- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BrainState, a cross-subject EEG decoding framework that integrates the convolutional mamba framework with a memory module. The training trials are organized into a hierarchical memory graph. A state-conditioned retrieval mechanism retrieves the evidence from poorly matched recording then adds them to the classifier through gated fusion.
Critical strengths
- The evaluation uses strict leave-one-subject-out splits with per-subject results.
- This paper explores an important problem in EEG decoding.
Critical weaknesses
- This paper does not compare with the latest brain foundation models, e.g., CBraMod[ICLR 2025], CSBrain [Neurips 2026], CodeBrain [ICLR 2026].
- The novelty of this paper is incremental by integrating a memory retrieval mechanism with CNN+Mamba. The motivation of this paper is also not clearly introduced.
- The paper claims to resolve eeg-to-language/brain-to-text decoding task. However, the authors only experiment on one dataset named TESSCCo, which involves five TV-control commands. So the task is actually a 5-class task. How does this method perform on more commonly-used text decoding datasets, such as ZuCo [1]?
- The performance is limited. The 5-class accuracy is 29.9%, only about 10 percentage points above chance (20%).
- The ablation study is conducted on only three of the 21 subjects. This makes the ablation results less reliable and insufficient to demonstrate the effectiveness of state-conditioned retrieval.
- The paper lacks qualitative analysis of the retrieval mechanism, for example which training sessions are retrieved for a held-out trial and whether they are actually close in recording state.
- The writing needs substantial improvement, and the paper is difficult to follow.
[1] ZuCo, a simultaneous EEG and eye-tracking resource for natural sentence reading, Scientific Data.
Questions for authors
Please see weaknesses.