- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors propose TwinMP, a post-training framework for adapting pretrained single-conformation inverse-folding models to dual-conformation design. The method keeps two parameter-tied streams for the two conformations, introduces residue-aligned cross-conformation message passing, and then fuses the hidden states for sequence prediction. The framework is evaluated on ProteinReasoner, ESM-IF, and ProteinMPNN using amino-acid recovery and structural consistency metrics, with an additional ProteinGym mutation-effect prediction experiment.
Critical strengths
- Reasonable method with broad evaluation. Adapting pretrained inverse-folding models to multi-conformation inputs is a sensible idea, and the paper evaluates it across three model families with both sequence- and structure-based metrics.
- Clear presentation. The paper is well organized, the figures are clear, and the method and experimental setup are easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited novelty relative to DynamicMPNN. DynamicMPNN has already studied essentially the same multi-conformation inverse-folding problem. The paper does not clearly explain what important limitation of DynamicMPNN it addresses, especially relative to DynamicMPNN+DSS, which also fuses features during message passing.
- The key message-passing contribution is not clearly described in the Method section. And the ablations show only small gains from message passing.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors explain in substantially more detail how residue-aligned message passing is implemented for each backbone, especially ProteinMPNN?
- What is the precise methodological difference between TwinMP and DynamicMPNN+DSS? DynamicMPNN+DSS also allows intermediate representations from different conformations to interact. It would be helpful to explicitly compare the two update rules and explain what capability TwinMP provides that DSS does not.