- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors address multivariate curve resolution (MCR), a classical problem in chemometrics that involves recovering component signals and their concentrations from measurements of mixtures. They also aim to reuse the recovered components to analyze new samples. Mathematically, each observed mixture signal is modeled as a weighted sum of component signals. The challenge is that both the component pool, including its size, and the corresponding weights may be unknown. The task is therefore to recover the shared component signals and their weights from multiple observed mixtures, and then infer the weights for new samples.
To achieve this, the authors introduce gMCR and theoretically investigate several questions: (1) Given the component pool, is the decomposition of a sample unique? (2) When the component pool is unknown, under what conditions can minimizing total component usage recover the true decomposition? (3) How does noise affect these recovery guarantees? The authors further propose EB-gMCR, a practical solver motivated by this formulation and theoretical analysis. Finally, experiments evaluate its ability to recover components, estimate their number, and reuse the learned pool to analyze new samples.
Critical strengths
- The method estimates the number of components automatically and reuses the learned components to analyze new mixtures.
- Experiments on synthetic and real data show that the method can recover meaningful component signals.
Critical weaknesses
1. Structural presentation problems. Although the manuscript provides background and explains some design choices, it lacks a clear narrative connecting the problem, the theoretical results, the solver, and the experiments. Definitions and theoretical statements often appear before their motivation and implications are sufficiently explained. This makes it difficult to understand why each result is needed and what the results collectively establish. Addressing these issues would require substantial reorganization and rewriting, rather than a few local clarifications.
2. Insufficient positioning and support for the technical contributions. The first two contribution statements are broad, while the differences from established sparse-representation and dictionary-identifiability results are insufficiently explained. The manuscript should distinguish established foundations from its new advances in assumptions, guarantees, or scope. Although the authors acknowledge limitations in applying the theory to the solver, the extent to which the guarantees support the implemented method remains unclear. The experiments demonstrate useful performance, but do not isolate the advantage of the energy-based gate over simpler alternatives. Appendix K.6 also shows that concentration thresholding substantially improves support recovery, leaving its practical selection and sensitivity important unresolved questions. Finally, Figure 2(c) evaluates reuse on synthesized mixtures rather than held-out real measurements, limiting the evidence for reuse under experimental variability.
Questions for authors
-
Which parts of Theorems 1 and 2 are new relative to the cited sparse-representation and dictionary-identifiability results, particularly Donoho & Elad (2003) and Garfinkle & Hillar (2019)? Please clarify the specific differences in assumptions, guarantees, and scope.
-
The manuscript acknowledges that the implemented usage-penalty schedule does not enforce the theoretical λ-window and that some recovery assumptions are unavailable in the experiments. Given these limitations, which guarantees can be established for the returned solutions, and which connections between the theory and the solver remain heuristic?
-
What additional benefit does the energy-based gate provide over a simpler gate that also separates component selection from concentration estimation? Do the existing ablations isolate this benefit?
-
Appendix K.6 reports substantially improved support recovery after concentration thresholding. How can this threshold be selected without knowing the true concentration scale or lower bound, and how sensitive is support recovery to this choice?
I appreciate the authors' efforts in addressing my concerns. After carefully reading the revised version, however, I do not think my major concerns have been adequately addressed.
I encourage the authors to thoroughly reconsider how to present the work to improve its readability. Readers are not proof-checking machines that can easily digest mathematical statements and proofs one by one and automatically fill in the gaps in the reasoning that the authors have not explicitly explained. I do not believe this is merely a matter of personal preference, as reviewer fcX8 expressed similar concerns about the presentation. As I mentioned in W1, I do not think these issues can be addressed simply by adding explanatory text. Substantial reorganization and rewriting may still be necessary. I therefore maintain my original rating.