- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors introduce the multi-state conformer generation strategy for AF3-style co-folding models. Using SWE approach on AF3's OPM operation, multiple pair representation can be obtained. The authors evaluated their method on multi-conformation systems, including multi-state states including membrane, domain motion and fold-switching, and ligand-induced systems including GPCR, kinase, and cryptic pocket. Moreover, the ablation studies are provided to evaluate the individual contributions of SWE and QBOP.
Critical strengths
The motivation of this work is clear. While AF3-style co-folding models use stochastic diffusion methods, they often fails to recover multiple conformational states and generate a single state. Therefore, these methods rely on stochasticity of MSA subsampling and require many inference seeds to recover diverse states. Instead, this method suggests how to preserve multiple views from a single MSA information on single trunk run.
Critical weaknesses
-
It is unclear how this methodology can be combined with the common recycling strategy involving MSA subsampling employed in AF3-style co-folding models. In particular, much of the structural diversity observed in AF3 is driven by MSA subsampling, yet the paper does not analyze the synergy between the proposed method and conventional subsampling.
-
It is difficult to argue that the ability to reconstruct the holo state without ligand information supports the method’s capacity to preserve evolutionary heterogeneity. Unlike in monomer-focused methods such as AFCluster or BioEmu, evolutionary signals guide co-folding models to generate either the apo or holo state depending on the presence or absence of a binding ligand. Consequently, it is unclear whether the improved recovery performance comes at the expense of the co-folding model’s ability to distinguish between conformational states based on binding context.
Questions for authors
- The generation settings used for evaluation are unclear. Author should report the inference settings including inference seeds, number of diffusion samples, and recycling iterations.
- How does the proposed method behave under the different binding conditions? For example, AF3Cluster, which incorporates MSA clustering of AFCluster to AlphaFold3, investigates how to find both apo and holo states with binding context.
[1] Cheng, Xiwei, et al. "Generalized Multi-State Protein Design with AlphaFold3." ICLR 2026 Workshop on Generative and Experimental Perspectives for Biomolecular Design.