- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper learns representations of And-Inverter Graphs using input-support information, reconvergence features, and logic-based regularization. The paper reports improvements in gate similarity and signal-probability prediction across three datasets, with additional experiments on synthesis changes and transfer to another dataset.
Critical strengths
-
The method makes good use of circuit structure: input support tracks which primary inputs can reach a gate, and fanin overlap identifies reconvergence. These features give the model useful information about shared inputs, and their benefit is supported by the ablations.
-
The improvements are consistent across both tasks and the three main datasets, with reasonably strong gains over the baselines. The component ablations help explain where the gains come from, and splitting the data by source design makes the evaluation more convincing.
Critical weaknesses
-
It is still unclear how much the proposed update mechanism adds beyond the extra input features. The ablations show that support and context information help, but a strong baseline given the same features would be needed to isolate the benefit of the architecture.
-
The prediction-level robustness claim needs a more direct comparison. Without the original errors on exactly the same matched gate pairs, the reported errors after synthesis do not show how much each model degrades, so better starting accuracy could partly explain the advantage.
Questions for authors
-
Could you compare against a strong baseline using the same support and context features? This would help establish what the proposed update mechanism adds.
-
In the synthesis experiment, what fraction of gate pairs survives matching, and how do the original and transformed errors compare on those same pairs?
2 comments
Response to Reviewer VpdF (2/2): Synthesis Robustness
W2. Correspondence coverage and prediction robustness under synthesis transformations
The reviewer notes that absolute post-synthesis MAE alone cannot distinguish synthesis-induced prediction degradation from differences in initial accuracy. The reviewer also asks what fraction of evaluated gate pairs can be matched and how their original errors compare with post-transformation errors.
A2. Response
We appreciate this important distinction. To directly address the concern, we report gate-pair correspondence coverage and conduct paired pre-/post-synthesis evaluations on exactly the same matched pairs, separating initial prediction accuracy from synthesis-induced degradation.
1. Correspondence coverage and evaluation protocol.
Following Appendix A.7, we evaluate the same ForgeEDA test circuits under four transformations: resyn2, dc2, rewrite, and refactor.
Whole-circuit equivalence is checked using ABC CEC. Candidate node correspondences are identified using 15,000 shared random input patterns with consistent PI ordering and subsequently verified formally.
An original evaluated EQ pair is retained for a transformation only if both endpoints have verified correspondences. We use the common intersection retained across all four transformations for the paired comparison.
All models use fixed checkpoints without retraining, identical retained pairs, and the original truth-table-distance targets. MAE is computed per circuit and then averaged across circuits.
Table R3. Gate-pair correspondence coverage.
| Matching requirement | Retained pairs per 10,000 original pairs | Coverage |
|---|---|---|
| resyn2 | 7,640 | 76.4% |
| dc2 | 7,910 | 79.1% |
| rewrite | 8,870 | 88.7% |
| refactor | 8,790 | 87.9% |
| Common intersection | 7,160 | 71.6% |
Coverage is a pooled pair-count ratio, whereas the MAEs below are circuit-averaged.
Key finding. The common intersection retains 71.6% of the original evaluated pairs, enabling consistent paired comparisons across all four transformations.
2. Paired prediction errors before and after synthesis.
We measure the original-view MAE and post-synthesis MAE on the same retained pairs for DeepGate3 and CircuitGate.
Table R4. Paired prediction errors under synthesis transformations.
| Transformation | Model | Pre MAE | Post MAE | ΔMAE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| resyn2 | DeepGate3 | 0.0868 | 0.1971 | +0.1103 |
| resyn2 | CircuitGate | 0.0789 | 0.1661 | +0.0872 |
| dc2 | DeepGate3 | 0.0868 | 0.1933 | +0.1065 |
| dc2 | CircuitGate | 0.0789 | 0.1630 | +0.0841 |
| rewrite | DeepGate3 | 0.0868 | 0.1919 | +0.1051 |
| rewrite | CircuitGate | 0.0789 | 0.1138 | +0.0349 |
| refactor | DeepGate3 | 0.0868 | 0.1921 | +0.1053 |
| refactor | CircuitGate | 0.0789 | 0.1152 | +0.0363 |
Here, . The Post MAEs reproduce Table 12 under the common-subset protocol described in Appendix A.7.
Key findings.
(1) The robustness advantage extends beyond initial accuracy.
Before synthesis, the MAE gap between DeepGate3 and CircuitGate is only 0.0079 (0.0868 vs. 0.0789). After synthesis, the gap increases to 0.0303–0.0781 across the four transformations.
Thus, higher initial accuracy alone cannot explain the observed post-synthesis advantage.
(2) CircuitGate consistently exhibits smaller prediction degradation.
Averaged over the four transformations, the MAE increases are:
- DeepGate3: 0.106800
- CircuitGate: 0.060625
This corresponds to a 43.2% reduction in average synthesis-induced MAE degradation relative to DeepGate3. Importantly, the reduction occurs under every transformation, rather than being driven by a single favorable case.
(3) Correspondence selection is controlled.
Both models are evaluated on identical matched pairs, eliminating differences in pair selection as an explanation for the observed degradation gap. The original-view MAEs differ from Table 1 because the evaluation concerns the common matched subset of 20 circuits, rather than the complete ForgeEDA test set.
Conclusion. The paired results directly address the reviewer's concern: CircuitGate achieves not only lower post-synthesis MAE but also substantially smaller prediction-error increases on identical gate pairs. Together with the matched-node CKA results in Table 5, these findings provide complementary evidence of representation consistency and task-level robustness under functionality-preserving synthesis transformations.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for this suggestion, which helped us provide a more direct evaluation of synthesis-induced prediction degradation.
Response to Reviewer VpdF (1/2): Contribution of the Update Mechanism
We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing the consistent performance improvements, circuit-aware design, and source-disjoint evaluation of CircuitGate. We appreciate the important concerns raised in the review and provide additional controlled experiments to address them.
W1. Contribution of the update mechanism beyond additional features
The reviewer questions whether the proposed update mechanism provides benefits beyond additional functional inputs and suggests comparing CircuitGate with strong baselines equipped with the same support and context features.
A1. Response
We agree that component-removal ablations alone cannot fully distinguish the benefits of additional functional information from those of the update mechanism. To address this concern, we conduct two complementary controlled experiments: feature- and objective-matched baseline comparisons and update-mechanism replacements within the same backbone.
1. Feature- and objective-matched strong baselines.
We augment DeepGate3 and MGVGA with the same EDA-native context attributes, parity-indexed structural PI-support sketches, support-size and coverage statistics, and six-dimensional reconvergent-fanin descriptors used by CircuitGate.
These inputs are incorporated at each propagation layer through concatenation and learned projection while preserving the baselines' original message-passing operators. Feature-projection configurations are selected using validation data. All comparisons use identical source-disjoint splits, task labels, evaluation protocols, and validation-based checkpoint selection. The "+ Logic" variants additionally incorporate the same logic-inspired regularization as CircuitGate.
Table R1. Feature- and objective-controlled ForgeEDA EQ comparison.
Key findings. Additional functional information substantially improves both baselines. Nevertheless, CircuitGate achieves 9.4% lower MAE than augmented DeepGate3 and 10.7% lower MAE than augmented MGVGA, even after matching functional inputs and training objectives.
This remaining advantage indicates that the improvements cannot be attributed solely to additional features or logic regularization. How these dependencies are incorporated into representation updates also matters.
2. Controlled update replacements within the same backbone.
To isolate the architectural contribution more directly, we retain CircuitGate's backbone, all functional inputs, and training objective, replacing only the additional gated correction term in Equation (8).
We consider two alternatives:
The unmasked gate still receives the complete reconvergence descriptor and can learn to exploit support overlap. This comparison therefore isolates the effect of explicitly restricting the correction to reconvergent nodes.
Table R2. Controlled update replacements on ForgeEDA EQ.
Key findings. The original update reduces MAE by 8.1% relative to static fusion and 5.7% relative to unmasked gating.
Unlike the existing "w/o Reconvergence" ablation, both controls retain reconvergence information. Thus, these comparisons isolate the update mechanism more directly rather than conflating its contribution with feature removal.
Conclusion. The two experiments provide complementary evidence: CircuitGate maintains an advantage over feature- and objective-matched strong baselines, and its original overlap-conditioned update outperforms alternative correction mechanisms within the same backbone. These results support the architectural contribution beyond additional functional features and suggest that the explicit reconvergence mask provides a beneficial inductive bias.
We thank the reviewer again for this valuable suggestion, which helped us clarify the independent contribution of the proposed mechanism.