- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Neuro-HGLN, a hierarchical graph–Transformer framework for EEG-based emotion recognition. The method consists of two complementary streams. The global stream combines a spatial Euclidean prior derived from electrode positions with a learnable adjacency matrix to capture global dependencies. The local stream constructs multiple attention-based graphs, processes them through parallel GCNs, and employs an iTransformer encoder to model cross-electrode interactions. Geometric consistency and functional diversity regularization are introduced to guide graph learning, and predictions from the two streams are combined through late fusion.
Experiments on SEED, SEED-IV, SEED-V, and MPED report improvements over the selected baselines under both subject-dependent and subject-independent evaluation protocols. Ablation studies and topology visualizations are provided to support the effectiveness of the proposed components.
Critical strengths
The paper presents a coherent dual-stream architecture that combines global graph learning with multiple attention-based graph representations. The joint modeling of global and potentially specialized connectivity patterns is well motivated for EEG emotion recognition and provides a useful architectural direction.
The method achieves competitive results on four EEG emotion recognition benchmarks, including improvements under leave-one-subject-out evaluation. The ablation experiments also suggest that the two streams contribute complementary information to the classification task. These results provide some empirical support for the proposed architecture.
Critical weaknesses
Although the method emphasizes region-level local topology learning, each local graph is defined as a full electrode-to-electrode adjacency matrix without explicit regional constraints. The functional diversity regularization discourages overlapping connections but does not necessarily enforce spatial localization or anatomically meaningful specialization.
Furthermore, the unconstrained learnable projections and biases in the graph construction can substantially transform, or potentially bypass, the spatial prior. Consequently, it remains unclear whether the resulting representations genuinely exploit anatomical topology or primarily benefit from increased model capacity.
The empirical comparisons rely on a relatively limited set of baselines, and several important controlled comparisons are missing. In particular, the paper does not establish the contribution of the actual electrode-distance prior against randomized or shuffled topologies, nor does it isolate the benefit of the iTransformer relative to conventional self-attention architectures.
Questions for authors
Since the proposed local graphs are full adjacency matrices over all electrodes, what mechanism ensures that they learn spatially localized or anatomically meaningful regions? How are the individual attention heads associated with the specific brain regions shown in Figure 2? Could the authors provide quantitative evidence of regional specialization?
Could the authors clarify the discrepancy between Table 1 and Table 3 regarding the average SEED-IV accuracy? Are these results obtained under identical protocols?
2 comments
Thanks for the authors' response. I will maintain my original score.
Thank you for your constructive review and for recognizing the motivation of our dual-stream architecture and the complementary contributions of its components. Your comments identify useful directions for clarifying the role of spatial priors, evaluating regional specialization, and strengthening controlled comparisons. We have improved implementation reproducibility and are conducting additional SEED-IV cross-session experiments. Below, we address your concerns point by point. W1 / Q1 — Local Graphs, Regional Specialization, and Figure 2 The full N×N graph is an intentional design that preserves flexible connectivity across all electrodes. Our diversity regularization encourages different attention heads to learn distinct connectivity patterns, rather than enforcing fixed anatomical partitions. To further enhance spatial localization, we are currently exploring a spatial masking strategy that introduces explicit regional constraints into graph learning. Regarding Figure 2, the displayed patterns were selected from multiple training runs and underwent additional visualization processing. The anatomical labels were assigned descriptively based on the observed patterns, rather than through predefined regional supervision. We will clarify this distinction and further investigate quantitative measures of regional specialization. W2 — Contribution of the Spatial Prior Distance-based spatial priors have been widely adopted and validated in previous EEG graph-learning studies. Our framework builds upon this established approach while introducing learnable projections to capture task-relevant connectivity patterns. Importantly, the geometric consistency loss explicitly penalizes deviations between the learned graph and the distance-based prior, ensuring that anatomical information remains an active constraint throughout training rather than merely serving as initialization. Our ablation results further support the effectiveness of this geometric regularization. We will clarify this mechanism and its relationship to prior work in the revised manuscript. W3 — Baseline coverage and the contribution of iTransformer Our existing comparisons emphasize methods closely related to EEG connectivity modeling. We plan to broaden this evaluation with representative recent Transformer-based approaches under matched data and evaluation settings. Within our framework, iTransformer applies standard self-attention across head-specific graph representations after electrode-level GCN processing. The architectural choice concerns the representations used as tokens and the level at which their interactions are modeled. To examine this choice, we plan to compare graph-token attention with electrode-token self-attention using the same underlying GCN features and comparable encoder capacity. We will also include concatenation-based fusion without an attention encoder. These comparisons will distinguish the contribution of attention-based integration from that of organizing interactions across graph representations. We will make the token definitions and tensor dimensions explicit in the revised manuscript. Q2 — SEED-IV Averages in Tables 1 and 3 Thank you for pointing out this error. The discrepancy is due to a typographical error in Table 3. The correct average SEED-IV accuracy is 84.14%, calculated from the three cross-session results (82.23%, 84.74%, and 85.45%) reported in Table 1, rather than the incorrectly reported 85.14%. Both tables follow the same evaluation protocol. We apologize for this oversight and will correct it in the revised manuscript.