- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes CPDcd, a change detection network meant to tell real ground change apart from differences in lighting and atmosphere between the two dates. Starting from a simple model of how sunlight reaches the sensor, it splits the features of each image into three maps meant to stand for illumination, atmospheric transmittance and surface reflectance, and predicts change mainly from how the reflectance map differs between the dates. Extra losses keep the three maps apart, keep the illumination and atmosphere maps smooth, ask the maps to rebuild the input image, and discourage the illumination and atmosphere maps from predicting change on their own. A causal graph is used to argue that this removes spurious cues from lighting and haze. The method reports F1 of 90.33 on LEVIR-CD, 69.38 on SECOND and 80.11 on SYSU-CD, ahead of eight retrained baselines.
Critical strengths
The problem is real. Pseudo-change from illumination, haze and seasonal radiometry causes a large share of false alarms in bi-temporal imagery, and putting an explicit multiplicative image model into the loss is a cheap and readable way to go after it. If the three maps behaved as named, and would also be useful diagnostics in their own right. It counts in my assessment only as framing, though.
Critical weaknesses
-
The three maps are not shown to be physical, and the robustness claim is never tested. The inputs are 8-bit RGB products, not calibrated radiance, and the maps are linear projections of encoder features with no sun or atmosphere input. The reflectance map is trained through the change labels, and in Figure 8 it looks like a building mask. Path radiance, the term through which haze mostly shows up in visible bands, is dropped after Eq. 4. Why drop the one term that carries haze? Section 4.4 does not help. Narrow histograms (Fig. 4) are what the smoothness loss produces anyway, a transmittance of 0.2 to 0.33 would mean heavy haze, the ENVI curves in Figure 6 cover about 1.5 to 2.75 µm instead of visible light, and all 36 values in Figure 5 are multiples of 1/255, as if read from an 8-bit image. Most important, there is no test under lighting or haze change (perturbed test pairs, a seasonal subset, cross-dataset transfer) and no component ablation, since Table 2 only sweeps loss weights. Whether the physics branch adds anything over the encoder and difference U-Net is therefore unknown. Retinex-style decomposition (Wei et al., BMVC 2018), the closest prior idea, is not discussed.
-
The comparison does not support the state-of-the-art claim. BIT and ChangeFormer get 80.01 and 84.40 F1 on LEVIR-CD in Table 1, against 89.31 and 90.40 in their own papers on the standard 256$\times$256 split, so if that split was used, CPDcd at 90.33 is below the published ChangeFormer number. Table 1 is also internally inconsistent. ChangeFormer on SECOND lists F1 66.79 with P 74.61 and Re 50.58, which give 60.29. The setting comes from Table 2, whose selected row reproduces the Table 1 LEVIR-CD test numbers to the second decimal, so Table 2 reports test results and nothing indicates that was chosen on a validation split. The top three settings are within 0.02 F1 of each other anyway.
Questions for authors
- Which encoder, crop size and train, val and test split did you use for each dataset, and how was SECOND binarized?
- Which output is the final change map? The conclusion mentions adaptive fusion of a reflectance branch and a semantic branch, but Section 3 never defines it. Fig. 2(c) draws from the U-Net row and labels that row and , the reverse of Eq. 14, and Eqs. 16 to 18 never supervise with directly.
- Focal loss is unbounded as the true-class probability goes to zero, so the two negative terms in Eq. 16 can be driven to minus infinity by making and confidently wrong. How is kept bounded? A prediction that is confidently wrong also still carries the change information.
- Where do the Figure 5 values come from, and which box is which class?
- Can you add a stress test, for example gamma, brightness and haze applied to one date of the LEVIR-CD test pairs, with false alarm rates for CPDcd and for the same backbone without the decomposition?