- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on smoke reconstruction from sparse views via vortex-based motion representation and Gaussian primitives. Instead of an Eulerian velocity field on fixed grid, this paper advocates a vortex-velocity joint representation to better track vortex motion and guarantee the velocity divergence-free condition. Thereafter, the LGM module is presented to locally reallocate and refine the visual details. The reconstruction results are evaluated on FluidNexus and ScalarFlow, as well as physical validation on synthetic data.
Critical strengths
The introduction of vortex representation is interesting and practical in fluid dynamics, which especially makes sense for smoke phenomena.
The paper reports competitive performance compared to several SOTA methods, e.g., PICT, FluidNexus.
Critical weaknesses
The tangible benefit of the claimed contribution is still not clear to me. Please refer to Questions For Authors below.
Questions for authors
- In the abstract, the paper claims “existing approaches require physical and visual constraints to be balanced”, and the paper “embeds fluid structure into…”. However, after reading the entire text, the physics and vision balance does not differ fundamentally from mainstream methodology. Please clarify what is novel in this regard.
- Please explain why ”vortex kernels constrain a broader spatial domain” compared with Eulerian velocity on grid under sparse views.
- The paper did not discuss or compare with recent works, such as NeuSmoke, GauSmoke, SmokeSVD. A direct comparison with GauSmoke seems quite essential.
- Biot-Savart law is traditionally used to describe the magnetic field generated by a constant electric current. Please justify its applicability and numerical treatment in your smoke reconstruction setting.
- The vortex representation is employed in a quite direct manner, via transport with velocity field and advection. What is the main gain and advantage of the vortex representation over grid-based velocity fields?
- The initialization of the vortex field is insufficiently described for reproduction. Please provide details.
- As for LGM module, what is its difference from an adaptive or two-level 3DGS? Table 6 shows marginal advantages over a direct application.
- The design of L_reg appears somewhat ad hoc.
- Table 3 reports PSNR of 31.72, while Figure 6 shows 26.60?
- Are any constraints imposed to improve long-term temporal consistency?