- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Authors propose to perform a multi-level wavelet decomposition of LR image, and uses a diffusion technique to better estimate the residuals and then adds it to the bicubic interpolated image to get the superresolution done.
Critical strengths
It is a good thing to explore the use of wavelets for SR (albeit not a new technique -- see comments later). It also obviates the need for "paired" LR-HR training data. Experiments are adequate and results are a bit better than SOTA.
Critical weaknesses
The key step in the manuscript is eq (7) that tries to utilize a conditional probability relationship between various layers (scales) of wavelet representation. I have a major concern for this -- if the lower scale image generation is done through a proper choice of wavelet, then the residual (after LPF) should be orthogonal to the LR image and if that is true, there is not a conditional probability as the conditioning falls off, ie, p(x/y) = p(x). How do you justify this? Your diffusion process then becomes unconditioned. How does it then converge?
You have done several ablation studies regarding various (hyper) parameters of the learning process, but not the most important part related to the wavelet decomposition! How does the reconstruction change if I use different types of wavelets (you may use different Daubechis (sp?) wavelets and then Haar and other wavelets). You must do an ablation on that.
Although the manuscript does refer to the most recent relevant citations, but it is very poor in terms of refering to distant past -- as if it does not exist! There have been several works on single frame super resolution, use of wavelet or contourlet for image SR without and LR-HR paired training (off hand, I remember C.V. Jiji's work in around 2004-5, pl also check P. Milanfar, etc). They did precise what you did except, of course, the ML part.
Questions for authors
See above.