acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Intermediate-Annotation-Free Latent Visual Reasoning via Multi-level Pseudo-Labeling

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Latent Visual Reasoning (LVR) enables Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) to perform intermediate reasoning in continuous representations, avoiding the need to verbalize visual information through discrete text. However, existing LVR methods either rely on costly intermediate annotations or learn latent tokens indirectly from final answer supervision, providing limited guidance on what the latent tokens should encode. We introduce Multi-level Pseudo-labeled Latent Visual Reasoning (MP-LVR), which derives explicit latent supervision directly from the pretrained LVLM's own internal signals without requiring intermediate human annotations or external teacher models. MP-LVR exploits layer-wise query-relevance attention patterns to adaptively construct multiple pseudo-labels, providing distinct supervision to individual latent tokens. In addition, we introduce Stochastic Information-Path Suppression, which reduces direct answer access to image and query tokens during training and encourages answer generation to utilize the latent tokens. Experiments demonstrate consistent improvements across diverse visual reasoning benchmarks and model configurations, while further analyses confirm that the latent tokens are actively utilized during answer generation.

Primary area:
unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords:
Latent Visual Reasoning, Large Vision-Language Models, Visual Reasoning, Latent Representation Learning, Pseudo-Labeling

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_opXROpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Multi-level Pseudo-labeled Latent Visual Reasoning (MP-LVR) to improve latent visual reasoning without intermediate annotations or external teacher models. The method constructs multi-level pseudo-labels from the model’s internal query-relevant attention patterns. It adaptively selects layers with different attention concentrations to provide distinct supervision for latent tokens. The authors also introduce Stochastic Information-Path Suppression (SIPS) to encourage answer generation to rely on latent tokens rather than directly accessing image and query tokens. Experiments across multiple visual reasoning and hallucination benchmarks show improvements over existing methods. Further analyses suggest that the learned latent tokens capture complementary visual information and contribute to answer generation.

Critical strengths
  1. The proposed multi-level pseudo-labeling strategy provides explicit supervision for latent visual reasoning without requiring intermediate annotations or external teacher models. Unlike existing methods that rely on bounding boxes, segmentation masks, or teacher representations, MP-LVR constructs supervision signals directly from the pretrained LVLM’s internal attention patterns. This reduces the dependence on additional annotations and auxiliary models.
  2. The adaptive layer selection strategy provides differentiated supervision for individual latent tokens. The method measures query-relevance concentration using normalized attention entropy and applies farthest point sampling to select layers with diverse concentration levels. It then constructs pseudo-labels by weighting image hidden states using the selected attention distributions. This design encourages latent tokens to capture visual information at different granularities rather than learning redundant representations.
  3. Stochastic Information-Path Suppression (SIPS) explicitly encourages the model to utilize latent tokens during answer generation. Instead of completely blocking access to image and query tokens, SIPS introduces stochastic negative biases to the corresponding attention logits during training. This design weakens direct information pathways while preserving access to the original inputs. It also allows latent supervision and answer prediction to be optimized within a single-stage training framework.
Critical weaknesses
  1. MP-LVR achieves only marginal improvements over existing annotation-free LVR methods. In Table 1, MP-LVR achieves an average score of 73.44, compared with 72.52 for CrystaL and 71.96 for LIVR. The improvements are less than 1.5 percentage points. Moreover, MP-LVR underperforms CrystaL on CV-Bench-2D and LIVR on BLINK and RealWorldQA. Similar trends are observed on Qwen2.5-VL-3B and Gemma3-4B, where the improvements over the strongest baselines are less than 1 percentage point. These relatively small gains make it difficult to justify the additional complexity introduced by the proposed framework.
  2. The contribution of multi-level pseudo-labeling is relatively small compared with information-path suppression. According to Table 3, standard SFT achieves an average score of 70.72. Single-level pseudo-labeling slightly decreases performance to 70.63, while multi-level pseudo-labeling improves it to only 70.85. Adaptive pseudo-labeling further increases the score to 71.31. In comparison, introducing image/query-path suppression increases performance to 72.03. More importantly, the paper does not evaluate SIPS independently without pseudo-label supervision. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the proposed multi-level supervision is necessary or whether similar improvements could be achieved through SIPS alone.
  3. The relationship between attention concentration and visual reasoning granularity is not rigorously established. MP-LVR uses normalized attention entropy to measure concentration and selects layers with different concentration levels to construct pseudo-labels. However, attention concentration only reflects the spatial distribution of attention weights. It does not necessarily indicate whether a layer captures coarse-grained context, fine-grained details, or complementary semantic information. Figures 3 and 5 provide qualitative visualizations, but no quantitative evidence establishes this relationship. Comparisons with alternative selection criteria, such as attention-map similarity or hidden-state diversity, are missing.
Questions for authors

See weakness

Reviewer_JcpUOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes MP-LVR, aiming to provide explicit supervision for latent tokens in visual reasoning without relying on external intermediate annotations or auxiliary teacher models. Specifically, the method first leverages layer-wise attention distributions within the model to construct pseudo-labels, guiding individual latent tokens to capture visual information; it then employs Stochastic Information-Path Suppression (SIPS) to weaken the answer tokens' direct attention to the original image and query tokens, thereby encouraging the model to utilize the latent tokens. Experiments across multiple visual reasoning benchmarks and three model backbones demonstrate consistent performance improvements.

Critical strengths

1.Clear research motivation. The paper directly addresses two critical issues in existing latent visual reasoning methods: the lack of effective supervision for latent tokens and the tendency for these tokens to be bypassed during answer generation.

2.Reasonable method design. Constructing supervision signals from layer-wise attention patterns while projecting them into a shared feature space at a fixed target layer is intuitive and well-structured.

Critical weaknesses

W1.Marginal performance gains and insufficient statistical support for some claims. In Table 1, MP-LVR achieves an overall average score of 73.44, outperforming CrystaL (72.52) by only 0.92 points. When considering only the five visual reasoning benchmarks, the improvement over standard SFT is merely 0.89 points. Moreover, the ablation studies in Table 3 and Table 5 do not report variance or standard deviations across multiple runs, making it difficult to assess whether these relatively small margins are statistically significant.

W2.The necessity of adaptive layer selection is not convincingly justified. In Table 5, the Adaptive strategy achieves an average score of 72.03, whereas the fixed Reverse and Forward schedules reach 71.74 and 71.58, respectively—a very narrow gap. While this suggests that supervising latent tokens with diverse layers is beneficial, it does not sufficiently prove that sample-wise adaptive selection based on attention concentration is meaningfully superior to simple fixed schedules. Additionally, the Random strategy drops drastically to 29.33 on CVB3D, far below other strategies, and this anomalous degradation lacks explanation.

Questions for authors

1.Given the narrow margin between the Adaptive strategy and fixed layer schedules in Table 5, could the authors provide multi-seed results (mean and standard deviation) for Table 5, and explain why the Random strategy suffers a severe performance collapse on CVB3D?

2.Could the authors further validate the relationship between attention concentration and the quality of visual information? For instance, could you provide visualizations or statistics of the attention distributions before and after calibration, and quantitatively analyze whether the pseudo-labels constructed from different layers are genuinely distinct and complementary?

3.In Table 4, performance drops to nearly zero when answer-to-latent attention is masked. Could the authors clarify what the model actually outputs under this setting? Furthermore, have you tried a cross-sample intervention—replacing the latent hidden states of one sample with those of another—to verify whether the latent tokens truly carry task-specific visual information that causally determines the final answer?

Reviewer_vt82OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes MP-LVR, a method that supervises latent visual reasoning tokens without intermediate annotations or external teachers. They extract attention weights from different layers to pool the 21st layer's hidden states as latent tokens. On Qwen2.5-VL-7B, MP-LVR outperforms SFT, LIVR and CrystaL on seven benchmarks, with smaller gains on Qwen2.5-VL-3B and Gemma3-4B.

Critical strengths
  1. Annotation-free and teacher-free latent supervision that is cheap to train. The bbox data needed for original LVR training is costly.
  2. Controlled comparison with SFT, LIVR, and CrystaL using the same training data, with results over 3 seeds.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Gains are within noise: +0.9 over CrystaL, while SFT’s standard deviation is ±1.9. The ablations are single runs, and gains on the 3B and Gemma models are below 1 point.
  2. The reliance claims are unsupported. Masking answer-to-latent attention drops accuracy to 0.06, well below chance, which points to model breakdown rather than information flowing through the latents. The pseudo-label is itself attention-pooled image features that the latents could compute on their own, so it is unclear what information the latents add.
Questions for authors
  1. What happens if swapping latents across samples?
  2. What happens if SIPS is also applied at inference, given that it is used only during training?
  3. Are the pseudo-labels computed from the frozen base model or from the current model being trained? If the latter, how do you prevent target drift?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.