- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the selection of new operators in adaptive VQE. The authors employ the Schur complement () of the QGT to quantify the geometric novelty of candidate operators. They experimentally compare ADAPT, the purely geometric selection method GAG, GAGrad, and random selection across four qubit configurations for LiH and BeH₂. The authors argue that perturbations in the reference state can lead to "gradient failure," and that geometric information improves operator selection near convergence while enhancing robustness against noise.
Critical strengths
Energy decrease and tangent space expansion are distinct selection signals; combining them is of research value.
Critical weaknesses
There is a logical error in the key reasoning of Theorem 1. Page 5 assumes that the gradient ranking degrades and approaches a random state under perturbation, and the proof on page 14 asserts that the correlation between gradient and geometric rankings must pass through negative values. However: correlation gradually approaches zero does not mean correlation necessarily becomes negative.
The experiments have not established any meaningful failure or robustness, and there are clear discrepancies in the reported results; the absolute error associated with "gradient failure" is very small. All these values are far below the chemical accuracy of 1.6x10^-3 Ha adopted in the paper.
The table on page 8 clearly extends beyond the layout boundaries; while the main text on page 8 states that the system ran on ibm_boston, the note for Table 10 on page 19 reads: Values are estimated from calibration data; actual results may vary.
Estimates derived from calibration data cannot serve as direct evidence of actual device measurements. Until this is clarified, the paper's conclusion regarding "real hardware verification" cannot be accepted.
Questions for authors
Regarding Theorem 1, why is the emergence of a negative correlation interval inevitable? Please explicitly rule out the hypothesis that "correlation remains non-negative and tends toward zero," and explain why fixed utility and fixed geometric ranking cause GAG to fail under strong perturbations.
How can one distinguish between gradient failure and residuals caused by optimization tolerance?
Where exactly is the noise in Table 1 applied?
Do the results in Table 10 represent empirical measurements, noise simulations, or calibrated estimates?
Why is there no comparison with directly relevant geometric baselines?