- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper aims to present the Grid2Op as graphs to enable power-grid control.
Critical strengths
None, as I hardly can understand this paper, to the very very best of my effort.
Critical weaknesses
The presentation of this paper is far from good enough. So many notations and terms are not introduced/defined before using. Many statements are vague; tables and algorithms are not formally presented; math formulations are not carefully checked. I will list a few points but not all of them will be enumerated because basically this paper requires significant revision.
- Fonts are different from other submission
- The key term, Grid2Op, is not introduced. I m not an expert on this topic but considering this is a machine-learning conference, such domain-specific terms shall be introduced to broad readers.
- Not clear what is “environment specification 𝑆”
- Notation C is misused in Eq. 1
- Not clear what is “persistent entities 𝑉”
- Not clear what is “𝑀 to Grid2Op indices or derived identifiers”
- Not clear what does “This is a logical state; its arrays may be materialized lazily.” mean
- Table 1’s readability is very bad.
- Not clear what does “A projection may subsequently collapse this path, but the canonical state preserves it.” mean
- Algorithm 1’s format is not standard and not formal
- Eq. 3’s presentation is also terrible: a lot of notations are misplaced at the subscripts of the readout operator.
Questions for authors
Please check the weaknesses.