- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a novel method to decompose a mixture of infrared spectra.
Critical strengths
The proposed method is interesting, addressing a difficult problem at the intersection of machine learning and chemistry. The paper is relatively well written, and the appendix provides several significant materials, including background material on infrared spectroscopy, allowing ML researchers to better understand the underlying problem.
Critical weaknesses
The proposed method is compared to 4 other methods. The challenging ones are the DeepCID for Raman spectra mixtures proposed by Fan et al. (2019) and the NNLS, which is the classical non-negative least squares (NNLS) recently explored on liquid-phase mixtures by Melle et al. (2026). It would have been relevant to explore related methods that are closely connected to the problem at hand. Comparing to methods that are designed to address Raman spectra mixtures or liquid-phase mixtures is not fair and misleading.
It is not clear which variant of the NNLS is used in the submitted paper, considering that several variants were studied by Melle et al. (2026) for liquid-phase mixtures. As given in (39) in Appendix B, it seems that the unregularized variant is used. However, Melle et al. (2026) have shown that the regularized variant outperforms other variants.
The proposed method relies on too many hyperparameters to be tuned by the user, including the many tradeoff parameters called such as comp, slot, mix, z, p, … The ablation studies nullify some of them, but it is not clear how all of them are fine-tuned.
At the end, it seems that the proposed method is fine-tuned to provide high performance, while compared methods are off-the-shelf. Moreover, compared methods often have fewer hyperparameters to tune.
Questions for authors
none