- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents Mycelium, a heterogeneous graph transformer for multiple inference tasks in electrical distribution systems, including state estimation, phase attribution, switch state inference, and fault diagnosis. The authors develop a unified graph representation for different grid components and introduce domain-specific designs such as communication edges and nominal voltage angle references. The model is trained on a combination of reference and synthetically generated distribution networks, and evaluated on unseen grids to examine its cross-grid generalization.
Critical strengths
- Efforts in data generation and evaluation. The authors construct a relatively comprehensive simulation pipeline and evaluate the model across multiple tasks, networks, and sensing conditions. The use of held-out network families is particularly valuable.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty. The proposed method largely consists of existing techniques assembled for a specific power system topic. Heterogeneous graph transformer, relation-specific attention, type-specific encoder, and task-specific heads are well-established components. The additional communication edges and nominal angle references are reasonable domain-specific modifications, but I do not see a substantial methodological advance beyond adapting existing graph learning architectures to electrical distribution systems.
-
Limited relevance and insights beyond the application domain. More importantly, it is unclear what new insights the proposed architecture offers to the broader graph representation learning community. The paper would be more compelling for ICLR if it identified a general learning challenge and proposed a solution that could potentially benefit applications beyond power systems.
-
Insufficient evidence for the communication edge design. In Table 3, randomly constructed communication edges outperform the proposed physics-motivated edges on several metrics, including switch-state inference on both the test split and benchmark.
-
Multi-task learning benefits are not supported. The comparison between joint and single-task training in Table 5 shows mixed results. Although multi-task training improves some metrics, single-task models still achieve better performance on others, including benchmark switch-state inference and exact fault localization.
-
Concerns for evaluation setup and benchmark difficulty. The fault detection F1 reaches 1.0 on both evaluation splits, while exact fault localization remains relatively poor. Given that fault onset is assumed to occur at the final observed timestep, I wonder whether the simulated detection task is overly simplified.
Questions for authors
See above.
6 comments
W5: Fault-detection difficulty and evaluation scope
-
Detection saturates under our protocol; classification and localization provide more informative comparisons.
- F1 of 1.0000 at the final timestep provides limited insight into harder detection settings. We are open to clarifying this scope and emphasizing classification and localization, while retaining detection in the pipeline.
- Benchmark fault-type accuracy is 0.7209, exact localization 0.1958 versus STGATv2’s 0.1177, and Hop@3 0.4114: a localization gain with substantial room for improvement.
-
The protocol targets prompt diagnosis at the first fault-affected observation.
- At the first fault-affected observation, a rolling window would place that observation at its endpoint without advance knowledge of onset. Random onset within fixed windows and sub-hour latency remain unevaluated with hourly data.
- Multi-hour persistence requires assumptions about clearance, protection, and restoration, which can change connectivity and energization. Later windows containing fault-affected history remain unevaluated.
Thank you again for your feedback. As discussion ends tomorrow, we would appreciate your response to our rebuttal and additional results. Please let us know if any concerns remain.
Thank you for recognizing the data-generation effort and held-out-family evaluation.
W1 & W2: Methodological contribution and broader relevance
Our contribution combines measurement-based inference, four-task prediction, and cross-family generalization.
Metadata-based reference alignment reduces angle error approximately 15-fold.
Equipment-aware connectivity and shared supervision support learning across grids.
The representation lesson is supported within distribution grids: aligning physical reference conventions improves angle prediction, while communication and shared-supervision benefits depend on task and grid family.
W3: Evidence for communication-edge design
Our design balances predictive gains, interpretable connections, and guaranteed coverage.
The comparisons demonstrate different strengths across this design space.
W4: Evidence for multi-task learning
Results are mixed, with a cross-family reversal in per-unit voltage MAE.
Fine-tuning provides separate, task-dependent adaptation value.