acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Rig, Render, Refine: Agentic 3D Rigging through Iterative Feedback

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

We present an agent-based approach to 3D mesh rigging and animation that frames rigging as an iterative cycle of perception, construction, and verification. Existing methods typically predict skeletons and skinning weights directly from 3D geometry, but geometry alone may not determine how an object should articulate or whether a proposed rig will produce plausible deformations under motion. Our key idea is to inspect a rig’s behavior under articulation and use these observations to guide its refinement. Starting from a static mesh, we construct and iteratively refine a 3D skeleton by integrating multiview renderings, geometric structure, mesh-part information, and 2D skeleton proposals. We then generate skinning weights and evaluate the resulting rig under diagnostic poses, using observed deformation errors to refine both the weights and the skeleton. Experiments on a challenging dataset of structurally diverse 3D assets demonstrate improved skeleton and deformation accuracy over state-of-the-art rigging methods.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Agent-based rigging, skeleton generation, skinning refinement, animation-driven optimization.

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_MzpmOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents an agent-based pipeline for automatic skeleton construction and skinning. It combines geometric scaffolds and semantic interpretation with iterative skeleton editing and deformation-based feedback. Experiments on 50 curated assets compare the complete system with existing rigging methods and examine individual components.

Critical strengths

The problem is practically relevant. Rigging unconventional morphologies remains difficult for existing methods. The complete pipeline reports substantial improvements in both skeleton agreement and reference-fitted deformation.

The supplementary material provides useful technical detail. It describes the algorithms, evaluation protocols, additional comparisons, and remaining failures, while explicitly acknowledging several experimental limitations.

Critical weaknesses

The evaluation does not establish the contribution beyond stronger prompting, specialized tools, and additional compute. The zero-shot baseline receives a minimal instruction and cannot use existing pipeline skills, while ReRig-Agent receives a substantially more structured workflow. Generation compute is not matched. This establishes that the complete system outperforms a minimally instructed agent, but does not show which proposed mechanisms are necessary. Since the underlying agent can already perform rigging, a carefully prompted, tool-matched, budget-matched baseline is central to assessing the methodological contribution.

The component ablations provide limited causal and generalization evidence. The generated-guidance comparison also changes component selection and grouping, while diagnostic refinement includes structural edits. Furthermore, its strongest improvements are measured on development poses used during repair. Reference-motion ADE improves by only approximately 0.25%, although MDE improves by 6.81%, and CD slightly worsens. These results support some local corrections but do not establish broadly improved deformation on unseen motions.

Questions for authors

How does ReRig-Agent compare with the same agent given a carefully designed rigging prompt, access to the same tools, and an equal generation budget?

With tools and compute fixed, what improvement comes specifically from the structured diagnostic-feedback loop over generic render–inspect–revise instructions?

Does refinement improve deformation on independently selected, unseen motions, and how much comes from skeleton edits versus skinning updates?

Reviewer_BCTrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents ReRig-Agent, an agent-based system that builds and refines skeletons and skinning weights for static 3D meshes. It constructs the skeleton using multiview renderings, geometric cues, mesh-part information, and generated 2D skeleton proposals. Skinning weights are initialized using geometric and semantic constraints, then refined by inspecting the mesh under diagnostic poses and measuring deformation errors. Experiments on 50 structurally diverse assets show lower average skeleton and deformation errors than Puppeteer and RigAnything.

Critical strengths

The iterative agent-based rigging framework is reasonable and well motivated: combining visual reasoning with deformation feedback enables correction of skeleton and skinning errors that are difficult to identify from the input mesh. In addition, agent-based rigging method can have better generalization than learning-based methods due to the broad prior knowledge and reasoning capabilities of modern agents.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Appendix F.1 provides a runtime breakdown and token accounting for one asset, reporting approximately 34 min. However, a single run does not establish typical computational cost, particularly because the skeleton reviews in this example required no edits. Dataset-wide runtime statistics and comparisons with Puppeteer and RigAnything would help assess the efficiency–quality trade-off and the additional cost of iterative refinement.

  2. The appendix provides initial v.s. refined skeleton comparisons and selected edit examples. However, I could not find a complete agent trajectory showing intermediate skeletons, proposed operations, validation results, and acceptance or rejection decisions across refinement rounds. End-to-end worked examples would help clarify how the agent identifies errors and how its successive actions produce the final improvement.

  3. It is unclear whether the refinement consistently improves deformation quality on unseen motions. As in Appendix E.3, the diagnostic results use poses employed during repair.

  4. Although the supplementary material provides additional visualizations (both rigging and animation using generated rigging), the qualitative results are still too limited. For a rigging paper, authors should provide enough visual comparison results for readers to assess the quality and improvement.

Minor weaknesses:

  1. In the abstract: “We present an agent-based approach to 3D mesh rigging and animation.” Since the paper primarily focuses on agentic rigging, I suggest revising this sentence to more accurately reflect the scope.

  2. In line 33, the discussion of previous work is not sufficient (only three references in the Introduction). Rignet cannot be listed as a recent work, which is published in 2020. You should also refer to some template-based methods here.

  3. The skeleton visualizations do not clearly identify the root joint or indicate parent–child relationships, making it difficult to assess the predicted skeletal hierarchy.

Overall, the proposed agent-based rigging is reasonable and well motivated. However, the experimental validation remains insufficient, and the presentation requires improvement before I can recommend acceptance.

Questions for authors
  1. Where is the user study mentioned in Section 4?

  2. Figure 6 combines a quantitative table with qualitative visualizations. Showing them as a separate table and figure would make the results easier to reference.

  3. Which VLM did you use in the paper?

Reviewer_B6ewOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses the problem of automatic rigging of 3D meshes through an iterative agentic process of skeleton construction, skinning, and deformation assessment. The proposed approach combines multiview renderings, medial geometry, mesh-part information, and generated 2D skeleton proposals to identify articulated parts and construct a skeleton. An agent reviews the resulting skeleton and proposes changes to joint placement and connectivity, which are executed and validated through geometric tools.

Skinning weights are initialized using interior distances and semantic part assignments. Diagnostic poses are then used to determine deformation defects, allowing the agent to revise bone influences and blending regions, or request further skeleton changes. Evaluation on 50 curated 50 rigged objects from Sketchfab, demonstrates improved skeleton and deformation accuracy over competing methods.

Critical strengths

The use of agentic systems for automated rigging is an interesting and timely direction. The observation that predicted rigs should be evaluated under different articulations is well motivated. Using deformation feedback to refine the skeleton and skinning weights offers a promising way to identify and correct errors that may arise from the initial generated rig.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The technical presentation is difficult to follow in places, as several central components are described at a high level without sufficient formulation or implementation detail. Although the appendix provides substantial information on individual operations, their connections within the overall pipeline remain unclear (see Questions). This makes it difficult to assess how the system operates and to reproduce the proposed method.

  2. The evaluation is restricted to an author-curated set of 50 rigged models from Sketchfab, with limited information about the selection criteria. While this collection targets uncommon morphologies, it provides limited evidence of performance across a broader range of assets. Evaluation on established rigging benchmarks, such as Anymate [1], Articulation-XL [2], and ModelsResource [3], using appropriate test splits, would strengthen the generalization claims and allow more direct comparison with existing methods.

[1] Deng, Yufan, et al. "Anymate: A dataset and baselines for learning 3d object rigging." Proceedings of the Special Interest Group on Computer Graphics and Interactive Techniques Conference Conference Papers. 2025. [2] Song, Chaoyue, et al. "Magicarticulate: Make your 3d models articulation-ready." 2025 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR). IEEE, 2025. [3] Zhan Xu, Yang Zhou, Evangelos Kalogerakis, Chris Landreth, and Karan Singh. Rignet: Neural rigging for articulated characters. ACM TOG, 39(4), 2020

Questions for authors
  1. How is the medial graph, which contains 3D coordinates and connectivity, represented and supplied to the agent? How does the agent use it to guide joint placement and connectivity?

  2. Have the authors evaluated off-the-shelf part segmentation as an alternative to groups derived from mesh connectivity or primitive boundaries? How are these groups presented to and reviewed by the agent, and what criteria determine whether a group requires separate articulation or should share skeletal controls with other mesh groups?

  3. How does the agent use the mesh-part decomposition to construct the semantic description H\mathcal{H}?

  4. How is the prompt q(H)q(\mathcal{H}) constructed from the semantic description? Does it follow a fixed template or is it generated by the agent? Please provide an example of H\mathcal{H} and its corresponding prompt.

  5. Could the authors provide the mathematical formulation of the bounded fitting procedure mentioned in lines 222–224? Please specify how reprojection agreement, medial-graph proximity, and soft interior constraints are combined.

  6. How are the diagnostic poses constructed, particularly the selection of joints, rotation axes, and motion ranges? Since these poses depend on the predicted skeleton, how does the system distinguish deformation artifacts caused by incorrect joint placement from those caused by skinning weights? What determines whether an observed defect triggers skeleton refinement or a weight update?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.