- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces 4DRefGS, a 4D reconstruction pipeline for dynamic reflective scenes. Motivated by prior works, 4DRefGS introduces a dual 4D Gaussian representation to separate physical-surface from reflections. Evaluation on the self-captured dataset shows improved rendering quality. However, the evaluation is not thorough enough. There is no visualization to support reflective disentanglement.
Critical strengths
-
This paper stuides dynamic reflective reconstruction, which is a challenging yet important problem.
-
On SelfCap, 4DRefGS outperforms all the baselines in rendering.
Critical weaknesses
-
4DRefGS is more like a system design, which combines many modules from existing works, such as Ref-DGS and FreeTimeGS. Thus, the novelty is limited.
-
Evaluation is not thorough.
- More baselines are required. FreeTimeGS should be compared.
- The diversity of evaluation benchmark is limited. I suggest adding evaluation on NeRF-DS [1], which focuses on dynamic specular objects.
- On Neural3DV, PSNR and SSIM and not explicitly improved. Authors should visualize the rendering results of different methods, especially in the regions with reflections.
- SelfCap is a small dataset that only contains two scenes. More videos with different scene types should be added to test the robustness of the pipeline. As shown in Figure 2, the reflection is mainly diffuse reflection and the reflective objects are flat floors. In addition, the video corresponding to the first row does not contain changing illumination as claimed in the paper. I would suggest adding the evaluation on more challenging settings, such as sharp mirror reflection and specular highlight. In addition, reflective objects with different shapes could be added, e.g. balls.
- Geometry should be visualized, such as normal map.
-
Ablation study is not convincing. SSIM and LPIPS keep the same after removing modules. In addition, the experiments of different modules are conducted on different sequences.
-
To better support reflective disentanglement, it would be helpful to visualize the rendering results of both global branch and local branch.
[1] Yan et al. Nerf-ds: Neural radiance fields for dynamic specular objects. CVPR 2023.
Questions for authors
see ''weaknesses''