- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
SPARNet is a 3D medical segmentation architecture intended to address detail loss from coarse tokenization and directional bias from Cartesian serialization in state-space models. SAFE aligns multiple patch scales on a fine token grid; SLS uses crop-centered radial layers with complementary inward/outward traversals; feature refinement and bidirectional fusion restore and combine volumetric features. Evaluation uses Synapse abdominal CT and MSD Pancreas CT under a shared training protocol. The eight-region rotational variant reports 85.25% mean Dice / 12.20 HD95 on Synapse and 64.02% / 17.15 on MSD Pancreas. Component, scan-order, layer-width, and plug-in ablations investigate the design.
Critical strengths
-
A useful investigation of serialization for volumetric state-space models. The radial scanning design provides a concrete alternative to axis-aligned flattening, and the scan-order ablation holds the surrounding backbone fixed. The supplementary plug-in experiments with U-Mamba, SegMamba, and SegMamba-V2 report HD95 improvements without changing parameter counts, providing evidence that the scan itself has value beyond the full architecture. These experiments are more informative than a comparison of complete networks alone.
-
Promising boundary-sensitive results with several relevant controls. The eight-region variant improves both reported mean Dice and HD95 over the evaluated baselines on the two datasets, with particularly encouraging pancreatic tumor results. The paper includes organ-level results, repeated Synapse runs, scale/fusion ablations, and measured patch latency and memory. I also appreciate the explicit acknowledgement that crop-centered scans are less suitable for some geometries and that the model is relatively heavy.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological advance appears incremental, and baseline coverage is insufficient to establish its significance. Multi-scale feature alignment, refinement, and bidirectional fusion are established design patterns. The shared-weight direct/reduce-expand Mamba branches closely resemble the squeeze/reinforce branches in EM-Net, which the paper acknowledges. The main distinct contribution is therefore the specific radial scan and its combination with these components. The novelty argument should distinguish this contribution from prior spatial/anatomical modeling, including nnMamba and Topology-Guided Deformable Mamba (TGDM). TGDM uses costal-cartilage topology/centerline priors, whereas SPARNet uses a geometric crop center; they are related approaches rather than identical methods.
The experimental comparison should prioritize a well-configured nnU-Net v2, including an appropriate residual-encoder preset, which is absent despite nnU-Net being cited. Other relevant additions are nnMamba, EM-Net, and 3D TransUNet. The issue is incomplete coverage and configuration, rather than all baselines being outdated: SegMamba-V2 (2025) is already included. A common 500-epoch SGD recipe is useful for a controlled architecture study, but does not establish that each competitor is competitively configured. Please disclose baseline variants, adaptation/tuning choices, and resource budgets. This concern is supported by nnU-Net Revisited, which shows why configuration and compute-aware validation matter. For the complete architecture, Table 10 also increases capacity from 41.22M to 92.36M parameters; the plug-in controls support SLS, but do not fully isolate the benefit of the larger combined network.
- The evaluation is too narrow, with unresolved selection and reproducibility issues. Only two abdominal CT datasets are used: Synapse has 18 training and 12 validation volumes, and MSD Pancreas has 225 training and 56 validation volumes. Section B.2 selects the best checkpoint by validation Dice, while the reported evaluation appears to use these same validation splits; no separate untouched test set is described. This risks optimistic performance estimates, especially with scan variants and layer widths also investigated on Synapse. Repeated runs on one fixed split do not capture uncertainty from patient sampling; the number of runs/seeds is unspecified, and MSD results lack comparable uncertainty reporting. Broader generalization to different anatomy, modalities, or external cohorts remains unestablished.
There are also concrete inconsistencies that impede reproduction. Algorithm 1 does not explicitly initialize the Stochastic-In path and fuses path outputs before applying a single inverse permutation, whereas Section 5 says each path is inverse-permuted before fusion. Table 12 reports 85.34 Dice / 8.62 HD95 for uniform width 1.0, outperforming the chosen uniform width 3.0 (85.25 / 12.20) on both metrics, yet Section C.3 describes width 3.0 as offering the best Dice. These may be presentation errors, but the implemented coordinate alignment and model-selection rationale need to be resolved. Together with the limited novelty and incomplete baseline evidence, these issues lead me to 2: weak rejection.
Questions for authors
Clarifications that could materially affect my assessment:
-
Were checkpoint selection, scan/width selection, and final evaluation performed on distinct patient sets? Please provide the exact split and selection procedure, the number of repeated runs and optimization/scan seeds, and explain which runs the tables summarize. If independent test, cross-validation, or patient-level uncertainty results already exist, please report them; otherwise qualify the generalization claims.
-
Can you provide a comparison with properly configured nnU-Net v2 / nnU-Net ResEnc under disclosed, comparable resource budgets? Please identify the variants and configuration/tuning process for all baselines. Comparison with nnMamba and EM-Net would help establish progress within volumetric Mamba models; 3D TransUNet is another relevant comparator for global modeling and small-target segmentation. Please separate the controlled common-recipe comparison from results using each method's recommended configuration, if available, and clarify how capacity affects the full-network gains.
-
Please reconcile Algorithm 1 with Section 5: where is the Stochastic-In path initialized, and are both path outputs restored to matched spatial coordinates before fusion? Please provide the corrected computation sequence corresponding to the reported implementation. Also explain the width-3.0 choice and revise the interpretation of Table 12, where width 1.0 has better Dice and HD95. Why do the HD95 changes in Table 11 not match subtraction from the baseline means in Table 2; do they use different runs or reference configurations?
-
What is the precise methodological distinction from EM-Net's shared-Mamba branches and TGDM's topology-guided spatial modeling? Please compare the required priors, sequence construction, and coordinate restoration. A numerical TGDM comparison would be informative if its anatomy-specific components can be fairly adapted to the same tasks; if this is not appropriate, explain the incompatibility and provide a substantive related-work comparison.
Suggestions for future work, rather than demands for new experiments during rebuttal: evaluate additional anatomy/modalities or external cohorts, and quantify sensitivity to crop-center placement, window offsets, and scan-construction seeds. These would test the generality of the proposed geometric prior.