- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose GSCP-Net, a physics-guided framework for optical field reconstruction under atmospheric turbulence. It combines a pretrained VAE with unitary coded probes to construct Gram matrices, reducing reconstruction to latent variable estimation. Experiments on a 2 km simulated turbulence channel with 42 combinations of turbulence strengths and receiver apertures demonstrate superior reconstruction accuracy, adaptability to dynamic turbulence, and training efficiency compared with the selected baselines.
Critical strengths
- The paper effectively exploits Gram invariance in lossless optical propagation and models finite-aperture effects through a low-dimensional effective metric, translating physical properties into a practical measurement design while avoiding explicit estimation of the full instantaneous propagation operator.
- By freezing the VAE and optimizing only the unitary probe codebook, the method reduces channel-dependent training costs while ensuring unitarity through structural parameterization, offering a simple design with potential applicability to other structure-constrained measurement tasks.
Critical weaknesses
- GSCP-Net uses 12 or 15 coded probes to obtain multiple measurements, whereas the U-Net and NAFNet baselines appear to use a different measurement protocol. Can the authors provide comparisons under matched measurement budgets and acquisition costs to demonstrate that the performance gains come from the proposed Gram-structured probe design rather than additional observations?
- Under finite-aperture reception, the effective metric varies across turbulence realizations, while the receiver uses a training-derived mean metric . Why does recovery remain stable when the instantaneous metric deviates substantially from its mean? Can the authors quantify the impact of metric estimation error and analyze sensitivity to the number of turbulence realizations used for estimating the mean metric?
- The method relies on a pretrained VAE to represent source fields in a low-dimensional latent space, and the experiments primarily use amplitude and phase maps constructed from MNIST. To what extent does the recovery performance depend on the learned source prior? Does the method remain effective for out-of-distribution complex fields or fields that cannot be accurately represented by the VAE?
Questions for authors
Please refer to the Weaknesses.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer uLhb (2/3)
Weakness 2: deviation of the metric from its mean, impact of the metric error, and number of realizations.
Under finite-aperture reception, the effective metric () varies across turbulence realizations, while the receiver uses a training-derived mean metric (). Why does recovery remain stable when the instantaneous metric deviates substantially from its mean? Can the authors quantify the impact of metric estimation error and analyze sensitivity to the number of turbulence realizations used for estimating the mean metric?
(1) In most conditions, the effective metric deviates little from the mean metric, so recovery is stable. The deviation is large only under strong turbulence with a small aperture, where recovery also degrades.
(2) The recovery error caused by the metric error is bounded, and every measured error lies within the bound, on average at about one third of it.
(3) The mean fidelity is insensitive to the number of realizations. With 8 turbulence realizations, it is already 0.83, the same as with the 64 used in the paper. The worst fidelity rises slowly with the number of realizations, from 0.50 with 8 to 0.54 with 64. A few dozen realizations are therefore enough for calibration in practice.
Table 3.2. Ablation of the mean metric, including the number of turbulence realizations used for calibration.
| Metric used by the receiver | Mean fidelity | Worst fidelity |
|---|---|---|
| No channel statistics (codebook unchanged) | 0.80 | 0.35 |
| Mean metric, 1 realization | 0.81 | 0.31 |
| Mean metric, 8 realizations | 0.83 | 0.50 |
| Mean metric, 64 realizations (paper) | 0.83 | 0.54 |
| True metric of each realization (ideal, not available in practice) | 0.86 | 0.86 |
Results for the mean metric with 64 realizations are taken from Table 2 of the paper. All other results are new and averaged over 3 seeds.
(1) Why recovery stays stable. Under weak and moderate turbulence, as long as the aperture is not too small, the effective metric deviates from the mean metric by at most 10%. This is because the part that is the same in every realization (e.g., how much light enters the aperture on average) is already contained in the mean metric, and only the fluctuation of each realization remains. For example, for m$^{-2/3}$ with apertures of 220 mm or more, and for m$^{-2/3}$ with apertures of 260 mm or more, the fidelity is 0.86, the same as with the true metric of each realization. Under the strongest turbulence ( m$^{-2/3}$) with the smallest aperture (140 mm), the deviation is as large as the mean metric itself, and the fidelity drops to 0.54. Even in this condition, the learned codebook raises the fidelity from 0.30 with the fixed codebook to 0.54 (Table 2 of the paper), because it is trained with the true effective metric of each realization.
(2) Error bound. To first order, the recovery error satisfies , which follows from Eq. (22) in the main text and Eq. (42) in Appendix A. Here, is the error in the Gram matrix caused by the metric deviation, and is the smallest singular value of the Jacobian of the equations solved by the receiver. We verified this bound in every condition using 32 turbulence realizations and 64 images per realization (new). The measured error of every sample lies within the bound, on average at about one third of it.
(3) Number of realizations. With only 1 realization, the estimated mean metric still contains the fluctuation of that realization, and the worst fidelity is only 0.31. With 96 realizations instead of the 64 used in the paper, the worst fidelity rises only slightly, from 0.54 to 0.55. Therefore, 64 realizations are already enough.
In the revision, the main text will include this error bound. The appendix will also report the ablation of the mean metric and of the number of turbulence realizations used for calibration, as well as the verification of the bound.
Response to Reviewer uLhb (3/3)
Weakness 3: dependence on the learned source prior, and out-of-distribution fields.
The method relies on a pretrained VAE to represent source fields in a low-dimensional latent space, and the experiments primarily use amplitude and phase maps constructed from MNIST. To what extent does the recovery performance depend on the learned source prior? Does the method remain effective for out-of-distribution complex fields or fields that cannot be accurately represented by the VAE?
(1) The recovery depends on the VAE only through the ceiling. A better VAE raises the ceiling but does not make the method more robust to turbulence.
(2) The method remains effective for out-of-distribution fields. Their fidelity is lower only because the VAE represents them less well, which lowers the ceiling. After turbulence, the mean fidelity still retains at least 96% of the respective ceiling.
Table 3.3. Ablation of the source representation and out-of-distribution fields.
| Source representation | Test fields | Ceiling | Mean fidelity | Fraction of ceiling retained |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Linear PCA | MNIST | 0.69 | 0.66 | 96% |
| Deterministic autoencoder | MNIST | 0.88 | 0.84 | 96% |
| VAE (paper) | MNIST | 0.86 | 0.83 | 96% |
| VAE (paper, not retrained) | EMNIST letters (unseen) | 0.79 | 0.76 | 96% |
| VAE (paper, not retrained) | Fashion-MNIST clothing (unseen) | 0.61 | 0.59 | 97% |
Results for the VAE on MNIST are taken from Section 4.1 and Table 2 of the paper. All other results are new and averaged over 3 seeds. For PCA and the autoencoder, only the source representation is changed, and the codebook is retrained with the same recipe. For EMNIST and Fashion-MNIST, the VAE and codebook of the paper are used directly, without retraining. The ceiling is the fidelity of the decoded field when the receiver estimates all 64 numbers exactly.
(1) Dependence on the source prior. The VAE compresses the source: it maps the 28×28 amplitude and phase maps (1568 numbers) to the 64 numbers that are transmitted. After the receiver has estimated these 64 numbers, the VAE decoder restores the source field. With a deterministic autoencoder instead of the VAE, the mean fidelity remains essentially unchanged (0.84 versus 0.83 for the VAE). Linear PCA gives a lower mean fidelity of 0.66, but only because it compresses the source less well: its ceiling is 0.69 (VAE 0.86, autoencoder 0.88). After turbulence, all three representations retain about 96% of their ceilings (Table 3.3), and the mean fidelity of each is within 0.03–0.04 of its ceiling. This indicates that a better representation raises the ceiling but does not make the method more robust to turbulence. The method therefore does not depend on the VAE specifically.
(2) Out-of-distribution fields. We applied the VAE and codebook of the paper directly to unseen EMNIST letters and Fashion-MNIST clothing images. The VAE represents these fields less well, so the ceiling drops to 0.79 and 0.61, respectively. After turbulence, however, the mean fidelity still retains 96% and 97% of the respective ceilings (Table 3.3). The recovery through turbulence therefore works as well as on MNIST (96%). With a VAE trained on such data, the mean fidelity reaches 0.84 in both cases (Table 10 of the paper). The mean metric does not need to be recalibrated, because it depends only on the turbulence and the aperture, not on the source. However, richer fields, such as natural images, cannot be represented accurately by 64 numbers. They require more numbers and more probes, and we leave this extension to future work.
In the revision, the appendix will include the source-representation ablation (PCA, deterministic autoencoder, VAE) and the results on out-of-distribution fields. A new paragraph on practical requirements and limitations in the main text will state that 64 numbers cannot represent richer fields accurately.
We hope these responses address your concerns, and we are happy to discuss any further questions.
Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments, which have substantially addressed my original concerns. Although the comparable performance of the Gram-based MLP leaves some questions about the distinct contribution of the physics-based receiver, I appreciate the additional evidence and clarification provided by the authors. Overall, the rebuttal has strengthened my confidence in the paper, and I have decided to raise my rating.
Response to Reviewer uLhb (1/3)
We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback and the suggestion of a comparison under matched measurement budgets. We are glad that the reviewer found that the paper "effectively exploits Gram invariance in lossless optical propagation" and offers "a simple design with potential applicability to other structure-constrained measurement tasks". We address the three weaknesses below (parts 1–3).
We first summarize how the results are evaluated. A fidelity of 1 means perfect recovery. Before transmission, the VAE compresses the source into 64 numbers. Even if the receiver estimated all 64 numbers exactly, the decoded field would reach a fidelity of only 0.86 on average (Sec. 4.1). This ceiling is set by the VAE, and a different VAE gives a different ceiling. Since we focus on recovering the field after turbulence, the loss caused by turbulence and the aperture should be read relative to 0.86, not 1. Each result is evaluated on 42 conditions, namely all combinations of 6 turbulence strengths (Cn2 from 10−15 to 3×10−13 m$^{-2/3},weaktostrong)and7receiverapertures(140–480mm).Themeanandworstfidelityaretheaverageandtheminimumofthe42per−conditionfidelities.ForGSCP−Net,theminimumoccursunderthestrongestturbulence(C_n^2 = 3\times10^{-13}$ m$^{-2/3}$) with the smallest aperture (140 mm). All results are averaged over 3 random seeds, and the same definitions are used in parts 2 and 3.
Weakness 1: comparison under matched measurement budgets and acquisition costs.
The gain comes mainly from the structure of the Gram matrix, not from additional observations. As requested, all receivers in Table 3.1 use the same 12 probes as GSCP-Net, at the same measurement budget and acquisition cost. With these 12 observations, U-Net and NAFNet reading the received fields reach a mean fidelity of only 0.44 and 0.48, respectively, versus 0.83 for GSCP-Net. An MLP reaches a mean fidelity of 0.82 when it is trained on the Gram matrix, but only 0.45 when it is trained on the received fields.
Table 3.1. Comparison under the same measurement budget and acquisition cost.
Results for GSCP-Net are taken from Table 2 of the paper. All other results are new and averaged over 3 seeds. All receivers in Table 3.1 use the same number of transmissions, the same total energy and the same acquisition time. The worst fidelity leads to the same conclusion (Table 3.1). U-Net and NAFNet reach a worst fidelity of only 0.22 and 0.17, respectively, versus 0.54 for GSCP-Net. The MLP reaches a worst fidelity of 0.59 when it is trained on the Gram matrix, but only 0.16 when it is trained on the received fields. Moreover, with 12 received fields instead of the single field used by the baselines in the paper, the mean fidelity of U-Net and NAFNet rises only from 0.32 to 0.44 and from 0.28 to 0.48, respectively. The additional observations therefore account for only a small part of the gain of GSCP-Net, and the rest comes from the structure of the Gram matrix.
In the revision, the U-Net and NAFNet baselines that read 12 received fields will be added to Table 1 and to the reconstruction examples in Figure 3 of the paper. Table 2 of the paper will also include the two MLP rows (trained on the received fields and on the Gram matrix).