- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose CurrDiT, a curriculum learning-based DiT model capable of dynamically adapting to varying degrees of degradation. Additionally, they developed a generative degradation synthesis pipeline tailored specifically for restoring faces in old photographs and constructed a dedicated benchmark, VintagePortraits, for evaluating naturally aged, authentic portrait photos. Extensive experiments demonstrate that this method offers advantages over existing approaches.
Critical strengths
- A generative degradation synthesis pipeline tailored specifically for restoring faces in old photos is valuable.
- The performance of this method appears to be superior to that of existing methods.
Critical weaknesses
- It is difficult to determine whether the performance improvement stems from the authors' design or from the use of a larger base model, given that this method employs a larger base model (FLUX-1) compared to the baseline methods. Therefore, the authors should compare their approach against the latest methods based on FLUX or on base models larger than FLUX—such as LucidFLUX (based on FLUX-1) and ODTSR (based on Qwen).
- As a method requiring supervised training rather than being training-free, it appears to offer no advantages in terms of inference speed or the total/trainable number of model parameters with existing training-based methods.
- There are too few methods for identity assessment; the scope should include all the methods listed in Table 1, as well as the newly added methods based on larger base model patterns.
- To my knowledge, SSDiff appears to inevitably alter the skin tone of the input face based on pseudo-label references; however, the SSDiff outputs shown in Figure 3 (using the authors' proposed dataset) do not exhibit any skin tone changes. Did the authors perhaps not use pseudo-labels? If that is the case, is the quantitative comparison with SSDiff presented in Table 1—based on the authors' proposed dataset—accurate?
- Architectural innovation is limited; it merely incorporates degradation awareness into the dual-stream framework, representing an incremental advancement.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses