- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the problem of periodic grid artifacts in one-step Diffusion Transformer (DiT) models for real-world image super-resolution. Through a translation equivariance analysis, the authors investigate the phenomenon of token-phase dependence. To mitigate this issue, they propose PhaDiSR, which consists of Polyphase Token Reassembly (PTR) for velocity prediction correction, a Token-Phase Wavelet Discriminator (TPWD) based on multi-scale and multi-shift Haar transforms, and Self-Prior Projection (SPP) for constructing training references. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed method effectively alleviates periodic artifacts and achieves competitive perceptual quality across multiple real-world image super-resolution benchmarks.
Critical strengths
1.The paper addresses the practically relevant problem of periodic artifacts in one-step DiT-based super-resolution. The motivation is clear, and the problem has practical significance.
2.The proposed method is thoughtfully designed to address the identified problem. PTR performs phase-aware correction in the velocity prediction space, while TPWD provides supervision in the image space. These two components complement each other in mitigating periodic artifacts.
3.The experimental evaluation is reasonably comprehensive, including quantitative and qualitative comparisons on multiple datasets, as well as ablation studies of the main components. The proposed method achieves competitive results on several no-reference perceptual quality metrics.
Critical weaknesses
1.OP4KSR[1] has already provided a detailed analysis of the causes of periodic grid artifacts, showing that they are related not only to latent token packing but also to positional encoding, such as RoPE. This prior work somewhat weakens the novelty of the problem analysis presented in this paper. The authors should further clarify the differences between PhaDiSR and OP4KSR and highlight the specific advantages of the proposed approach.
2.Conventional GAN-based adversarial supervision can already suppress periodic grid artifacts to some extent. Therefore, it remains unclear to what extent TPWD alone, without PTR, can suppress these artifacts, and how much additional improvement TPWD provides over a conventional GAN discriminator. More direct quantitative and qualitative comparisons would help establish the effectiveness and necessity of the proposed TPWD design.
3.The paper lacks detailed inference efficiency comparisons. Since PTR introduces additional computational overhead, the authors should report inference latency, GPU memory usage, and FLOPs compared with the baseline and existing methods under identical settings.
[1]Chengyan Deng et al. OP4KSR: One-Step Patch-Free 4K Super-Resolution with Periodic Artifact Suppression
Questions for authors
Please see the three points raised in the Weaknesses section.
Thank you for your insightful review and kind follow up
Dear Reviewer 3obv,
Thank you again for your thorough and insightful review, which helped us substantially strengthen the paper. As the discussion period closes soon, we wanted to kindly check if our responses, revised manuscript, and additional experiments have addressed all of your concerns. Please let us know if any further clarification would be helpful. We truly appreciate your time and consideration!