- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposed HarmoCore to reconstruct oscillatory wave fields from scattered sensors using shared continuous spatial bases and sample-specific Functional Tucker cores. In particular, it proposed a frequency-aware, compact representation of complex oscillartory wave fields based on functional Tucker models. Then it trains a frequency-conditioned diffusion prior over normalized cores and reconstructs fields through observation guidance in core space, optionally supplemented by Helmholtz-equation residual guidance. Experiments show improvements under 1%–2% sensing.
Critical strengths
It reports significantly better results in 2D and 3D field reconstruction using the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
Both the 2D and 3D fields are pretty simple and symmetric. It seems that they are generated from single source and single frequency. It would be good to consider a variety of fields with different sparsity levels.
Questions for authors
- What is the main benefits of using stacked real and imaginary channels over using stacked amplitude and phase channels?
2.How about the performance of field reconstruction generated by multiple sources and multiple frequencies? Is it necessary to train a different model for a different source and frequency? - Does diffusion outperform regularized inference in the same frozen basis when observations and physical constraints are held fixed?
- Figures 5–7 label rows as amplitude and phase, while their captions describe real and imaginary components.
4 comments
Thank you very much for your detailed and constructive review. As the discussion is approaching its end, we wanted to kindly follow up. We have updated our response/paper to address the concerns and questions you raised (please see our latest reply/update). We would greatly appreciate it if you could let us know your current thoughts and any further questions or concerns you may have. We remain happy to clarify or provide additional information. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Thank you again for your review. As the discussion is closing soon, I wanted to kindly follow up. We would greatly appreciate any feedback you may have. Thank you for your time.
Thank you again for your review. As the discussion deadline is approaching, we would be grateful for any final comments or confirmation you may have. Thank you for your time.
We sincerely thank you for the careful review and constructive feedback. We particularly appreciate the valuable suggestions, which have helped us improve our experiments and clarify the contributions and limitations of our work.
R1 — Multi-Source Fields, Multiple Frequencies, and Sensing Ratios
We thank you for highlighting the importance of field diversity. Our benchmarks include 1–4 sources in 2D Helmholtz, 1–3 in 3D Helmholtz, and 1–3 in synthetic fields, with randomized source positions and complex phases. Figures 7–9 provide multi-source examples.
The benchmarks cover 51, 41, and 17 frequencies for 2D Helmholtz, 3D Helmholtz, and synthetic fields, respectively. For 2D Helmholtz, 11 frequencies are used for training and 40 for interpolation. A single frequency-conditioned model is used across all frequencies; no separate model is trained per frequency.
We also added an independent-source evaluation (Appendix C.7). The 20 test configurations have unseen source-position/complex-amplitude combinations relative to the 500 training configurations. Without retraining, HarmoCore achieves 0.03656±0.03392 Rel. L2 at 5% sensing over 1,020 source-frequency cases, and 0.03482±0.03014 over the 800 interpolated-frequency cases.
The main results cover 1%, 2%, and 5% sensing, with additional 10% results in Appendix B.1. Our frequency-generalization claim is limited to interpolation within the evaluated range.
R2 — Why Real/Imaginary Channels Instead of Amplitude/Phase?
We use real and imaginary components as the modeling channels because they provide a natural Cartesian representation of the complex wave field.
For a complex field,
u=uR+iuI,
the amplitude and phase are
\qquad \phi=\arg(u_R+iu_I).$$ There are two main reasons for choosing the real/imaginary representation. First, the complex Helmholtz equation naturally couples the real and imaginary components. Using these components directly allows the governing-equation residual to be formulated and differentiated without introducing additional transformations. Second, phase is a periodic variable with a branch discontinuity at the phase boundary and becomes poorly defined near zero amplitude. Modeling real and imaginary components avoids explicit phase unwrapping and provides a continuous Euclidean representation for diffusion training. We emphasize that the joint-versus-independent ablation in Table 7 evaluates the benefit of jointly modeling the two Cartesian components. It is not a direct experimental comparison between real/imaginary and amplitude/phase representations. We therefore present the above as the motivation for our representation choice rather than claiming that its superiority over amplitude/phase has been experimentally established. For visualization, the qualitative figures display amplitude and phase derived from the reconstructed real/imaginary channels. ## R3 — Does Diffusion Outperform Regularized Inference in the Same Frozen Basis? We added two complementary comparisons. **Learned versus Gaussian prior.** Table 11 replaces only the learned diffusion score with a conditional Gaussian score, keeping the frozen FTM, observations, source, initialization, normalization, guidance, and sampling fixed. At 1%/10% sensing, the learned score achieves Rel. L2 errors of 0.130/0.031, versus 0.284/0.149 for the Gaussian score. **HarmoCore versus fixed-basis LS.** Table 12 compares HarmoCore with observation-only least squares using the same frozen spatial factors. On 20 independent source configurations, their Rel. L2 errors at 1%/2% sensing are 0.128/0.067 and 0.750/0.500, respectively. At 5%, they are comparable (0.038 vs. 0.039), while at 10% LS performs better (0.011 vs. 0.032). These results indicate that the learned prior is particularly beneficial under extreme sparsity, but does not always outperform LS at higher sensing rates. We acknowledge that LS does not use PDE guidance; the Gaussian-score comparison provides the more controlled comparison under identical physical guidance. ## R4 — Amplitude/Phase and Real/Imaginary Figure Labels We thank you for identifying this inconsistency. The model is trained on joint Re/Im channels, while the figures visualize the derived amplitude and phase. We have corrected the row labels and captions to clarify this distinction.