- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes AnalyticVarNet, an unrolled framework for multi-coil MRI reconstruction that incorporates a fixed covariant wavelet scattering operator. The operator combines Gaussian low-pass filtering with the modulus of oriented Morlet wavelet responses. It omits subsequent averaging and subsampling to preserve spatial information, while learned layers predict reconstruction corrections. The authors analyze the frequency coverage, translation equivariance, and stability of the fixed operator and evaluate the model on fastMRI knee and brain data. The main empirical advantages are improved robustness to unseen sampling patterns and reduced parameter count and inference time relative to the NO baseline.
Critical strengths
- Relevant problem and meaningful generalization setting. Robustness to acquisition-pattern changes is an important issue in learned MRI reconstruction.
- A well-motivated integration of analytic and learned components Combining fixed frequency and orientation analysis with learned adaptation and explicit data consistency is a well-motivated approach to reconstruction. The contribution lies mainly in this task-specific integration.
- Useful efficiency gains. The model reduces trainable parameters from approximately 141.8M to 57.4M and lowers reported inference time from 177.38 to 145.34 ms per slice.
Critical weaknesses
- Core attribution is unproven: only one baseline (NO), differing simultaneously in width, capacity, and structure. A matched-width, matched-parameter standard-conv ablation is missing.
- Robustness rests on a single baseline (NO); E2E-VN and diffusion methods are never tested for robustness. NO's collapse to ~11–13 dB/SSIM 0.34 on Gaussian/Poisson despite data consistency is suspicious and should be checked for evaluation artifacts.
- Only J=1 Morlet bank is used; genuine scattering multi-scale structure is absent. The "scattering" claim in the title/abstract is overstated.
Questions for authors
- Given your claim that finer low-frequency partitioning matters at higher native resolution, is J=1 validated on 640×640 data? Can you provide an L (number of orientations) sensitivity analysis?
- Does the positive lower frame bound apply to discrete Nyquist grids or a specified band-limited space? A finite collection of decaying filters cannot have a uniform positive lower bound over all continuous frequencies. Are the reported and established analytically or evaluated numerically?
- Are standard deviations computed across slices or volumes? Are training, fine-tuning, and evaluation sets disjoint at the subject level? Can volume-level paired differences or confidence intervals be reported?