We will clarify the number of images and runs per image and include these stability statistics in the revised manuscript.

2. Runtime of the newly added comparisons

We report the runtimes of the additional comparisons on FFHQ center inpainting with σy=0.3\sigma_y=0.3, using 100 distinct images and 10 sampling runs per image. We also compare the augmented baselines to compare reconstruction quality and runtime at a larger sampling budget.

Recent solvers and their NCLG variants.

MethodLPIPS ↓Low-noise norm aggregate ↓Time (s/image) ↓
DPS0.316938.875.25
DPS (1,200 steps)0.263915.5330.42
DPS + RS + LNP0.138106.7413.48
DiffStateGrad-DPS0.264892.636.32
DiffStateGrad-DPS (1,000 steps)0.248838.4329.20
DiffStateGrad-DPS + RS + LNP0.132105.8114.79
SPGD0.247517.9225.74
SPGD (1,000 outer steps)0.219454.82115.94
SPGD + RS + LNP0.12596.1453.27

SPGD step counts refer to outer diffusion steps, with five warm-up iterations per step.

Latent diffusion (LDM-VQ-4).

MethodLPIPS ↓Low-noise latent likelihood-score norm aggregate ↓Time (s/image) ↓
Latent DPS (LDM-VQ-4)0.32474.3548.13
Latent DPS (LDM-VQ-4, 1,000 steps)0.29672.07234.85
Latent DPS (LDM-VQ-4) + RS + LNP0.14336.5193.57

Compared with increasing host sampling steps, RS+LNP achieves 42.9–51.7% lower LPIPS with 49.3–60.2% less runtime across all four hosts, demonstrating a better computation–performance trade-off. We will add these runtimes and extended-step comparisons to the corresponding experimental tables in the revision.

Reviewer_214uOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper empirically observes that larger likelihood-guidance norms in the low-noise regime tend to correlate with worse perceptual reconstruction quality in diffusion-model-based inverse problem solvers. Based on this observation, the authors propose NCLG, a training-free framework consisting of three components. The framework demonstrates improvements across multiple inverse problem tasks.

Critical strengths

The paper presents an interesting empirical observation: likelihood-score norms in the low-noise regime are more strongly correlated with reconstruction quality than those in the high-noise regime. This finding may offer a useful diagnostic signal for diffusion-based inverse problem solving.

Critical weaknesses

[W1] Unclear relationship between norm reduction and better reconstruction. The paper proposes a sampling framework based on the observation that likelihood-score norms correlate with reconstruction quality. Although Figure 1 and Table 1 support this empirical observation, it is difficult to conclude that reducing the norm leads to better reconstruction. For example, in the center-inpainting task in Table 5, the norm decreases substantially (938.87→112.51938.87\rightarrow112.51), while LPIPS improves only slightly (0.316→0.2740.316\rightarrow0.274). By contrast, adding LNP yields a small norm decrease (112.51→106.74112.51\rightarrow106.74) but a substantial LPIPS improvement (0.274→0.1380.274\rightarrow0.138). This raises the question of whether norm reduction sufficiently explains the mechanism behind the improvement.

[W2] Incremental novelty of gradient control. Many previous studies have addressed inaccurate or unstable likelihood guidance in diffusion-model-based inverse problem solving. For example, DiffStateGrad [1] preserves the diffusion prior by projecting the measurement-guidance gradient onto an appropriate subspace, while SPGD [2] analyzes conflicts between the prior and likelihood gradients and proposes a way to alleviate them. As explained in Section 4.1, this paper follows a similar line of work by normalizing the likelihood gradient and modulating the sampling process. Its use of gradient magnitude directly is a point of distinction, but it is unclear what fundamental advantages the proposed design offers over existing methods. More detailed comparisons, including direct experimental comparisons, are needed to support the claimed strengths of NCLG.

[W3] Insufficient explanation of the cause of improvement. NCLG combines three mechanisms: restart initialization, Langevin refinement, and stochastic candidate selection. However, it is difficult to determine whether the performance gains come from the core idea of likelihood-norm control or from the combination of a good initialization and additional refinement. Table 5, in particular, shows that LNP alone does not improve LPIPS, but yields a large improvement when combined with RS. This suggests that LNP’s effect depends on the initialization state produced by RS. Moreover, the basic idea behind RS is closely related to previous work, such as CCDF [3], which constructs a better initialization for inverse problem solving. An experiment comparing general Langevin refinement with LNP under the same initialization, or combining LNP with another initialization strategy, is therefore needed. Without such an experiment, it is difficult to determine whether the improvement comes from norm-based guidance.

[W4] Limited performance gain from NSS despite a large increase in computational cost. Table 4 shows that NSS substantially increases computational cost while providing a relatively small improvement. Peak GPU memory increases by about ×3.2\times3.2 and runtime by about ×2.2\times2.2, while LPIPS improves only from 0.1380.138 to 0.1310.131. Although the paper includes comparisons under different computational budgets, it remains unclear whether NSS provides enough practical value to be considered a core component.

[1] Zirvi, Rayhan, and Bahareh Tolooshams. "Diffusion state-guided projected gradient for inverse problems." ICLR 2025

[2] Wu, Hongjie, et al. "Enhancing diffusion model stability for image restoration via gradient management." ACM MM. 2025.

[3] Chung, Hyungjin, Byeongsu Sim, and Jong Chul Ye. "Come-closer-diffuse-faster: Accelerating conditional diffusion models for inverse problems through stochastic contraction." CVPR 2022

Questions for authors

[Q1] How do likelihood norms change during the sampling process? The paper does not explicitly show how NCLG affects the sampling trajectory. Could the authors visualize or quantify the likelihood-score norm at each timestep for the proposed method and the baselines? In particular, comparing the norm before and after applying LNP would help confirm whether the module acts as intended.

[Q2] Why is norm-based guidance better than general Langevin refinement? LNP performs Langevin refinement by normalizing the likelihood gradient and combining it with a prior score. However, the effects of the Langevin refinement process itself and those of norm-dependent scaling are not disentangled. Could the authors provide a comparison using the same RS initialization and computational budget against standard Langevin refinement with a fixed likelihood-guidance coefficient, or against a version that uses simple gradient clipping? Such experiments would also help clarify the methodological differences between this approach and existing methods such as DiffStateGrad [1] and SPGD [2].

[Q3] How does the LNP update actually reduce the likelihood-score norm? In Section 4.1 and Eqs. (74)–(76) of Appendix H.10, LNP performs Langevin updates using a normalized likelihood gradient. However, limiting the magnitude of a normalized gradient is different from reducing the original likelihood-score norm. Specifically, although Eq. (75) ensures that the norm of the adjusted likelihood gradient does not exceed a certain upper bound, it does not guarantee that the original likelihood-score norm decreases with each update. Furthermore, because the analysis in Eq. (76) is based on a restricted linear setting, is there a reason to expect this norm reduction to hold for general nonlinear observation operators and complex denoisers?

[Q4] How much does LNP’s performance depend on RS initialization? As shown in Table 5, applying LNP alone degrades performance, whereas combining it with RS yields a significant improvement. This suggests that a high-quality initialization may itself be an important factor in improving performance. Does LNP provide similar gains when paired with other existing initialization strategies, such as CCDF [3]? Such a comparison would help distinguish the effect of RS initialization from the norm-based refinement effect of LNP, and clarify why these two modules need to be combined.

[Q5] Do the theoretical assumptions hold during the actual sampling process? Theorem 3.2 and Eq. (5) describe the relationship between the likelihood-score norm and the conditional-score approximation error. However, the derivation relies on assumptions about posterior concentration, measurement consistency, and low-noise conditions. Appendix F.9 also states explicitly that this theory provides no guarantees at the trajectory level or with respect to reconstruction quality. To what extent are these assumptions satisfied along the actual sampling trajectories for datasets such as FFHQ and ImageNet? Given that Appendix Table 12 presents cases where a reduction in the norm does not align with an improvement in reconstruction quality, a more detailed analysis of how these theoretical conditions relate to actual performance gains is warranted.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to reviewer 214u part. 1

We appreciate the reviewer's thoughtful comments and constructive suggestions. Our responses follow below.

Q1. How do likelihood norms change during sampling?

To demonstrate how NCLG affects the sampling trajectory, we quantify the likelihood-score norm at each reported timestep for DPS and its NCLG variant (RS+LNP) on FFHQ center inpainting with σy=0.05\sigma_y=0.05.

Round / t/Tt/T0.70.60.50.40.30.20.1
First round (DPS)155.4357.1746.9543.3740.5038.0434.35
Second round (RS+LNP)128.2252.4438.8835.1833.0331.4528.73

The NCLG variant achieves a lower likelihood-score norm at every reported timestep.

We have added this comparison in Appendix H.15, Table 25, with a summary in Section 5.4.

W1. How does norm reduction relate to reconstruction quality?

We clarify that we do not claim a linear relationship between the likelihood-score norm and LPIPS. A possible explanation for the large LPIPS gain from a small norm change is that the refinement improves the reconstruction along directions to which LPIPS is particularly sensitive. Rather, our theory supports an approximately linear relationship between the likelihood-score norm and the conditional-score error norm under the stated assumptions.

We have clarified this distinction in Appendix F.9, in the paragraph "Score error versus perceptual reconstruction quality."

W2. What distinguishes NCLG from existing gradient-control methods?

We thank the reviewer for this question. We clarify the distinction in objective and design:

  • Likelihood-score norm reduction. NCLG explicitly targets likelihood-score norm reduction, motivated by its connection to conditional-score approximation error. DiffStateGrad [10] projects measurement gradients onto a diffusion-state subspace, while SPGD [11] mitigates prior–likelihood gradient conflicts and temporal fluctuations. These mechanisms do not explicitly target reduction of the original likelihood-score norm.

  • A norm-control wrapper for existing solvers. NCLG can be added to existing Tweedie-based solvers. These modules can operate alongside the host's gradient-management mechanism, allowing NCLG to complement methods such as DiffStateGrad and SPGD.

The main paper already reports improvements over DPS, DCPS, MGPS, DAPS, DDRM, and DDNM. Here, we also compare DiffStateGrad-DPS and SPGD with their NCLG variants on FFHQ center inpainting with σy=0.3\sigma_y=0.3. We use the same evaluation instances, observation operator, and pretrained prior.

MethodConfigurationLPIPS ↓Norm ↓
DPSBaseline0.316938.87
DPS + RS + LNPPaper defaults0.138106.74
DiffStateGrad-DPSState-guided projection, retention threshold 0.99, projection every step0.264892.63
DiffStateGrad-DPS + NCLGSame host + RS + LNP; NSS disabled0.132105.81
SPGD100 outer steps, 5 warm-up iterations per step, ADM β=0.95\beta=0.950.247517.92
SPGD + NCLGSame host + RS + LNP; NSS disabled0.12596.14

Here, we show the following:

  • NCLG substantially improves both methods. LPIPS decreases from 0.264 to 0.132 for DiffStateGrad-DPS and from 0.247 to 0.125 for SPGD, with lower likelihood norms in both cases. These gains demonstrate that the likelihood-score norm perspective complements existing gradient-management mechanisms.

  • The strongest baseline also has the lowest likelihood norm. Among the unaugmented baselines in this table, SPGD achieves both the lowest LPIPS (0.247) and the lowest likelihood norm (517.92), providing further empirical support for our norm-control perspective.

We have added the comparison and configurations in Appendix H.16, Table 26, and highlighted the complementarity in Section 5.2.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to reviewer 214u part. 2

W3, Q2, and Q4. Do the gains come from norm control or from initialization and refinement?

We thank the reviewer for suggesting these controls. To disentangle the effects of norm-based guidance, additional refinement, and better initialization, we conduct the following ablation study on FFHQ center inpainting with DPS, σy=0.3\sigma_y=0.3, and NSS disabled. We compare fixed-coefficient Langevin refinement, gradient-clipped Langevin refinement, and LNP under RS and CCDF-style initialization. The latter forward-noises the same first-pass reconstruction to tinv=⌈0.7T⌉t_{\mathrm{inv}}=\lceil0.7T\rceil.

InitializationAdditional refinementLPIPS ↓Norm ↓
Random initializationNone0.316938.87
Random initializationLNP0.3371585.94
RSNone0.274112.51
RSFixed-coefficient Langevin (αt=0.01\alpha_t=0.01)0.206110.47
RSGradient-clipped Langevin0.146107.60
RSLNP0.138106.74
CCDF-styleNone0.293852.62
CCDF-styleFixed-coefficient Langevin0.3251488.13
CCDF-styleGradient-clipped Langevin0.3351529.84
CCDF-styleLNP0.3281518.43

We draw two conclusions:

  1. Better initialization and additional refinement can help, but do not match RS+LNP. For example, RS with standard Langevin refinement and CCDF-style initialization without refinement both reduce the likelihood norm relative to the DPS baseline. However, neither matches RS+LNP in norm reduction or reconstruction quality.

  2. The results support the coupled design of RS and LNP. LNP increases the likelihood norm when combined with CCDF-style initialization, whereas it reduces the norm when combined with RS.

We have added these controls and conclusions in Appendix H.17, Table 27, with a summary in Section 5.4.

W4. Does the benefit of NSS justify its additional computational cost?

We clarify that the existing results in Appendix H.12, Table 23, show that standalone NSS provides an LPIPS improvement comparable to that of RS alone in Table 4, supporting its use when additional computation is available. For clarity, we reproduce the quality and runtime results from these two tables side by side in Appendix H.20, Table 30.

The results for FFHQ center inpainting with DPS and σy=0.3\sigma_y=0.3 are:

ConfigurationLPIPS ↓Time (s/image) ↓
DPS0.3165.25
DPS + RS0.27411.24
DPS + NSS0.26819.47

Relative to the same DPS baseline, NSS alone reduces LPIPS by 0.048, compared with 0.042 for RS, demonstrating a substantial standalone benefit.

We have added the standalone NSS benefit and computational cost comparison in Appendix H.20, Table 30, and highlighted its benefit in Section 5.2.

Q3a. How does LNP reduce the original likelihood-score norm?

We thank the reviewer for the careful feedback. We clarify that, following the practice of simplifying costly Jacobians in SCD [1] and SDS [2], LNP uses the normalized likelihood score to accelerate refinement by avoiding the additional derivative through gtg_t. We expand the calculations below to explain this approximation.

For the likelihood score gtg_t, direct score-norm refinement uses the direction

=-\nabla_{x_t}\\!\left(\frac12\\|g_t(x_t)\\|_2^2\right) =-J_{g_t}(x_t)^{\top}g_t(x_t),$$ where $J_{g_t}=\partial g_t/\partial x_t$. LNP instead uses the normalized likelihood score $$d_t^{\mathrm{LNP}} =\alpha_t g_t(x_t) =\operatorname{stopgrad}\\!\left(\frac{\gamma}{\\|g_t(x_t)\\|_2+\varepsilon}\right)g_t(x_t).$$ In the spirit of the Jacobian simplifications used in SCD [1] and SDS [2], we consider the local curvature approximation $-J_{g_t}\approx c_t I$ with $c_t>0$. This gives $d_t^{\mathrm{direct}}\approx c_tg_t$, explaining the approximate alignment with LNP. Normalizing this direction and retaining the prior score give $\nabla\log p_t+\alpha_tg_t=\nabla\log q_t(\cdot;\alpha_t)$ with $\alpha_t$ fixed, connecting direct refinement to LNP's local target. To justify this approximation, we compare the two refinements on FFHQ center inpainting with DPS ($\sigma_y=0.3$, 100 evaluation instances): | Refinement | LPIPS ↓ | Low-noise norm aggregate ↓ | Time (s/image) ↓ | |---|---:|---:|---:| | RS + direct score-norm refinement | 0.137 | 106.26 | 24.85 | | RS + LNP (normalized likelihood-score direction) | 0.138 | 106.74 | 13.48 | LNP achieves comparable LPIPS and low-noise norm aggregates at lower cost. We have summarized the computational motivation in Section 4.1 and detailed the direct-to-target connection in the opening paragraph of Appendix H.10, with the refinement directions in Eqs. (75)–(76), Table 21, and the SCD/SDS references.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply to reviewer 214u part. 3

Q3b. Why expect norm reduction with nonlinear operators and denoisers?

We thank the reviewer for this question. To explain why norm reduction can also occur with nonlinear operators and denoisers, we extend the descent argument in Appendix H.10 (Eq. (79)) by locally linearizing their composition Ft(xt)=A(x^0(xt,t))F_t(x_t)=\mathcal A(\hat x_0(x_t,t)), with Jacobian JFtJ_{F_t}. Under this local approximation,

\approx -\frac{\\|J_{F_t}g_t\\|_2^2}{\sigma_y^2}\le0.$$ This supports local norm reduction for sufficiently small likelihood steps when nonlinear curvature terms are negligible. We have included the curvature calculation and its local approximation in Appendix H.10, Eqs. (80)–(81). We further demonstrate the norm-reduction effect empirically on the nonlinear JPEG and HDR tasks: | Task | Norm before LNP ↓ | Norm after LNP ↓ | LPIPS before (DPS) ↓ | LPIPS after (DPS+NCLG) ↓ | |---|---:|---:|---:|---:| | JPEG (QF=2) | 433.6 | 127.54 | 0.463 | 0.334 | | HDR | 285.72 | 80.65 | 0.492 | 0.292 | We have added the norm measurements and final LPIPS comparison in Appendix H.18, Table 28, with a summary in Section 5.4; the nonlinear task settings remain in Appendix H.1. # Q5a. Why does a lower norm not improve reconstruction quality in Table 12? We clarify that Table 12 deliberately tests likelihood-proxy misspecification, including an incorrect noise variance and a mismatched noise family. Reducing a misspecified proxy norm need not improve reconstruction quality. Table 12 assesses the robustness of NCLG; it does not establish that the same norm–quality reversal occurs in our standard matched-model benchmarks. We have clarified the purpose of the misspecification study in Appendix G.1, immediately before Table 12. # Q5b. Do the theoretical assumptions hold during practical sampling? We clarify that our theory provides a low-noise certificate that motivates NCLG's design for the **full practical sampling procedure**: - **Why the assumptions are natural at low noise.** Adding noise that is small relative to mode separation leaves $x_t$ near the clean sample $x_0$ with high probability. In our model, the denoising posterior then concentrates near the original mode, keeping $\mathbb E[x_0\mid x_t]$ close to $x_0$. Since the observation comes from the same $x_0$, small measurement noise [6-9] also makes its predicted measurement close to $y$. Our theory formalizes the norm–error relation under these concentration and consistency conditions. - **How NCLG constructs assumption-consistent states during the full practical sampling procedure.** RS partially inverts a measurement-consistent first-pass reconstruction $x_0^{(1)}$. Under inverse consistency, $\hat x_0(z_{t_{\mathrm{inv}}},t_{\mathrm{inv}})\approx x_0^{(1)}$, keeping the posterior mean near that reconstruction and transferring its measurement consistency to the restart state up to inversion error (Section 4.2; Appendix H.14). Regarding the data model, MoGs are a standard and widely used setting for diffusion analysis [3-5], capturing multimodality while permitting explicit posterior calculations. We have added these explanations in Appendix F.9, referring to the existing inverse-consistency and residual-transfer analysis in Section 4.2 and Appendix H.14. # References [1] Steerable Conditional Diffusion for Out-of-Distribution Adaptation in Medical Image Reconstruction. [2] DreamFusion: Text-to-3D using 2D Diffusion. [3] Learning Mixtures of Gaussians Using the DDPM Objective. [4] What Does Guidance Do? A Fine-Grained Analysis in a Simple Setting. [5] Theoretical Insights for Diffusion Guidance: A Case Study for Gaussian Mixture Models. [6] Diffusion Posterior Sampling for General Noisy Inverse Problems. [7] Diffusion Posterior Sampling for Linear Inverse Problem Solving: A Filtering Perspective. [8] Tweedie Moment Projected Diffusions for Inverse Problems. [9] Monte Carlo Guided Denoising Diffusion Models for Bayesian Linear Inverse Problems. [10] Diffusion State-Guided Projected Gradient for Inverse Problems. [11] Enhancing Diffusion Model Stability for Image Restoration via Gradient Management.
Reviewer_zZfJOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes norm-controlled likelihood guidance (NCLG) for existing diffusion inverse solvers. It uses the low-noise likelihood-gradient norm as a diagnostic and combines partial inversion and restart, normalized Langevin refinement, and noise selection without retraining. The authors analyze the relationship between this norm and conditional-score approximation error under a finite-support prior. Experiments with four solvers on FFHQ and ImageNet256 report improved reconstruction quality across the main tested settings, at additional computational cost.

Critical strengths
  • The paper reports lower mean LPIPS in all 48 main comparisons. For FFHQ center inpainting with a noise standard deviation of 0.3, the method also gives lower LPIPS than baselines with more sampling steps and other tested alternatives at comparable or lower runtimes. These results are the strongest evidence of the method's practical value across existing diffusion inverse solvers.

  • The low-noise correlation analysis provides empirical support for the proposed diagnostic. The DPS ablation also shows that RS and LNP are more effective together than separately. These findings help motivate the framework and identify an interaction between the modules that contributes substantially to the reconstruction gains.

Critical weaknesses
  • The claim that the discrepancy floor vanishes at low diffusion noise is not established by the appendix analysis. The explicit bound includes twice the residual tolerance divided by the diffusion noise variance. The stated assumptions do not ensure that this term vanishes. The exponential factor also depends on measurement noise, rather than diffusion noise. This weakens the theoretical justification for the diagnostic.

  • The target distribution and norm reduction claimed for LNP are insufficiently justified. The likelihood weight depends on the current sample, so the target score includes an additional term from differentiating that weight. This term is missing from the update. The derivation uses a fixed weight, but does not justify the adaptive target. Reducing the measurement residual also does not necessarily reduce the likelihood-gradient norm, because the denoiser Jacobian depends on the current sample. The supporting descent calculation only covers a linear case where the denoiser is the identity map. These gaps limit the mathematical justification for the implemented refinement.

Questions for authors
  1. Under what additional assumptions does the discrepancy floor vanish as diffusion noise decreases? The authors should clarify how the residual tolerance and noise levels must scale for this claim to hold.

  2. Is the adaptive likelihood weight treated as fixed within each LNP update? If so, which claims about the target distribution and norm reduction remain valid for the adaptive procedure?

  3. The algorithm descriptions give different LNP activation windows. With the default settings, is LNP enabled at or below 70 percent of the original maximum diffusion timestep, or 30 percent? When is NSS applied if its default selection is at the original maximum timestep, but the restarted loop begins at 70 percent of that timestep? These details are needed to reproduce the results.

3 comments

We thank the reviewer for their careful reading and insightful questions. We address each point below.

Q1. Interpretation of the discrepancy floor

We clarify that, besides the identified term 2ry/σt22r_y/\sigma_t^2, both the remaining term in δfloorlik\delta_{\mathrm{floor}}^{\mathrm{lik}} and the likelihood norm ∣slik(x)∣2\\|s^{\mathrm{lik}}(x)\\|_2 contain the same explicit factor 1/σt21/\sigma_t^2 (Appendices F.3 and F.7). Factoring out this common scale gives

\sigma_t^2\delta_{\mathrm{floor}}^{\mathrm{lik}} &=2r_y+\frac{\Delta_{\max}\varepsilon_\kappa}{1-\varepsilon_\kappa} \exp\\!\left(-\frac{\Delta_{\min}^2}{4\sigma_y^2}\right),\\\\ \sigma_t^2\\|s^{\mathrm{lik}}(x)\\|_2 &=\frac{\\|\Sigma(x)(y-\bar\mu(x))\\|_2}{\sigma_y^2}, \end{aligned}$$ where $\Sigma(x)=\operatorname{Cov}(x_0\mid x)$ and $\bar\mu(x)=\mathbb E[x_0\mid x]$. With a measurement-consistency tolerance $r_y=O(\sigma_y)$, the first rescaled floor term is $O(\sigma_y)$, while the second is exponentially suppressed by $\Delta_{\min}^2/\sigma_y^2$ for fixed mixture geometry. The rescaled likelihood norm contains the explicit factor $1/\sigma_y^2$. Therefore, on this common scale, the floor provides a small additive tolerance in the low-measurement-noise regime. We have added the complete floor in Section 3, Eq. (6), and clarified the common-scale comparison in Appendix F.9, Eq. (61). # Q2a. Is the adaptive likelihood weight treated as fixed within each LNP update? Yes. We compute $\alpha_t$ from the current state and deliberately freeze it within each LNP update using stop-gradient. It serves as an adaptive normalization coefficient that compensates for variations in likelihood-score magnitude and helps stabilize the Langevin correction. With $\eta_{\mathrm{mcmc}}=1/\gamma$, the likelihood component of each step is bounded by $\\|\eta_{\mathrm{mcmc}}\alpha_tg_t\\|_2\le1$ (Appendix H.10). Accordingly, $q_t(\cdot;\alpha_t)$ is a local target for that update, and its score excludes derivatives through $\alpha_t$. We have made the frozen-weight convention explicit in Section 4.1 and Appendix H.10 (Eqs. (71)–(74)). # Q2b. How does LNP reduce the original likelihood-score norm? We thank the reviewer for the careful feedback. We clarify that, following the practice of simplifying costly Jacobians in SCD [1] and SDS [2], LNP uses the normalized likelihood score to accelerate refinement by avoiding the additional derivative through $g_t$. We expand the calculations below to explain this approximation. For the likelihood score $g_t$, direct score-norm refinement uses the direction $$d_t^{\mathrm{direct}} =-\nabla_{x_t}\\!\left(\frac12\\|g_t(x_t)\\|_2^2\right) =-J_{g_t}(x_t)^{\top}g_t(x_t),$$ where $J_{g_t}=\partial g_t/\partial x_t$. LNP instead uses the normalized likelihood score $$d_t^{\mathrm{LNP}} =\alpha_t g_t(x_t) =\operatorname{stopgrad}\\!\left(\frac{\gamma}{\\|g_t(x_t)\\|_2+\varepsilon}\right)g_t(x_t).$$ In the spirit of the Jacobian simplifications used in SCD [1] and SDS [2], we consider the local curvature approximation $-J_{g_t}\approx c_t I$ with $c_t>0$. This gives $d_t^{\mathrm{direct}}\approx c_tg_t$, explaining the approximate alignment with LNP. Normalizing this direction and retaining the prior score give $\nabla\log p_t+\alpha_tg_t=\nabla\log q_t(\cdot;\alpha_t)$ with $\alpha_t$ fixed, connecting direct refinement to LNP's local target. To justify this approximation, we compare the two refinements on FFHQ center inpainting with DPS ($\sigma_y=0.3$, 100 evaluation instances): |Refinement|LPIPS↓|Low-noise norm aggregate ↓|Time (s/image) ↓| |-|-|-|-| |RS + direct score-norm refinement|0.137|106.26|24.85| |RS + LNP|0.138|106.74|13.48| LNP achieves comparable LPIPS and low-noise norm aggregates at lower cost. We have summarized the computational motivation in Section 4.1 and detailed the direct-to-target connection in the opening paragraph of Appendix H.10, with the refinement directions in Eqs. (75)–(76), the comparison in Table 21, and the SCD/SDS references. # Q3. LNP activation and NSS placement We thank the reviewer for highlighting the need to clarify when NSS is applied. We clarify that all timesteps below refer to the original diffusion schedule with a maximum timestep of $T$. The first pass produces the host reconstruction $x_0^{(1)}$. RS then inverts it to $t_{\mathrm{inv}}=\lceil0.7T\rceil$ and starts the second pass there. NSS performs its default selection at this largest second-pass timestep, with $\mathcal T_{\mathrm{sel}}=\\{t_{\mathrm{inv}}\\}$. LNP is enabled during the second pass when $t/T\le0.7$. We have unified this sequence in Section 4.1, Figure 3, Appendices H.5–H.6 and H.12, and Algorithms 1–4. # References [1] Steerable Conditional Diffusion for Out-of-Distribution Adaptation in Medical Image Reconstruction. [2] DreamFusion.

Thank you for the clarifications and additional experiments. The LNP and NSS schedules are now clear, and the fixed-weight interpretation addresses my concern about the local target. The new comparisons also strengthen the empirical support.

However, the new floor argument concerns rescaled quantities at low measurement noise. It does not establish the original claim that the discrepancy floor vanishes as diffusion noise decreases. The norm-reduction argument supports small likelihood steps under a local approximation, but does not establish norm reduction for the complete LNP update. Since these arguments motivate the norm-control design, I remain concerned about the gap between the theoretical explanation and the implemented procedure. The additional experiments support the practical benefits, but do not fully resolve this concern. I will maintain my assessment.

We thank the reviewer for the careful follow-up. We believe our earlier explanation may have left room for misunderstandings about the intended scope of our theory and the design objective of LNP. We clarify both points below.

1. Scope of the discrepancy-floor argument

We clarify the wording of our theoretical statement and its intended meaning:

Our original wording is: "This exponential decay captures the rapid vanishing of mode ambiguity once the diffusion noise σt\sigma_t drops below the separation threshold." Specifically:

  • "vanishing" is intended to describe mode-ambiguity suppression (component of discrepancy floor) in the separated-mode regime, rather than convergence of the full discrepancy floor to zero.
  • The phrase "drops below the separation threshold" specifies the finite low-noise regime considered in our analysis, rather than the zero-noise limit.

Our claim is a small discrepancy bound at a fixed positive diffusion noise level under the stated conditions, not that the full floor vanishes as diffusion noise tends to zero. We will clarify this distinction in Section 3 and Appendix F.9.

2. Motivation for the complete LNP update and the roles of its components

We clarify that the complete LNP implementation objective is consistent with our theoretical analysis. Specifically:

  • Theoretical analysis. Our theory relates the likelihood-score norm to the conditional-score error norm within the forward diffusion model xt∼ptx_t\sim p_t. This forward diffusion model xt∼ptx_t\sim p_t is part of the assumptions underlying the analysis, so the implementation should maintain this diffusion-marginal consistency while reducing the likelihood-score norm.
  • LNP Implementation objective. Section 4.1 already states this joint motivation: reducing the likelihood-score norm while maintaining consistency with the diffusion marginal distribution pt(xt)p_t(x_t), rather than minimizing the norm in isolation.

Our motivation is therefore twofold: (i) reduce the likelihood-score norm and (ii) maintain consistency with the diffusion marginal distribution. To realize this joint objective, the complete LNP update combines two complementary components:

  • Likelihood correction. Our local analysis explains why this component can reduce the likelihood-score norm under the stated curvature and step-size conditions.
  • Langevin refinement with the prior score. The prior score and injected noise encourage consistency with the diffusion marginal p(xt)p(x_t), helping counteract drift away from states supported by the diffusion prior during likelihood correction.

The following ablation examines how these components work together on FFHQ center inpainting with DPS and measurement noise 0.3:

Refinement after RSLPIPS ↓FID ↓Low-noise norm aggregate ↓
None0.27430.11112.51
Likelihood correction only0.16347.3297.52
Prior score and Langevin noise only0.27329.86113.15
Complete LNP0.13828.80106.74

We draw two conclusions:

  • Likelihood-only refinement yields a lower norm but worse LPIPS and FID than complete LNP, and worsens FID relative to RS alone. Thus, minimizing the norm in isolation can degrade distributional quality.
  • Prior-only Langevin refinement gives little improvement in LPIPS and does not reduce the likelihood-score norm. Adding the likelihood correction improves both reconstruction quality and norm reduction.

Together, these results support LNP's joint objective of likelihood-score norm reduction and consistency with the diffusion marginal distribution. We will clarify this joint design rationale in Section 4.1 and add the component ablation to Appendix H.10.

We believe the clarifications above help resolve the misunderstandings underlying the two remaining concerns. We would be grateful if the reviewer could reconsider their assessment and score in light of these clarifications and the additional evidence.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.