- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a method to generate a realistic tree in 3D using Graph Neural network. Unlike other previous works, this work predicts topology and geometry at the same time. This work uses QSM reconstructions from BioDiv-3DTrees dataset to evaluate the performance. From unconditional neuronal morphonolgy generation, this methos shows 100% valid tree generations, and have four best scores out of five, in distributional agreement, compared to SemlaFlow and MorphoGen methods. Also, this method shows an unconditional generation performance as well. This also compared with SemlaFlow, MorphoGen and the proposed method has at least 14 times fewer parameters which use only 1.57 M parameters.
Critical strengths
- Introducing a new iterative 3D tree generation method that simulates the biological growth of real trees.
- This approach predicts topology and geometry at the same time unlike other previous works that are introduced in this paper.
Critical weaknesses
- Missing core tree related works including Space Colonization, Tree-D Fusion.
- The title and abstract show the major contribution of this paper is generating a realistic tree. But why it shows molecular generation for the validation?
- Line #18-#20, the authors claim that “simulating the biological growth of real trees”, yet the method is compared with QSM, which is non-deterministic reconstruction algorithm and this paper does not show any tree related metrics and validation such as DBH, the number of branches, branching angles, etc.
- From my view, the trees that are visualized in Figure 5, does not realistic as the paper claims in Line #18-#20. Also, in Figure 6, the trees in d_max=20, in the middle shows flat branches which look unrealistic.
Questions for authors
- The title says “Growing Trees” and other parts showing some neurons and trees. Which one is the main contribution of this paper?
- There are no tree specific evaluations in this paper. Why those are not included and why authors say Line#18-#20 that “simulating the biological growth of real trees”?
- How do you know the generated trees in Figure 5 and Figure 6 are realistic?
- One of the baselines, SemlaFlow, uses QM9 and GEOM dataset. Any reasons authors did not make comparisons using those datasets?
Summary of revisions and responses to reviewer concerns
We thank the reviewers for their constructive feedback. In response, we have substantially revised the manuscript with new experiments, analyses, and clarifications to explain the method and scope more clearly, and better illustrate our contribution.
Strengths
Changes in the revised paper
The main revisions are listed below:
Reviewer q8Q9
Reviewer 9WiE
Reviewer gpo9
As the discussion period is nearing its end, we would appreciate feedback on whether the changes and clarifications resolved the points raised, or which points remain outstanding.