- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work presents MIRA for molecular mixture property prediction. Unlike previous work that relies on fully black-box prediction, MIRA decomposes the prediction into three complementary pathways corresponding to individual components, pairwise interactions, and the mixture as a whole, which potentially improves the interpretability of its predictions. On 11 CheMixHub tasks, MIRA achieves state-of-the-art performance, and the ablation studies further validate the distinct and complementary pathway behaviors across different properties.
Critical strengths
- The experimental section is comprehensive and thorough. Through benchmarking against baseline methods and extensive ablation studies, the results largely demonstrate the superior performance of MIRA on molecular mixture property prediction and help explain the different roles played by the three individual modules for different target properties.
Critical weaknesses
- The main novelty of this work, namely the explicit modeling of the contributions from different components using three separate modules, still lacks sufficient justification. From a methodological perspective, supervision is applied only to the final aggregated prediction, while the outputs of the individual modules are essentially unsupervised. Under this setting, explicit modeling does not necessarily offer an advantage over implicit modeling, much like how hand-crafted feature engineering has largely been replaced by transformer-based representations. Therefore, although the model demonstrates strong empirical performance, I am not convinced that the proposed method provides substantial insight into the task itself.
- The readability of the paper could still be improved. (i) There are several minor errors and formatting inconsistencies. For example, the last row under Density in Table 1 is missing a closing parenthesis, and Table 4 uses inconsistent numbers of decimal places when reporting the results. (ii) In Section 4.4, the experimental settings and objectives of the individual ablation studies are not described clearly, which makes this section considerably difficult to follow.
Questions for authors
- Since the training objective only supervises the final prediction obtained by combining the outputs of all three pathways, the individual pathway outputs are essentially unsupervised. This raises a major concern about whether explicit modeling of these pathways is necessary. Could the authors provide additional clarification or experiments to verify that the outputs of the individual components are indeed physically interpretable?
- Both the Pairwise Correction and Whole-mixture Correction appear to consider only interactions between pairs of components. Is it possible that interactions involving three or more components exist and cannot be captured by such pairwise modeling? If so, would this introduce a systematic limitation in MIRA's formulation? The authors are encouraged to provide the necessary clarification or correct my understanding if this concern is unfounded.
- In Section 4.5, MIRA's generalization ability is evaluated only on novel combinations of molecules that were individually observed during training, rather than on mixtures containing previously unseen molecules. Since MIRA is built upon a shared pretrained CheMeleon encoder, it should in principle be able to make predictions for systems containing molecules that were not observed during training. Could the authors include additional experiments on mixtures containing unseen molecules to further evaluate the generalization ability of MIRA?
- Could the authors provide a comparison with the baselines in terms of model size (e.g., number of parameters) and the runtime required for evaluation?
- Could the authors provide an anonymous code repository or include the implementation in the supplementary materials? This would help improve the reproducibility of the work.
6 comments
Question 1
Could the authors provide additional clarification or experiments to verify that the outputs of the individual components are indeed physically interpretable?
Reply 1
We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We analyzed how the fitted models use the three pathways and compared their outputs with physical reference data. The component pathway tracks the composition-weighted pure-liquid reference, the pairwise pathway helps predict symmetric deviations from it, and the whole-mixture pathway captures part of the composition asymmetry. Our reply to the first point of Weakness 1 explains the rationale for explicit modeling.
1. Pathway allocation in fitted models
Without separate physical labels, pathway outputs represent predictive attributions. Across independently fitted models, the dominant pathway agrees on 15/20 mixing-enthalpy systems, 16/20 NIST-small viscosity systems, and 17/20 surface-tension systems (Rebuttal Table 7). The component pathway has the largest magnitude for NIST-small viscosity, and the two correction pathways dominate for mixing enthalpy. For mixing enthalpy and NIST-small viscosity, replacing the largest-magnitude pathway output with its training-fold mean in the frozen model caused the largest test MAE increase (Rebuttal Table 8).
Rebuttal Table 7. Relative Pathway Magnitudes and Dominant-Pathway Agreement
| Property | Component | Pairwise | Whole-mixture | Agreement |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mixing enthalpy | 12.0% | 30.1% | 57.9% | 15/20 |
| NIST-small viscosity | 58.3% | 13.1% | 28.6% | 16/20 |
| Surface tension | 37.6% | 10.6% | 51.8% | 17/20 |
Rebuttal Table 8. Test MAE Increase under Frozen Pathway Mean Replacement
| Property | Component | Pairwise | Whole-mixture |
|---|---|---|---|
| IL conductivity | +0.218 | +0.125 | +1.901 |
| IL viscosity | +0.895 | +0.214 | +0.745 |
| NIST-small viscosity | +0.201 | +0.026 | +0.076 |
| Mixing enthalpy | +0.007 | +0.128 | +0.293 |
2. Component pathway
For 1,593 viscosity measurements from 188 held-out binary systems, we constructed a composition-weighted reference from the two pure-liquid log viscosities measured at the same temperature. For mole fraction of B,
The component output correlated with this reference (), supporting its role as a composition-linear starting point. The full model fit the measured pure-liquid viscosities more accurately than the component pathway alone (MAE 0.0273 vs. 0.1526).
3. Pairwise pathway
We illustrate the pairwise pathway using methanol (A) and dimethyl carbonate (B) at 307.15 K. The measured deviation is . We average the deviations at complementary compositions as . For predicted deviations, the reference uses the model’s pure-liquid predictions.
Rebuttal Table 9. Symmetric Log-Viscosity Deviations with Fixed and Composition-Dependent Pairwise Outputs
| A:B compositions | Original pairwise output | Fixed at mean | Measured average deviation | Prediction (fixed) | Prediction (original) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90:10 and 10:90 | +0.00074 | +0.00740 | −0.02725 | −0.01788 | −0.02453 |
| 80:20 and 20:80 | +0.00525 | +0.00740 | −0.03940 | −0.03475 | −0.03690 |
| 70:30 and 30:70 | +0.01016 | +0.00740 | −0.04635 | −0.04784 | −0.04507 |
| 60:40 and 40:60 | +0.01344 | +0.00740 | −0.04855 | −0.05650 | −0.05045 |
With model weights and other outputs fixed, restoring the original pairwise output preserved the mean prediction and lowered absolute error at all four composition pairs (0.00586 to 0.00210 overall). Across 167 held-out NIST-small binary systems, it reduced curve-shape MAE by 30.6% after subtracting each curve’s own mean. The pairwise pathway helps MIRA capture composition-dependent symmetric deviations.
4. Whole-mixture pathway
We used molecular-dynamics mixing enthalpies for 716 held-out binary systems from CheMixHub Miscible Solvents. At each composition, we subtracted the linear interpolation between the model’s two pure-component predictions. With the fitted model fixed, including the pairwise term lowered MAE at all four compositions (20:80, 80:20, 40:60, and 60:40) and for the averages over complementary compositions (0.294 to 0.205 kJ/mol).
When the proportions are reversed, and stay the same. The pairwise term therefore cancels in the difference between the two adjusted predictions, leaving only the change in the whole-mixture term. For each complementary pair, we compared this predicted change with the difference between the two reference mixing enthalpies. The resulting MAE was 0.278 kJ/mol, compared with 0.386 kJ/mol for a baseline predicting zero change. This shows that the whole-mixture term captures part of the composition asymmetry.
I thank the authors for their rebuttal. While their responses have addressed some of my concerns, the following issues remain unresolved:
-
My primary concern, as stated in Weakness 1, is that the proposed explicit decomposition of component contributions may be unnecessary, as implicit modeling could already be sufficient. The additional experiments provided in Reply 1, in fact, seem to further support my concern. Across all four properties, the proposed explicit modeling approach achieves only marginal and statistically unsubstantiated improvements in MAE over the feature fusion baseline, which could simply be attributed to random variation or insufficient training. This fundamentally challenges the central motivation and necessity of the proposed method.
-
Perhaps due to an oversight, I could not find the authors' responses to Questions 2–5.
In summary, although the paper is clearly structured and the experiments are relatively comprehensive, I find its motivation insufficiently justified and lacking in novelty. The proposed approach offers limited new insights into the field and, in my view, does not meet the standards of ICLR. Therefore, I remain inclined to recommend rejection.
Weaknesses 1
Reply 1
We thank the reviewer for raising this point. Supervising only the summed prediction leaves the individual pathway outputs underdetermined. Explicit decomposition makes each additive output directly observable and lets us test how the fitted model relies on it by replacing that output while holding the rest of the model fixed.
To assess the accuracy trade-off, we compared MIRA with a feature-fusion baseline using the same inputs and encoder architecture across five matched folds (Rebuttal Table 6). Explicit decomposition achieved lower mean test MAE on all four properties, with reductions of approximately 0.5%-3.0% relative to feature fusion. It achieved lower MAE on four of five folds for mixing enthalpy and Polymer-MW, three of five for NIST-small viscosity, and all five for IL viscosity. As described in the reply to question 1, we used the separate outputs to examine which pathways the model relies on for different properties and how their predictions relate to measurable mixture behavior.
Rebuttal Table 6: Explicit Decomposition vs. Feature Fusion (Test MAE ↓)
Weaknesses 2
Reply 2
Thank you for catching these presentation details. In the revised manuscript, we will fix the missing closing parenthesis in Main Paper Table 1, standardize decimal precision across Main Paper Table 4 (and all other tables), and carefully proofread the entire text. Additionally, we will restructure Section 4.4 by explicitly stating the objective, experimental setup (retrained models vs. frozen-model interventions), and key takeaway at the beginning of each subsection so that the diagnostic progression is easy to follow.