- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The work focuses on spatio-temporal super-resolution for weather forecasting using re-analysis dataset at different resolutions. They proposed a generative model trained on paired grid-coarsened data of six-hourly observations and fine-grid data at hourly of and three-hourly resolution. Their method is presented as an extension of Conditional Flow Matching and Adaptive Flow Matching for weather forecast tasks. In the paper, they present the importance of the super-resolution tasks being modelled in both axes: temporal and spatial, proposing a method that addresses both problems jointly. The authors highlights its contribution to the baseline by including a better informant and guidance encoding, wind-guided local operators, modelling a complementary weather source, and a residual mixer model. Experiments are validated on different resolutions according to the different datasets East Asian ERA 5, ERA5-CERRA and CERRA, for which they report the CRPS and relative gain percentage performance from each baseline.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
Summary of concerns
The paper reads as preliminary work. It is hard to follow, and I have several major concerns about the experiments and the clarity of the method.
Experiments
Missing baselines and references. Besides the extended CFM and AFM variants, the paper should compare against additional baselines. PISR (Xu et al., 2026b) is already cited in the related work and addresses both the spatial and temporal aspects of the problem, so it should also appear in the experiments. Other relevant works include:
- A generative framework for probabilistic, spatiotemporally coherent downscaling of climate simulations (Schmidt et al., 2024), which should be included as a baseline.
- FlowConGRU (Hader et al.), which should also be included as a baseline.
- Fourier Neural Operators for arbitrary-resolution climate data downscaling (Yang et al., 2023), which also addresses the spatiotemporal setting on ERA5 and should therefore be discussed in the related work and included as a baseline.
The related work should also cover physics-aware (hybrid/grey-box) models for climate and weather, such as Neural General Circulation Models (Kochkov et al., 2023) and Variational Grey-Box Dynamics Matching (Singh et al., 2026), in addition to the already cited ClimPhyDM from the same author.
Evaluation. The evaluation relies mostly on CRPS and compares against only two baselines, which falls short of a standard climate/weather evaluation protocol. At a minimum, I would expect:
- Deterministic forecast skill (latitude-weighted RMSE and Anomaly Correlation Coefficient) across multiple lead times, with climatology and persistence as reference forecasts.
- Spectral analysis, such as power spectra or spectral power ratios.
- Spread-to-skill ratio alongside CRPS, to assess the ensemble variance and calibration.
- Evaluation on extreme events, to assess generalization out of distribution.
Clarity of the paper
The introduction and the application task are relevant and well motivated. However, after the introduction the paper becomes hard to follow, and the method section has several technical problems. The notation is often undefined or introduced without explanation, and it is heavier than necessary. Examples:
- In Eq. (2), the quantities are not defined, and it is unclear what they represent or how they differ.
- is introduced but later defined as an identity matrix, which makes the notation redundant, and is never defined.
- (Eq. 3) is not defined anywhere in the paper.
More importantly, it is unclear which functions are learned and which are fixed. It is also unclear whether time and spatial coordinates are inputs to the learned model and, if so, how they are encoded.
The contributions are hard to identify from the method as presented. The background on AFM, the most relevant prior work, is not presented clearly, which makes it difficult to see what the paper extends from it and what is new.
Questions for authors
The work should require a substantial amount of work adressing the points remarked in the critical weakness:
- Improve the submitted text and method clarity
- Include the new baselines asked
- Extend the evaluation pipeline to include all the metrics required to assess the weather forecast model