- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper uses Flood Complexes to represent MD trajectories, which is a sensible thing to do. It further adds a protein-based prior, which is the masking of inter-residue atoms when constructing the PH features.
Critical strengths
- The paper uses Flood Complexes to represent MD trajectories, which is an improvement upon other PH based approaches for MD.
- The paper also adds a protein specific masking, which makes sense, and improves the results.
Critical weaknesses
No major weaknesses. The main contribution is applying Flood Complexes to MD and adding atom masking. The masking step is very intuitive, and the use of PH is not new to MD. While it is not very novel, it works well.
Questions for authors
-
Does the analysis show the importance of the different Gaussians (exponential structure elements) on the dynamics, and explain what each element represents?
-
How does removing some of them affect the MSM, and can combinations of these Gaussians act as an indicator for specific dynamics?
2 comments
We thank the reviewer once more for their input, which has led to a stronger submission. In light of the approaching end of the discussion period, we would like to ask whether our responses have sufficiently addressed all raised questions. If so, and if the reviewer deems it warranted, we would greatly appreciate a reconsideration of our score. Otherwise, we remain happy to answer any further questions.
To briefly summarize this thread:
- We discussed all angles in which our approach indeed displays novelty, including that our kinetic embedding transfers to unseen datasets (see also our new results on ATLAS in the thread of reviewer
g36h). - It is indeed possible to attribute importance to individual structure elements. Those corresponding to voids linked to small cavities are made visible by masking and contribute most to the slow dynamics captured by the kinetic embedding (Appendix G.2).
- Removing the most important elements costs several times as much as removing random ones, and their combination acts as an indicator of folding (Table 27, Fig. 7).
We thank the reviewer for the feedback and for taking the time to evaluate our work. We are pleased that the reviewer finds our approach intuitive and recognizes its effectiveness.
As a general comment regarding novelty, we want to highlight that we do not just simply apply PH in the context of studying MD. Instead, our mFlood approach introduces a method to infuse domain-specific knowledge into the simplicial complex construction itself, i.e., the very basis for all downstream applications. As we lay out in our answer to reviewer g36h's first question, this renders filtration values biologically informative, e.g., with respect to the presence of secondary protein structure and folding contacts. Overall, this enables building computationally tractable topological representations that are both structurally and dynamically informative. We furthermore, deviate from the traditional method of learning kinetic embeddings specific to each protein, and introduce a topologically-informed shared kinetic embedding space. These embeddings turn out to be kinetically more consistent than those from traditional approaches and also generalize in various ways: first, as was added in this rebuttal (see section 5.2 and D.5), they do so for the lower temperature simulations of the unseen ATLAS dataset (Vander Meersche et al., Nucleic Acid Res, 2024), identifying subtle important motions; second, the generative model training, guided by MSMs, transfers to contrasting dynamics of smaller, fast-folding proteins.
In summary, novelty can be summarized as (1) the introduction of domain knowledge at the basis of simplicial complex construction via masking, (2) computational tractability and scalability of the latter, (3) building topological representations that are both structurally and dynamically informative of proteins, (4) the learning of a shared kinetic embedding space and (5) strong empirical evidence for generalizability.
Questions
Assessing the importance and interpretation of individual structure elements is a good idea. We added two such analyses to the paper (see Appendix G.2).
First, to measure the importance of single structure elements on the dynamics, we shuffle the values of the corresponding feature (i.e., a single coordinate of the PH vectorization) along the time axis of the MD trajectories, while preserving all other features. We then record how much the VAMP-2 loss deteriorates. The three most important structure elements identified in this manner are located in the H2 diagrams at birth times between 3.2–3.3 Å. Looking at the points in the persistence diagrams that are closest to these structure elements, we see that they correspond to small cavities that exist in the folded domain and disappear as it unfolds (see Fig. 7d–f). Moreover, for the most important structure elements, we observe that the majority of their corresponding feature (a sum of contributions from individual voids) comes from voids that are only made visible to the filtration by masking.
While the above addresses the contribution of each structure element in terms of dynamic information, we can not rule out that the VAMPNet is capable enough to restore temporal information from a combination of the other elements. To address your second question, we assess how much of the VAMP-2 score is lost when retraining the network without particular combinations of features.
First, we observe that retraining without the H0 vectorizations, i.e., without all H0 structure elements, has almost no effect on the VAMP-2 score (0.7%), while removing H1 (14.3%) and H2 (16.8%) vectorizations results in a large drop. We conclude that important slow dynamics are primarily encoded in H1 (loops) and H2 (voids).
Second, removing the overall 32 (6.3%) or 96 (12.5%) most important structure elements identified from the shuffling experiment (across H0, H1 and H2) costs 3–5 times as much as removing the same number of random ones. Furthermore and to answer your last question, we hypothesize that combinations of elements do act as indicators of specific dynamics. More specifically, the summed value of the three most important elements is high in folded conformations and drops as the domain unfolds, closely following the fraction of native contacts along a trajectory (Fig. 7 d-f). Across validation domains, the corresponding contribution follows the fraction of native contacts with a median correlation of 0.66.