1.The central physiological interpretation is not sufficiently validated.
The paper treats each motif as a coordinate with a fixed region–frequency meaning. However, the spatial and spectral terms in Equation (3) are soft biases, the queries contain free parameters, and the final activations are produced by trainable functions supervised through emotion labels. A coordinate can therefore encode discriminative information that is not specific to its designated region or frequency band.
The randomized-mapping comparison in Table 1 supports the predictive usefulness of the physiological prior, while the attention-redundancy results in Table 5 support differentiated evidence assignment. Neither directly validates the physiological semantics of individual coordinates. Similarly, the interventions in Equation (6) precisely measure a scalar’s contribution to the prediction, but do not independently establish its physiological meaning. This gap affects the paper’s central contribution: whether the learned representation provides a reliably interpretable physiological coordinate system.
2.The source of the cross-model geometric correspondence remains insufficiently controlled.
Both LaBraM and REVE motif representations are trained using the same emotion labels and downstream objectives, and both receive spectral information computed directly from the EEG. The high correlations in Table 3 may therefore reflect the combined influence of shared supervision, shared spectral information, and the downstream mapping. The geometry computed directly from raw band-power features is not a supervision-matched control. The disagreement of CBraMod establishes that the shared procedure does not inevitably produce agreement, but does not isolate the factors responsible for the LaBraM–REVE result.
Moreover, pairwise distances and centroid angles are invariant to coordinate permutations. These metrics can consequently agree even when identically named motifs do not have corresponding physiological meanings across models. The current evidence does not sufficiently establish the specific value of the proposed physiological coordinates over an equally supervised generic representation or a learned spectral representation for cross-model comparison.
3.The main positive findings lack adequate stability and uncertainty analyses.
The headline geometric result is based on five emotion categories in the in-house dataset, yielding ten pairwise distances. The exact emotion-identity permutation tests and multiple-comparison correction support the statistical significance of the correspondence between the estimated geometries. However, they do not characterize uncertainty from participant and stimulus sampling or from downstream training randomness. Figures 4 and Table 4 examine fold-wise variability only for CBraMod; equivalent analyses are not reported for the central positive LaBraM–REVE finding.
In addition, the accuracy advantages of structured over randomized motifs in Table 1 range from 0.4 to 3.6 percentage points, with several small differences. Variability across random mappings and training seeds is not reported. It is therefore difficult to assess the reproducibility of both the physiological-mapping advantage and the principal geometric finding.
4.Essential implementation and evaluation details are missing.
Several choices that directly determine the results are not sufficiently specified, including the motif activation function, the precise intervention losses and their weights, the recurrent-motif selection rule, and the construction of randomized mappings. EEG preprocessing, feature-window settings, and the exact evaluation splits for SEED and SEED-IV also require further detail.
These omissions prevent a clear assessment of whether the randomized control changes only the intended physiological correspondence while preserving available information and structural complexity. They also leave unclear how activations from independently trained outer-fold motif heads are normalized and combined into a common geometry. Because the main cross-model finding additionally relies on an incompletely described in-house dataset, independent verification is difficult.