- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
BranchTokens studies skeleton serialization and inference-time candidate selection for mesh-conditioned autoregressive skeleton generation. Its branch-centric tokenizer applies BFS to a series-reduced tree, restores degree-two nodes within contiguous branches, and adds explicit branch delimiters; siblings are ordered by distance. At inference, it decodes six axis-aligned rotations, maps predictions back, and selects one skeleton using mesh coverage and joint-set consensus. On Articulation-XL2.0, CD-J2B is 1.687, versus 2.030 for the reported Auto-Connect baseline and 1.770 without TTA. Evaluation includes ModelsResource, diverse-pose, structural metrics, and a separately trained Anymate model. The backbone and next-token training objective remain standard.
Critical strengths
1.We presented BranchTokens, a skeleton generation framework built around two design choices:branch-centric tokenization and view-augmented generation. The author has proved the effectiveness of the method through numerous experiments.
2.The theoretical intuition of this paper is excellent, and the design of BCT is highly elegant, effectively introducing graph-theoretic properties into sequence generation. However, there are notable flaws in experimental rigor (specifically, the discrepancy in data size), and the TTA design appears somewhat cumbersome.
Critical weaknesses
1.This is the most critical flaw. The authors must clarify the discrepancy in dataset size (57k vs. 46k) in the rebuttal or revised manuscript to ensure a fair comparison.
2.As shown in Table 10, TTA has a nearly 6-fold increase in computational cost. The authors need to justify whether this significant computational overhead is warranted.
Questions for authors
1.The paper argues that Auto-Connect's BFS traversal "treats all nodes equally" and fails to capture distinct structural roles (junction, leaf, connection). However, Branch-Centric Tokenization (BCT) essentially only reorders the token sequence without altering the underlying model architecture. The authors should explicitly clarify in the Introduction: Why does this seemingly simple sequence reordering yield such significant performance gains?
2.The rationale behind the specific design choices in BCT needs further justification. Specifically, compared to a standard Depth-First Search (DFS) traversal—which also keeps branch nodes contiguous—what are the essential advantages of the proposed concatenation method and the introduction of the boundary token [E3] in preserving topological connectivity? What problems can they solve?
3.Due to the inconsistent orientation of the grids in the dataset, this paper employs six axial rotations for enhancement. However, random rotation augmentation has already been widely used during the training phase (as mentioned in Section 5.1 Implementation). Since the model has already encountered random rotations during training, does fixing the six viewing angles for rotation during testing really compensate for the orientation ambiguity?
4.Equation (6) employs negative exponential decay to calculate the distance from the grid surface points to the predicted bone segments. This measurement method is actually very similar to Chamfer Distance (CD). In this paper, CD is used as the evaluation metric, and a measurement highly correlated with the evaluation metric is adopted as the basis for selecting TTA. Is there any irrationality in this?
5.Table 10 shows that inference time increases from 1.0s without TTA to 5.8s with TTA. This represents a nearly 6-fold increase in computational cost for less than a 10% improvement in CD metrics (e.g., J2J decreases from 2.438 to 2.364). The authors are suggested to discuss the practical application scenarios and efficiency trade-offs of this method in the Introduction or Conclusion.
6.In Section 5, the authors describe an Articulation-XL2.0 dataset containing 57k samples, including the diverse-pose training split. However, the original paper of Auto-Connect reports 46k training samples in its Section 4.1 [1]. Please clarify the discrepancy between the reported sample sizes or add a comparison of absolute alignment with Auto-Connect on the 46k data.
7.The experiments cover Articulation-XL2.0, ModelsResource, the diverse-pose split, and Anymate (in the Appendix). However, the generalization capability in "in-the-wild" real-world scenarios is insufficiently supported, as it relies solely on qualitative demonstrations provided in the Supplementary Website.