- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DistoDyn proposes to use pairwise distance distributions produced by structure predictors as cheap alternative to explicit conformational sampling. The distogram is used either to construct additional graph edges or directly as edge features. Then relational GNNs are used to combine distance edges, with these distogram-derived relationships.
Critical strengths
- The paper is dealing with how to incorporate conformational info into scalable protein representation without requiring MD trajectories. The motivation & idea of reusing info from structure predictor is appealing.
- The evaluation is complete, covering residue classification, affinity, mutational stability, PPI, RNA tasks, etc. Some of the effect sizes are large enough and I believe there is a real and useful signal in those distograms.
Critical weaknesses
- My major concern is on the interpretation of those signals in the distograms. A structure predictor's distogram is not, in general, a Boltzmann distribution over physical conformation (of course, the authors may argue that can be learned by large corpus of training). It can contain different confounding factors including but not limited to aleatoric structural variability, evolution information, training-set priors, etc.. I think there could be some more experiments to directly demonstrate the claim on "dynamics" (especially, distinguish "dynamics" from a very strong learned soft-contact representation). Additionally, I guess there are architecture/capacity confounds, particularly in the PPI experiment. Adding a relation to an R-GNN changes more than the graph: it adds relation-specific parameters. Thus a distance-only model and a distance+distogram model are generally not parameter matched.
Basically, I hold the positive attitude towards this work. Additional illustrations are welcome from the authors.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors distinguish “dynamics” from a very strong learned soft-contact representation?
- (Minor) Does the quoted 30-second figure include MSA search, preprocessing, model initialization, and full inference? If not, the comparison is not end-to-end.
We thank the reviewer for their comments and their positive appreciation of our work.
> W1 My major concern is on the interpretation of those signals in the distograms. A structure predictor's distogram is not, in general, a Boltzmann distribution over physical conformation (of course, the authors may argue that can be learned by large corpus of training). It can contain different confounding factors including but not limited to aleatoric structural variability, evolution information, training-set priors, etc.. I think there could be some more experiments to directly demonstrate the claim on "dynamics" (especially, distinguish "dynamics" from a very strong learned soft-contact representation)
We thank the reviewer for raising this important point. We believe that strong evidence that distograms encode dynamic information was provided in previous publications by several research groups. For example, in 10.1038/s41467-026-69172-y the authors used distograms to generate conformational ensembles of intrinsically disordered proteins, whose accuracy was validated against a large set of experimental data. A similar approach was proposed in 10.1038/s41467-025-56572-9. More recently, in 10.1002/qub2.70062, the authors demonstrated that multi-modal distograms encode information about protein alternative states, well beyond local fluctuations around the ground state.
All these works provide a solid foundation of our interpretation of distograms capturing protein dynamic information. We will include a section in the related work dedicated to the established links between distograms and dynamic.
Beside the literature cited above, the comparison of the performances obtained in our tasks where Molecular Dynamics data is available, and specifically the comparison between distances+distograms vs distances+distograms+MD data, indicates that MD is not providing additional information compared to distograms. This point, along with the references cited above, indicates that most of the predictive improvement is attributable to dynamics. We will put forward this important comparison by clarifying the paragraph around L316 and adding an explicit reference to Table S4.
>W2 Additionally, I guess there are architecture/capacity confounds, particularly in the PPI experiment. Adding a relation to an R-GNN changes more than the graph: it adds relation-specific parameters. Thus a distance-only model and a distance+distogram model are generally not parameter matched.
In the PPI experiment, our baseline is external and represents the current SOTA for this task. SpatialPPIv2 was retrained from scratch on our dataset in order to compare its performance with our approach. For this reason, we didn’t alter the architecture and number of parameters of the model.
We carried out additional experiments on both the binding-site prediction and binding-affinity prediction tasks, matching the number of model parameters and the average number of edges per graph across graph constructions by adjusting the distance and distogram thresholds. The results show consistent improvements with the distance + distogram construction across both tasks and architectures, with the exception of a slight decrease in accuracy for EGNN on the binding-site prediction task. This suggests that the observed imp
Affinity prediction task:
Binding-site prediction task:
We hope to have addressed your questions, and thank you again for helping us improve our submission.